Rejecting Rias Gremory x Male reader X Erza Scarlet

Reunion

Third-person P.O.V~

Akeno smiled as she lay on her bed and looked at a photo of Y/n, Erza, and little Rosemary while reading a letter aloud to herself.

Akeno:" Dear Akeno, I just wanted to say that I'm doing well and tell you that the delivery went great and now Erza and I have a little daughter. My precious bundle of joy's name is Rosemary Akeno L/n."

Akeno smiled that Y/n had partially named his daughter after her. Akeno then resumed reading the letter.

Akeno:" I gave her that name after one of the strongest and kindest women (second to only my wife) because I want her to be strong yet kind just like you, Akeno. Anyways I hope you're doing well and happy, Erza and I are struggling a little bit with the newborn, but otherwise, we're great. From Y/n L/n."

Akeno smiled before putting away with the other ones she had hidden from Rias and everyone else. Akeno then looked at the photo of Y/n and his family as she heard the door to her room open. Akeno turned to see Rias enter her room.

Rias:" Hey Akeno, I'm ordering some pizza; want any?"

Akeno:" Sure."

Rias then looked at the photo in Akeno's hand and spoke.

Rias:" What photo is that?"

Akeno quickly put the photo in the drawer with the rest as she spoke.

Akeno:" Nothing. Now come on, let's go get some pizza."

Akeno left the room, but Rias, being curious, opened the drawer and picked up a photo to see a selfie of Akeno and Y/n both smiling, making her scream out.

Rias:" What the fuck!!"

Akeno quickly entered the room and looked at Rias, whose eyes were still on the photo. Akeno gulped in worry as she spoke.

Akeno:" Listen, Rias, it's not what it looks like-."

Rias:" How long have you been hiding this from me!?"

Akeno gulped as Rias shouted out again.

Rias:" How long!?

Akeno looked down worriedly as she spoke.

Akeno:" Years..."

Rias's left eye twitched as her fists clenched and her magic focused around her.

Rias:" Take me to him."

Akeno:" What?"

Rias:" Take me to Y/n!"

Akeno:" Rias, I can't just take you to him-"

Rias:" Now, Akeno, that's an order!"

Akeno sighed as she spoke while looking down.

Akeno:" Yes madum President."

*Scene change*

Y/n smiled as he sat outside his and Erza's house, looking up at the clouds passing over him before he heard a familiar voice.

Akeno:" Um, hey Y/n?"

Y/n smiled as he heard his old friend's voice and looked at her only to see Rias beside her.

Y/n:" Akeno good to see- oh hello, Rias. What are you doing here?"

Rias smiled as she stepped closer and spoke.

Rias:" Y/n, it's lovely to see you."

Y/n:" Good to see you too, but you didn't answer my question. Why are you here?"

Rias:" I want to start over with you. As lovers this time, so what do you say?"

Y/n's eyes widened for a second before he spoke.

Y/n:" No."

Rias's eyes whitened as she spoke.

Rias:" What! Why not?"

Y/n smiled and held up his hand, showing his ring as he spoke.

Y/n:" I'm sorry, but I'm married, and I love my wife very much. So there's nothing you can do, but if you want to be friends again, I would love that."

Rias sighed as she shrugged and spoke.

Rias:" Sure. I would love that."

Y/n smiled as Rias and him shook hands. They talked for a bit before he entered his house to see Erza taking a nap on the couch with their daughter. Y/n joined the two of them, happy to be with one another.

.
.
..
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
*Epilogue*

Y/n smiled as he looked at his son Simon talking with Gajeel's daughter Gale as Erza sat next to him and spoke.

Erza:" How are you doing, dear?

Y/n:" Good, just looking at the kids."

Erza looked at the scene as she spoke.

Erza:" Oh, how cute."

Y/n smiled as he held Erza's hand. He loved his life so much he had a wonderful family, and he would go through all the pain he had before just to be with them again.