Reunited.. (Hayes Grier Fan Fiction)

Chapter Eleven

"We should play truth or dare." Cameron suggested. We all agreed.

"Sarah, truth or dare?" Nash asked first. Oh no. What do I expect?
"Truth." I said, but it came out sounding like a question.
"What do you think is your biggest physical flaw?" I sigh. Partially because I hate saying things like this and this is just an awkward topic to talk about with all guys.
"Oh god. Flaws?" I asked to no one in particular. I looked down at the floor as everyone was waiting for an answer. Hayes, who is still beside me, repositioned his body. "I have too many." I whispered, having my eyes get glossy without my permission. Everyone was silent, waiting for me to go in detail. "Do you really want me to go in detail? There might be some tears." I slightly chuckled, lifting my head.
"Yeah." Nash looked at me and the rest of the guys said the same thing. Hayes seemed like he really wanted to know. I sighed as I thought of where I could begin.
"Well. For as long as I can remember, I hated my body. Everything about it.  I was really young too, I tried everything to make me feel beautiful. Makeup, skinny clothes, hanging out with new people. Nothing. Even to this day, I feel like I have to many flaws." I cried as everyone was silent.
"I had no clue that's how you felt." Hayes whispered, opening his arms so I can hug him. Without a thought, I hugged him tightly as I cried in his embrace. "Sarah, no matter what. You will always be beautiful in my eyes." Hayes whispered, emphasizing the word always. My heart began to beat faster.
"We all think you're so beautiful." Cameron smiled as he stood up for a hug. I got up and met him halfway and we hugged. Everyone then got up too and got me in a group hug.
"Thanks guys. Love you all." I smiled as we disconnected, sitting back down where we originally sat.
"Matt, truth or dare?" I asked, wiping the tears.
"Dare." Matt grinned, preparing for the worst.
"Go on your contact list, go on the eleventh person and call then saying that you stole from a store and you need someone to bail you out of jail." I chuckled as I watched Matt pull out his phone.
As we were waiting for him to begin the call. He counted the eleventh person and then threw his head back. We all laughed.
"Who is it?" Nash asked, looking over at his phone. He pointed to who he has to call.
"It's his mom!" Nash laughed as we all did too.
"Put it on speaker." Cameron whisper yelled.
"Yeah, yeah." Matt whispered back as he put it on speaker as we waited for Matt's mom to pick up.
"Hello?" Matt's mom answered.
"Mom?" Matt started off on a serious note.
"Matt? What's wrong?" I could tell in her voice she was getting worried. I began to feel bad because I was the one who told Matt to do this.
"Look, I'm going to tell you something. But please don't be mad, or tell dad." He paused, continuing to look at the floor as we still watched him.
"What did you do?" She asked, impatiently waiting for an answer.
"Today Sarah, the guys and I all went to the mall and I saw these sunglasses that I really wanted and I tried to steal them. I ended up getting caught and I only have one phone call to get someone to bail me out of jail." Matt ended in a sad tone.

That story was pretty realistic, if I was Matt's mom I would have believed it without a doubt.

"Matthew Lee Espinosa!" She began.
"Look, I'm sorry." He stated, now having a scared tone in his voice. Silence then filled the other end. "Mom?" Matt asked, wondering if she hung up. She sighed.
"I-I have no clue what to say." Matthew the looked up at me and I was feeling horrible.
"Please end this." I mouthed to him, he nodded and looked back at the phone.
"Mom?"
"Yeah?"
"This was a prank." Matt stated, as the room erupted in laughter, awe's and sorry's. She took a sigh.
"Matthew! Don't do that to me. Be thankful I didn't tell your father right away." She laughed. I'm glad that she can handle Matthew's jokes. I stood up at sat beside Matt so I could talk to his mom.
"Hi Ms.Espinosa, it's Sarah." I began.
"Hello, Sarah."
"Look, I'm so sorry if I caused a mini heart attack. I dared him to do that. During the whole time I was feeling really bad so I'm so sorry." I apologized, slightly laughing.
"It's okay. Matt has done a lot of those but this was the first one that I thought was real." She laughed too.
"I have to go. I love you mom. I'm sorry too." Matt laughed.
"Okay, Matt. Love you too, apology accepted. Please be safe." She laughed too as she hung up.
"Well, I'm done with truth or dare." I chuckled as I went back to go sit beside Hayes. "I have never felt so bad giving a dare." I sighed.
"It's fine, and don't worry. My mom said it was fine. Don't worry, the past is in the past." Matt stated, comforting me.
"Okay. I'm going to bed. Goodnight." I smiled, just about to walk to my bedroom.
"Night. I'll be there soon." Hayes smiled as all the guys filled the room with awe's. I blush as I leave the room.