WWE Women One shots/Imagines

Toni and Rhea- Puzzle Pieces

(Author's Note: Requested by heavenupsidedown_ )

"So, what are you gonna do, Y/n?" I finished tying my boots and looked up at Raquel.

"What do you mean?" I'm one of the last superstars to arrive today. So, that's why Raquel is standing with me as I'm getting ready.

"You have two beautiful women who are crazy about you. They flirt with you and you flirt back. I can't watch this weird dance continue. Rhea and Toni don't deserve to be lead on. Either choose one or quit playing with heartstrings." I paused and thought about what she said.

"I'm sorry, Raquel. I didn't think I was doing that. I'll do something about it." I left the locker room to find either Toni, Rhea, or both.

I found Toni first. She smiled at me. "Hey, good looking."

"Hi, Toni. Where's Rhea?" Toni pointed behind me I looked and saw Rhea coming my way.

"Hi, love. Good to see you." I noticed Rhea and Toni are giving each other dirty looks right now.

"Ok, you can both stop. I know what's going on." They looked at me, shocked i caught the staring contest. "I'm gonna say it like it is. I know you both have feelings for me. You're always fighting over me like I'm a prize. Well, I'm not. I'm a person."

"Yeah, you're right. Sorry, love." Rhea said, apologizing to me.

I crossed my arms and sighed. "To tell you the truth, I share your feelings. I like you both. Problem is, I have a hard time deciding. So, I've come up with a solution. Each of you will take me on a date. After both, hopefully my heart will have chosen who I want to be with. What do you think?" I looked at both women.

"I'm alright with that." Toni agreed with me. I smiled at her. "Rhea? What about you?"

"Fine, if that's what you want. Who are you going with first?" Rhea turned to me.

"Honestly, I don't know. I don't want to seem like I'm gonna play favorites. Just do rock paper scissors. First one to win goes first." They shrugged and held their fists out. Toni threw paper and Rhea threw rock.

"Awe, come on!" Rhea groaned with annoyance, seeing Toni won.

"Sorry, you're just too predictable. So, looks like I'm first. I'll pick you up at five tomorrow." Toni smirked, happy she gets to go first.

"One more thing." I said, which got their attention. "When I'm on Toni's date, we will not talk about Rhea's date. Same with you, Rhea. You will not talk bad about each other to try and convince me that your better than the other."

****

Like she said, Toni picked me up at five. She took me to a restaurant so we can talk. I got to get to know Toni more, which is nice. We normally don't get to talk much since we have interviews, promos, and matches all of the time.

She's been a gentlewoman the whole time. It reminds me of why I like her so much.

"I had a lot of fun, Toni." I said as she walked me to my door. I invited her to come inside with me for a minute, so we stayed in the doorway.

"Me too, Y/n." She pulled me in for a hug. It felt right, almost as if we fit together like pieces of a puzzle, but it almost felt incomplete. "I'll see you at work." Toni went to pull away from the hug, but she stopped. Her hands are still on my waist and mine are on her shoulders. I can feel the tension in the air. "Can I kiss you?"

My heart skipped a beat because of the question. "Yes," I said with a smile. Having gained permission, Toni kissed me. It's full of passion and I felt butterflies in my stomach.

****

The following week, Rhea took her turn. She took me to a theater to watch a new horror movie that came out. During the movie, I noticed Rhea had her hand facing up. I've seen this trick before, but it still made me smile.

I grabbed her hand and linked our fingers together. She looked at me and we shared a smile.

After the movie, we stopped at a restaurant to get food. Overall, this is a great date too. Similar to Toni, Rhea walked me to my door.

We finished our conversation from the car ride here and hugged before she had to go. Once again, I felt like we melded together, but I still feel like something is missing. She pulled away, but stayed where she is, not wanting to leave yet. We stared at each other with grins, just enjoying each other's company. "Are you gonna kiss me, or what?" I surprised myself with what I said.

Rhea seemed surprised too, but it didn't last long. "I thought you'd never ask, love." She cupped my cheeks and kissed me. Rhea was gentle with me, causing my heart to melt.

It was almost like we couldn't stop, because afterwards she gave me a couple pecks. "I'll see you at work, Demi." She sent me a wink and left me with my thoughts. Now is the time for me to choose.

****

"Hey, chica. I heard you went on a date with Toni and Rhea. So, have you made up your mind?" Raquel had stopped me after I left the locker room. I have my gear on and I'm ready for my match.

"Yeah, I gave myself time to think about it. Could you come with me? I don't know how they'll react to my decision." Raquel smiled and nodded.

We found Rhea and Toni and pulled them aside so I can talk to them. "I've had some time to think things over. I had fun on both our dates. Time and time again, I've had trouble with choosing between you both. I find it impossible to choose again. So, I've come up with a solution." The three women looked at me expectantly. Toni and Rhea are obviously nervous. "I wanted to know if I can date you both at the same time?"

"You want to date us both?" Toni looked so confused.

Rhea looked like she's thinking hard on this. "So, you mean like a polyamorous relationship?" I nodded, relieved she understands. "I don't wanna date Toni and you at the same time."

"No, Rhea, you don't have to. I date you both, but you don't have to date each other. I can split my time with you both so it's even. I understand there's hesitation and we will have to double down on communication." Everyone nodded along to what I'm saying. "I'm willing to try this if you are."

"I like that idea. It can work, but only if the three of you want it to work. I'll give you three space so you can decide without outside influence." She told us and walked away. Raquel agreeing with me helps me feel better, but not entirely. This decision is up to Rhea and Toni. I've said my piece, so the ball is in their court now.

"I'm willing to give this a try. If it means you can be my girlfriend, then I'm all for it." Toni told me. I smiled and hugged her.

I pulled away after a few seconds to see what Rhea's answer is. "I'd rather not lose my friend through the process of fighting over you. I'm saying yes because this way, I get to keep you both." I sighed with relief and hugged Rhea.

"I'm so happy you both said yes. Just know that if you feel uncomfortable or think this isn't working out, just let me know. I will understand completely. Now, group hug!"

The two blondes chuckled and hugged me close. Now I feel complete. I have all my missing puzzle pieces.

(Sorry this took awhile. I was busy this whole weekend. Hope you like it!)