Sisters by chance

Which Is Witch

Piper was relieved to see Paige and Prue orb in. She knew she shouldn't be worried because she knew they would be good babysitters. She handed Melinda to Paige.

"Maybe you can sing to her like you normally do. It always puts her right to sleep."
Paige looked at Melinda and then Prue.
"Right."
She looked back at Melinda
"Hush Little baby don't say a word." She started singing. Piper cut her off
"Paige! Are you drunk? You sound terrible." She said.
Prue stepped in.
"No she's not. She's just tone deaf." She said through her teeth staring at Paige.
"Hm tough crowd." Paige said
Prue turned to Piper.
"You can go ahead and take your nap." She said
"Yeah! We got this!" Paige said
"I know I just want to make sure you guys can handle her." She said
Paige turned towards Piper
"Piper you worry too much. You need to relax. Take your butt to your room and go to sleep." She ordered.
Piper stood shocked normally bossiness was Prue's thing.
"Okay! Your spending way too much time with Prue and Fine! But come get me if something happens." Piper said.
"Okay" Paige and Prue said at the same time.
Piper gave them a confused look before walking out.

Phoebe walked in to see Prue reading a magazine and Paige holding a sleeping Melinda
"Do you see what Prue is wearing right now? Ugh it's even worse than that green sweater last week." Phoebe whispered to Paige.
Paige gave her a dirty look
"There's nothing wrong with it. Plus Phoebe it's not nice to talk about people." Paige said defensively.
"Um weren't you the one who said Prue dresses like an old lady?" Phoebe asked.
"Apparently." Paige said rolling her eyes.
Phoebe laughed. She thought Paige was playing dumb.
"I'm going to get some work done on the computer while she's asleep. You don't mind do you?" Phoebe asked.
"No of course not." Paige said
Phoebe went downstairs.

Once Prue seen that Phoebe was gone.
She looked at Paige who was still reading the magazine.
"Paige?" She looked up to see herself looking back.
"Do you and Phoebe talk shit about me?" Prue asked.
"No why would you say that?" Paige asked.
"Because she just came up to me thinking I was you and just started naturally talking crap and even let it slip that apparently you think I dress like an old lady." She said annoyed.
Paige sighed knowing she was caught.
"Oh then yes we do." Paige said
"I would totally smack you right now if you weren't in my body." Prue said through her teeth.
"Oh come on. You and Piper don't talk about Phoebe and I?" Paige asked.
Prue didn't say anything
"Well I have my answer." Paige said with a smirk.

Phoebe came back in.
"Prue the light bulb in the kitchen is flickering. Can you change it?"
"Yeah." Both Prue and Paige said.
They both gave each other annoyed looks.
Prue looked at Phoebe.
"Did you say Prue or Paige?" She asked
"I said Prue." Phoebe said confused on the tension in the room.
Paige stood up.
"Prue it's okay I'll do it. I wouldn't want you to electrocute yourself." She made sure to emphasize "Prue". So her little sister would catch on.
"No it's okay Paige. Prue's always done it." Phoebe said.
Paige sat down and shrugged.
"I'll just meet you downstairs. I just seen Melinda move. Just in case she wakes up. You can go ahead." Prue said
"Okay." Phoebe said as she went back downstairs

Paige turned to Prue but kept staring at herself
"Prue I don't know how to change a lightbulb!"
She said
"All you do is unscrew it." Prue said explaining to her younger sister.
"We haven't even had time to figure out how to reverse this potion." Paige said
" I don't think we are doing that bad." Prue said
Paige just sighed

It had been about 3 hours since they got to the manor. Piper came back into the babies room.
She seen Paige changing the babies diaper. She was shocked Paige was a good aunt but she refused to change diapers.
"Wow your finally changing her? Piper asked
"Huh? Oh yeah." Paige said
"Well I'm gonna go make dinner." Piper said
"Lasagna sound okay?" Piper asked.
"Of course I love your Lasagna." Paige said
"You've never had my lasagna?" Piper said confused.
Paige froze and looked a Piper slowly.
"No I meant. I would love your lasagna. Prue's told me so much about it." She said
"Oh." Piper said laughing
"Love ya!" Paige said
"Love ya too Paigey." Piper said

The four girls were at the dinner table.
Everyone was enjoying Pipers lasagna.
Prue started to load hers up with salt earning a kick from "Paige" under the table.
"Stop I have high blood pressure." Prue whispered to her little sister who was about to give her body a heart attack.
Piper seen her the two of them having a whisper conversation away from Phoebe and Herself.
"Care to share with the class?" Piper asked
"I was just reminding Prue over here to watch her salt intake because of her blood pressure." Paige said sharply.
"Yeah I forgot." Prue said
"Right." Piper said not totally convinced
Everyone finished their dinner. Paige and Prue went home.
"You didn't think they were acting weird?" Piper asked Phoebe.
"Oh they totally were." Phoebe answered.

Back at the apartment.
"Paige! Andy's calling can you please just tell him we got caught up at the manor? Try and sound like me."
"Yes. Stop freaking out." Paige said
"Hello? Prue Halliwells phone." She said only to see Prue shaking her head.
"Wow what a formal introduction." Andy said laughing.
"Yeah." Paige said trying to make him get to the point
"Listen last night was amazing. I keep thinking about you and that look in your eye. I want you really bad. " Paige make a disgusted face and looked at Prue who was laughing.
"Yeah I had fun too."
"Good. How about tomorrow You and I go out to get dinner?" He asked
"Sounds good." Paige said
"Great I'll see you tomorrow sexy" He said
"Right back at ya." Paige said hanging up.
"You sounded nothing like me!" Prue said
"Well how was I supposed to know what to say?" Paige asked

"I hope we switch back soon. I've avoided peeing all day." Prue said.
"Oh you have?" Paige asked guilty.
"You haven't?" Prue asked
"No I went Pee earlier and I changed after Melinda puked on me." Paige explained.
"Fine then. I'm going Pee now." Prue said
"Okay." Paige said

"Paige Demon." Piper yelled
Prue came running out of the bathroom.
"Paige! Piper! Danger."
Paige ran over to Prue who orbed them to Piper.
"Paige send his fireball back towards him!" Piper yelled.
"Uhh ok." Paige said
"Fireball" She shoved it towards him.
She missed and hit the attic window.
"Paige? Seriously? We're back to this?" Piper said as she froze the room.
Prue ran over to get the warlock vanquishing potion they had upstairs and threw it at him.
The demon was vanquished.
Piper looked at Paige.
"What just happened? I thought we were over this! You had gotten so good with your powers. Your acting all scared all of a sudden."
Paige and Prue looked at each other.
"Okay! Why do you keep doing that?" Piper asked irritated.
Paige looked at her.
"Um I'm not Paige I'm Prue." She said
Piper then looked at Prue's body
"And I'm Paige"
"What?" Piper asked
"We switched bodies." They said at the same time.
"For how long?" She asked concerned
"No clue." Paige in Prue's body said
Piper sighed.
Prue looked at Paige and shrugged
Piper walked over to the book.
"Which one of you drank it? Piper asked
"Paige." Both said at the same time
"Well luckily we made most of the potions in the book to be prepared. Let me look and see if I find it."
Piper went to the chest in the corner of the room.
"Here." She said holding up the potion.
Since they were in the opposite body Prue had to drink it this time since Paige was inside her.
She drank it.
"I want to be me again."
Both fell to the floor and after a few seconds woke up.
"It worked." Prue said
"Thank god." Paige said
"No thank Piper." Piper said
They all laughed
"What made you drink the body swapping potion in the first place? Piper asked
"She had a headache and I remembered the potion grams used to give us as kids for migraines. So I looked through all of the blue ones and figured it had to be the one without the label." Prue said
"Um the ones Grams used to give us was Pink." Piper said laughing
"Oh." Prue said slowly turning her head towards Paige who was pissed
"Well I think it's time for bed." Piper said standing up.
"Okay bye love you." Prue said before Paige orbed them both home.
————————————————————————
Please Vote and Comment on what you want to see happen next!