Glitched Memories [FNAF AU | Story 1]

~+[ Chapter 22 | A Weird Theory ]+~

Sam and Elizabeth would just be talking as Sam sat on the couch just upside down as he only sat up to drink either a thing of water or take a bite out of the strawberry-flavored pop tart he found in the kitchen.

"Not gonna lie, I honestly didn't see any sort of resemblance between you and your guy's dad at first since ya told me he was your dad cause, If HE has blonde hair and your guy's mom had brown hair, How the hell did YOU end up with ginger hair?" Sam asked.

Elizabeth just shrugged since honestly didn't know. "Maybe he used to have ginger hair??" She replied as Sam just thought for a moment as he then just sat up on the couch.

"Hm, true true..wait- the only way to prove that he did is to look at any old photos of him cause that's the only way I can prove my theory...and if it's not true I'm then gonna assume either your adopted and were lied to bout Evan being your twin or your guy's mom cheated on your dad secretly-" Said he.

Elizabeth glared at him. "I think any portraits or photos of my dad or of anyone in this family if we're talking old and not recent, are probably in the attic back at my old house.." Said she. "Then come on let's go then! Also not gonna lie that sounds like he's trying to make you guys sound perfect-" Said Sam as he quickly sat up.

"Heh..guess your right" Elizabeth replied as Sam quickly ran away outside while Elizabeth followed behind. She remembered the photo she still had on her that had her dad in the photo but she just ignored it as she followed behind Sam toward his car as the two got into the car and drove away.

As they made it to the old Afton house, Sam just looked at the place in awe as the house was a huge two-story house. "Holy shit you used to live here?!" Said Sam as Elizabeth nodded a small bit.

"Damn didn't know y 'all was both fancy AND rich-" Sam continued before getting punched in the arm by the girl. "Shut up you southern-sounding dumb blonde-" Said she as Sam just paused a moment before then messing up the girl's hair and quickly running away towards the front door.

Sam then once got to the front door and tried to open it but the door was locked as he sighed quietly, now just disappointed. "Move over-" said Elizabeth as she got out a thing of keys considering she just lived at the Afton house for a long time ever since she just woke up even though supposedly she was meant to be dead...but she wasn't.

"I- how did you-" "If I'm being honest, I was living here for a small bit since well...I woke up here..since I'm supposed to be dead..." said Elizabeth as Sam looked at the girl and frowned a bit as Elizabeth unlocked the door and opened it as she walked away inside as Sam followed behind.

"Oh..Well, let's just look for what we're lookin' for and get out of here said Sam as he quickly ran away through the living room and up some stairs as Elizabeth followed behind. As Sam ran upstairs he'd look up at the ceiling to see if he could find a hatch or door that led up to the attic.

Sam found it and before he was about to go grab a chair he'd find a plush on the ground as he jumped a small bit and let out a tiny scream that sounded like a mouse just got stepped on. Elizabeth looked at the floor and saw it was a plushtrap plush as she picked it up and then looked at Sam confused.

"WHY DO YOU GUYS HAVE THAT-" Sam yelled. "Oh calm down it's just a plush that bites people's hands and fingers off. "She jokingly said as Sam glared at her. "Not. FUNNY." Said he as the girl giggled a small bit.

"Meanie-" Sam replied as he jumped up and grabbed the handle that was attached to the attic door as Elizabeth moved out of the way when the door opened up and the stairs for it folded out and hit the floor.

"I'm goin' up-" Said Sam as he quickly went up the ladder as Elizabeth just followed behind even though she knew following him would possibly be a bad idea.

Once the two were in the attic Sam would instantly start looking through some old boxes and any with the words 'Photos' on them as Sam opened up one box only to find a box filled with blacked-out photos. "Darn-" Said Sam quietly as he went over to another box. 

Elizabeth looked through one of the boxes since wanted to help as she opened up one of the boxes and found an old wedding photo and it was of the woman with the long ginger hair and green eyes, and the guy with the short blonde hair and reddish-brown eyes as Elizabeth looked at the photo slightly in awe since the woman in the photo just looked so pretty as she realized the two were her grandparents.

"You found somethin'?" Sam replied as Elizabeth nodded while sneaking the photo she had in her pocket into the crack on the side of the portrait as Sam looked at the photo and then the one Elizabeth snuck and attached as he just tilted his head.

"Huh, so I'm HALF right on my theory" Said Sam as he put the photo back then looked to Elizabeth before then looking back at the photo of the woman as he smiled a small bit. "Heh, Just realized you almost look exactly like her" Said he.

"I doubt that-" Said Elizabeth as she sat on the floor. "No look" said Sam as he walked over to a nearby mirror as Elizabeth walked over then looked at the mirror as she was standing in front of it then at Sam who held the photo up as Elizabeth looked at the photo and then at herself. "Oh, I guess your right" Said she as Elizabeth looked at herself.

"See? Told ya" said Sam as Elizabeth just rolled her eyes at him. "Come on let's go you got to prove your point and that I look kinda like my grandma-" said she as Elizabeth walked over to the ladder and climbed down as Sam followed behind.