BEN drowned x Reader (Silenced)

{CHPT. 10}

I left you guys with no chapters for so long that even I forgot what was going on 💀 (even to the point where when I was re-reading I got invested in my own book...)

Y/N woke up in Nina's room, only to remember everything that had happened yesterday.

Everything still felt bitter. But... It was just to protect them right? Could they trust Jeff?

They hopped out of Nina's bed and snuck out of the room, everyone was still asleep so they went to BEN's room.

They opened the door only to see BEN violently spraying the whole top bunk in blossom perfume.

Y/N giggled and blushed, BEN snapped his head towards them. He released a sigh of relief. "Hey Y/N." He muttered.

"What's up, BEN? What's with all the perfume?" BEN looked at them and decided that he had sprayed enough.

"Something's up. I just don't know what. I don't want any traces of Jeff in here anymore."

Y/N began to fidget again. "..Y/N? Do you know something I don't?" He asked, climbing down the ladder.

"I don't know much more than you but.. Nina told me something strange is going on. Jeff has been acting weird." Y/N began to avoid eye contact, rubbing their shoulder anxiously.

BEN sighed, "I'm glad you know this, I didn't wanna say anything about it but I've noticed it too. He.. Hates me now." Y/N tilted their head.

"What happened?" "Last night, when I noticed you were gone. I assumed it was him, he's been acting much more.... Calm around you. When I realized you were in Nina's he came out of his room to quote 'See if Y/N was okay. I wasn't out here for your attitude or you at all.' He's never like this! I mean, I'm not mad he cares about you..." BEN got quiet at the end.

Y/N smirked at him, they had learned he is a jealous person. They grabbed his cheek, "I know what you mean, BEN. He's being an asshole. You want nothing to do with him." BEN nodded and blushed.

He would never admit it but he's madly in love with them. He was just scared of rejection, or losing them.

Y/N cupped his face and ruffled his hair, smiling... Then they snatched his phone and flopped down onto his bed. "Hey!" BEN yelped, and Y/N only laughed at him.

BEN jumped on top of them and nuzzled himself into their stomach, whining. Y/N sat their hand on top of his head, trying to hide the fact their head was racing and they were a blushing mess.

"Is this seriously what you think 'just friends' do?" They asked, heart racing. BEN looked up at them, beginning to get off. Y/N pushed him back down. "I never said I didn't like it."

BEN stayed on top of them while they played on his phone. This continued until Jeff walked in.

BEN put his arms on either side of Y/N, pushing himself up to look at Jeff. This only made it look like he was pinning Y/N to the bed but...

"What the hell are you doing in here?" BEN asked angrily. Jeff looked completely calm. "Bro, what the fuck is your problem? I've done nothing wrong to you." Jeff tilted his head, glaring at him.

BEN now fully lifted himself off of Y/N, pulling them up with him and putting them on his lap.

Y/N rested their head on his shoulder so that they were no longer looking at Jeff, which only angered him.

"What the hell?" Jeff snarled. BEN looked over at him after admiring Y/N. "You haven't done anything? Oh really? Have you not been here this whole time? Do I even have to explain what you did?!" Jeff rolled his eyes as BEN went on.

Steps began to approach the door, which caused them all to freeze. "What is all this ruckus about," Kate questioned, not really caring what was going on. Jeff looked at her, eyes looking a tad psychotic. "Nothing." He laughed.

And with that, Kate left... With a feeling of dread stuck in her stomach. A smile crept onto Jeff's face as he turned back to look at BEN and Y/N. BEN felt worry swimming in his veins.

"Jeff.. Why can't you just leave us alone.?" Y/N spoke, "It's not about you and BEN, Y/N. I'm only here for you." BEN's grip tightened on Y/N while Jeff spoke.

Kate, who was at the bottom of the stairs had finally come to realize. There was another person in the mansion. She stumbled back up the steps, "Jeff! You... You're a liar! I am so getting your ass murdered." Kate chuckled, pointing at Jeff. His smile only widened as he pulled the ropes from his pockets, jumping onto Kate and pinning her to the floor.

"J.. Jeff!" She groaned, squirming under his grip. He took the ropes and wrapped her in them, knotting them to his abilities, which were very high quality. He covered her mouth in duct tape and dragged her down the stairs.

Nina was sitting in her room, headphones blasting in her ears while salty tears slowly dripped down her face.

Her lip quivered and she quietly spoke to herself. "I'm... so... sorry, Y/N." was all she could muster up.

Jeffrey buried her alive outside and left her to suffer, making himself comfortable back inside the mansion with a smirk on his face.

Nina scurried inside BEN's room and burst out into words. "This is terrible, so so so so so terrible! Whatsgonnahappennext!?" Nina sputtered, pulling her hair.

"Nina, calm down. We're gonna work this out!" BEN softly spoke as Y/N got up off of his lap and stood up.

"The mansion members are gonna start dropping like flies as long as Jeff stays here! If people keep finding out, creepypastas will be no more!" Nina looked terrified as she spoke.

"Is that really such a bad thing?" BEN asked, now standing up. Y/N set a hand on his shoulder and shook their head, "BEN..." "What?"

"Yes, it is! BEN, even if you don't like this place, there are still people living here!" Nina exclaimed.

BEN scratched his head awkwardly as Y/N pinched the bridge of their nose disapprovingly. "Take Toby for example, he's not dead. He was a teenage boy, he doesn't deserve to die. All of the proxies are living, Sally is barely aware she's dead, not everyone here deserves to perish to Jeff's insanity." Nina shook her head, looking at the both of them intently.

"Nina, it's gonna be alright. It will be fine." Y/N spoke in a soft but comforting tone.

Nina turned her back to both of them, fidgeting again. She sighed before speaking,

"I'm afraid this isn't a love story just yet."