CHOOSE | Stefan Salvatore

18 | caught

Season 3, Episode 12
The Ties That Bind

Estella woke up and looked to her right, seeing Bonnie lying on her stomach and facing her. She was still asleep, small snores escaping her lips, and Estella smiled. She moved closer, moving a strand of hair from Bonnie's face and keeping her hand on her cheek. Bonnie leaned into her hand, her eyes fluttering open.

Bonnie gave Estella a sleepy smile, not wanting to get up. She moved closer to Estella and snuggled into her neck. Estella scooted closer to Bonnie and was now sitting up, the blanket uncovering her top half. Bonnie lay on Estella's chest, drawing circles on her stomach lazily.

"Can I tell you something?" Bonnie whispered to Estella, her hot breath tickling her neck. Estella hummed in response, twirling a piece of Bonnie's hair in her fingers.

"That was my first time. With a girl." Bonnie's face flushed red as she spoke and she nuzzled her face into Estella's neck so she couldn't see. Estella grinned, pulling Bonnie into her lap, making Bonnie squeak in surprise. Estella grabbed her face and kissed her.

"If that was your first time... then wow." Bonnie giggled at Estella's response, kissing her again. The two got into a heated make-out session, their tongues fighting for dominance and their hands roaming each other's bodies. Just then, the door opened, and Bonnie squeaked, rolling herself off of Estella and covering their bodies.

Stefan stood in the doorway, his jaw dropped as he saw Estella and Bonnie making out. He looked to Estella, who was in nothing but her underwear, and he gulped and turned away. His dead heart drummed in his ears, and he forced himself to calm down.

"Bonnie. We have things to do. I'll be waiting outside." Another pang of jealousy hit Stefan and before either of the girls could say anything, he walked out and closed the door behind him.

Estella looked at Bonnie and couldn't help but giggle. Bonnie looked at Estella with wide eyes, but soon after she joined her fits of laughter. After a moment, the two calmed down and Estella got out of bed, stretching her arms and legs. Bonnie crawled over to Estella's side of the bed, pulling her back and wrapping her arms around her torso. She kissed her hip before using Estella to get up. She groaned at the soreness of her legs, wobbling for a second before Estella grabbed her by the shoulder to steady her.

"You okay?" Estella kept a firm grip on the dark-skinned girl, unsure if she was going to collapse if she let her go. Bonnie nodded in response, and Estella let her go slowly. She wobbled for a second before balancing on her feet and walking to the bathroom, shutting the door.

While Bonnie was in the bathroom, Estella grabbed her clothes that were scattered on the floor and put them on. She then fixed her hair to the best of her ability in the bedroom mirror, also wiping her eyes and rubbing her smeared lipstick off of her mouth. When she finished, she walked outside and to the living room where she saw Stefan sitting and tapping his foot impatiently. Stefan looked over when he heard footsteps only to see Estella walk out of the room instead of Bonnie. Another pang of jealousy went through him at the thought of their night together, but he didn't speak a word, continuing to tap his foot on the floor.

"So, what exactly are the things you and Bonnie have to do? I assume it has something to do with your obsession with my brother. Do you have a crush on him or something?" Estella held back a laugh at her joke. Stefan glared at the floor, ignoring the girl's joke and her question. Estella rolled her eyes at Stefan's lack of speaking and eye contact, instead looking around the room.