Your last class was canceled today so you decided to surprise Billie with a visit. She's been working hard this week and sometimes you like to surprise your girlfriends with lunch.You walked into the building smiling at the women at the front desk. She smiled as you walked by with your hands full of Billie's favorite takeout.
You opened her office door and what you saw next was completely unexpected. There was Billie's face deep between some woman's thighs as she trembled on her desk.
"Oh god, Billie Dean." the woman moaned.
"Billie?" you called out.
The blonde's head pops up quickly as she looks at you.
"Y/n?"
"I...I um I brought you lunch but it looks like you already have some," you mumbled setting the bags down on the table.
"Y/n."
"See ya at home," you said quickly as you ran out of the office.
"Wait no! Y/n! Y/n!" Billie screams running after you.
You didn't stop you ran as fast as you could. You cried the whole way home going over the scene again and again in your mind.
Once you made it home and behind closed doors, you snapped. Your sobs were loud and painful. It felt like your heart was being squeezed in your chest.
"Sweetheart?" Cordelia called out.
"Oh honey what's the matter?" she asked sitting beside you on the couch.
You cried harder as she held you. It didn't take long for Mina to walk into the living room.
"What's wrong? What happened?" she asked. Cordelia shrugged her shoulders as she tried to calm you down.
The front door slammed shut as Billie walked in.
"Oh thank god you guys are here. Y/n I.""Get away from me," you screamed.
"Y/n please let me explain."
"Yes please do please explain to them how you were cheating on us!"
"What?" Cordelia and Mina said in unison.
"Yeah. I went to her office with lunch to surprise her and there she is fucking some woman in her office." You shout.
Cordelia and Wilhelmina's heads snap towards Billie. "What?" they asked in unison shocked to hear this.
"It's not what you think," Billie says to them.
"It was Ally." She says.
The name means nothing to you but you notice how the other two women's shoulders relax a bit as if this is good news.
"Who the fuck is Ally?" You hissed.
"Ally is a friend of ours. She lives in Michigan. She's a senator there." Billie says.
"Okay. And?" You asked still not understanding.
"Babydoll before you the three of us would invite others to sleep with us. Mostly random women we met out but sometimes friends. Ally is someone we used to sleep with often whenever she came to town to visit. She hasn't been here in a while but she showed up today."
"Wait a minute. So you've all been sleeping with her since we've been together?" You asked looking at each of them.
"No." They quickly say.
"Sweat heart we haven't been with anyone since you," Cordelia says softly.
"Well until now..." Mina adds looking at Billie pointedly.
"Hey! We never talked about Ally and if our plans changed. It's not like I planned this she just showed up. It's nothing that any of us haven't done before." She says defensively.
You look over at the blonde tears streaming down your face. "How would you feel if you saw me like that? Huh? Pinned down by some other woman throwing my head back in pleasure as she eats me out?!"
Mina growls at the thought of someone else having their hands on you. Out of the three of them, she is the most possessive.
Billie Dean lowered her head in shame.
"I wouldn't like that. I'm so sorry y/n I swear to you it wasn't something I had planned nor would I do it again. Babydoll please believe me." She begged reaching out to hold your hand.
You snatched your hand back rejecting her advances and shaking your head."I don't want to be touched. I want to be alone I need to think." You said making your way towards the stairs.
The three women watch you disappear upstairs.
"Nice going Billie Dean!" Mina hissed at the blonde.
"I didn't do it on purpose you know how Ally is.""Yeah, I do. But that still gives you no right to just have your way with her. I thought we left that lifestyle once we became involved with y/n." She says looking over at Cordelia.
"I thought so too but Billie Dean is right we never spoke about what would happen if Ally or any one of our friends returned. I think the two of us subconsciously decided we were done with that once we met y/n. Maybe Billie had other thoughts?" She asked looking over at Billie.
"So you two are just going to blame this on me? I never thought about being with anyone else but the three of you. Ever. Ally is different though. I thought... I thought it was okay."
"Well, it wasn't," Mina adds.
"I know that now!" Billie huffs.
"We will figure it out," Cordelia says.
"I hope y/n will forgive me." Billie cries.
Cordelia frowns as she brings Billie into her arms holding her tightly. Mina looks at the sight in front of her as her heart breaks. One for Billie Dean and one for you. While she was upset with Billie she didn't like to see any of you upset.
"Just give her some time. She's hurt but she will come around. I will speak to her." Mina says.
"Thank you." Billie smiles.
The three women smile at each other sending looks of love to one another as the sound of Billie's phone interrupts them.
Billie frowns as she looks down at her phone."Who is it, Billie?" Cordelia asked.
"It's Ally." She sighs handing the phone over to Cordelia.
Cordelia and Mina look over the text.
Are you lovely ladies free tonight? I miss the three of you.
Flight leaves at noon on Friday.
Let me know.
-Ally.
YOU ARE READING
SP Character One Shots
FanfictionSarah Paulson Characters/ Reader One Shots. Requests are open.