Too Weird (Ben Drowned)xReader

Ch.9

A/N: Just a warning, there are some minor swear words. Still thought I should warn you, even though there aren't enough to mark it as mature or anything.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

After multiple hours of talking and playing video games, you finally began walking home. The sun was setting, casting a beautiful orange color over the empty sidewalk. You stretched and smiled, glad that you got to spend some quality time with your best friend. You couldn't remember the last time you were able to do that because of school and your job.

You checked your phone in the silence of the walk, seeing no new messages. You sighed, remembering your parents were away on a trip and no one else bothers to talk to you. The sad fact of life is that they never bothered to check up on you when they were away. It hurt you a little, being their only child and they leave you to your own devices whenever they leave.

Your feet shuffled slowly on the sidewalk towards your house. You were taking longer on purpose, not too anxious to come home to the empty house. That was until you remembered BEN. You smiled subconsciously at the thought of the killer, not sure why this suddenly perked you up to arrive home quicker. The time passed by faster as you made your way back home, thoughts swirling in a mess of everything that happened that day and the previous. Slipping out your key, you unlocked the dark house and walked inside.

The lights were all out to your slight confusion. Maybe BEN didn't like the lights, you thought. A crash came from the living room with some shouting. Dropping your bag to the floor, you ran into the living room to see BEN pinned to the ground by another teen. He had longish black hair and a white hoodie over black slacks. He looked like he had tried to dress formal but had failed pretty bad. The boy held a knife to BEN's throat as said elf looked up at him with a cocky smirk. "You little cheater!" The white clad boy yelled. BEN just laughed, "Its all part of the game Jeffy-boy."

You watched on in silence, your mouth dropped open in disbelief. Not only were there two boys fighting, but the couch just happened to have a giant slash down the middle facing the paused game on the TV. Now you weren't one to be angered easily, but this was a little too far. "What the hell are you doing in my house!?" You yelled. Both boys' heads snapped in your direction in surprise.

You took a step back, startled at the appearance of "Jeffy". His skin was white, paper white and his eyes were large and unblinking. Probably the most terrifying thing about him was the large red smile that seemed to be cut into his flesh. BEN smirked and waved, "Hi (y/n). Fancy seeing you here." He said casually as if not expecting you to walked into your own home. "Jeffy" glared down at BEN, "You didn't tell me this was someone's house you little asshole." He said, pressing the knife into the elf's throat. You rushed forward and grabbed his arm, trying hard to pull the knife away. "If there's blood on my floor, my parents will kill me!" You screamed. The killer glanced at you and your useless tugging, effortlessly keeping his arm there. You let go with a huff and stepped back. Strength was never really your strong suit.

BEN chuckled, "Guess I should do the introduction here." He glanced between you and the boy dressed in white. "(Y/n) this is Jeff the Killer. Jeff this is (y/n)." He said, as if it was everyday you meet a killer in your living room. Now that you thought about it, it was a little strange that there were TWO of them in your house. You shook your head and took another step back to look at them both, "Now as I say again, what the hell are you doing in my house?" You repeated, not as angry as before. Jeff stood up and shoved the large kitchen knife into his sweatshirt pocket. BEN slowly got up, prolonging the explanation. "BEN. Explain." You said, making sure to keep an eye on the new killer. You didn't know how he acted yet. As they say, better safe than sorry.

BEN grinned, "Weeeell, I might have invited Jeffy h-" "Don't call me that!" Jeff yelled and glared as best as he could at BEN. Said elf smirked, "Sorry, can't help it. Anyway I invited him over to play some video games and he's stuck on the fact that he thinks I cheated." Jeff turned to BEN, reaching for his knife. "Cause you did!" he shouted. You sighed, not wanted to physically get in between the fight. "Guys, no more fighting. Seriously. And BEN, it isn't hard for you to cheat; you practically live in video games." You said.

BEN pouted, "Aw, (y/n). You're on his side?" he asked. You couldn't help but smirk at his behavior. He acted so much like a child sometimes. "No, BEN. I don't pick a side. I'm always on the winning side." You said with a confident smirk. BEN chuckled, "I should have seen that coming." Jeff looked at you both before obnoxiously coughing to get the attention in the room. "I also came for you BEN. Slendy know you're here and he isn't the happiest."