"You want some sugar, sugar?" You asked a young, 8 year old Tony Stark. Your (s/c) hand held out some brightly colored candies. Tiny grabbed some and popped them in my mouth. "So tell me again why you call me sugar?" Tony asked.
"Because you're sweet as candy, and candy is made out of sugar." You replied. Your bright red hair bounced as you giggled. Tony reached over to you, and touched your red cone nose. You giggled once more. "You're my favorite girl!" Tony said as he poked the tip of your nose.
7 years later
You were trapped. Your colors faded away. You color sat in a rainbow puddle. You were stuck in your box. Tony forgot about you. He was too busy with school, and girls. He forgot about his favorite girl. He was 15. You were nothing. Only a monochrome clown. Like your dad.
Your dad was right. Humans only live to betray. You then peaked through the hole I'm your box. You saw him with another girl. His 8th one that week. "Do you really mean that?" The girl asked with a blush. "Of course. You are my favorite girl." He said.
You no longer got jealous when he said that to girls. It was usual now. Soon the girl looks around his room and sees your music box. She walks over to it and picks it up. "A Laughing (Y/n) in a box?" She asked, looking at Tony. The box was black and white, lost its color. Tony shrugged and looked at it.
He thought it looked familiar. "Where did you get this? Did you make it?" The girl asked. "I don't know. I think my dad gave it to me." Tony answers. "You can have it if you want." Tony said. You felt a pang of hurt in your heart. He is going to just give me away!? His first friend!
Later that night the girl was on the news. She was dead. Her organs were thrown about, her body stuffed with black candy, her eyes gouged out, and a disturbingly familiar saying. "Want some sugar, sugar?" Was written in the floor in blood.
Present Day
Tony had a new girlfriend named (Y/n). She had (h/c) hair, (e/c) eyes, and (s/c) skin. Tiny forgot all about the girls death, the music box, and you.
Tony walked up behind her and kissed her cheek. She was making his coffee. "Want some sugar, sugar." She said with a smile. Tony froze. He knows he's heard that before. But where?
He said a no, and took his coffee. You smirked. You were making him paranoid. That's what you wanted.
Later that night you were in the computer reading CreepyPasta. Specifically yours. Tony walked up behind you and saw what you were reading. He instantly got paranoid again.
The next day he kept seeing a creepy monochrome clown girl.
It was Friday now, and Tony couldn't access anything. Not even JARVIS. "(Y/n)!? Babe, can you access anything?" Tony called out. "No!" You yelled. You knew exactly why he couldn't access anything.
Later that night, Tony shifted towards your side of the bed, but it was cold. You weren't there. He then heard a loud bang. He slowly got up and went to the kitchen. He then saw a figure hunched over. When it looked up, he saw red eyes.
Tony froze in his place. Soon the lights flicked on, and there was the whole Creepy Pasta group. His precious (Y/n) was on her knees, tied up, a hatchet at her throat.
"I'll do what you want, just please don't kill her!" Tony said. You began laughing like a maniac, along with a monochrome clown. "Slender, take the illusion down please." You said. When the illusion was taken down, there you were. A monochrome clown.
"Hey there Tony! Remember me!?" You said, towering over him. "You're.... You're Laughing (Y/n).." He said, gulping. "Annndd." You said. Tony took a moment. "My first friend." Tony mumbled. "DING, DING, DING! We have a winner!" You yelled.
He took in your black and white appearance. You then know what he was thinking. "7 years. 7 years of sitting in that box, waiting for my friend to notice me. How he called me his favorite girl, when I wasn't. Always brought home a girl, and gave her my title. Then you made the mistake to give me away like trash. So, I realize my father here, was correct. Humans are full of betrayal. So now you know why I killed that girl. To show you how I felt." You said.
"Call me insane, I don't care! At least I met my best friend again!" You said. "A-are you going to kill me?" Tony squeaks. "...No." You said. "What?" Tony asked. "I only came here to give you a scare. Come on guys, let's go." You said. "What... Do you not actually love me?" Tony asked.
You froze. "Yeah, I do love you." You said following your family. Before you left, Tony gave you a long, love filled kiss. "Come see me again soon, alright?" Tony said. "Actually... I'll stay." You said, gazing into his eyes.
Your family was in the corner 'Aww'ing and your father, L.J, gagging.
