You Should Know (a Joe Sugg Fan Fiction)

Chapter Seventeen // True Friends Stab You In the Front

"Why are you doing that to Caspar?" I demanded.

Oli pushed me against a wall and put his hand on my cheek. I didn't break eye contact with him the whole time. I felt his hot breath on my face. His glare digging into me. I wasn't going to break eye contract. I think he knows I'm not scared.

"Oli!" I replied in a stern voice, "what are you doing to Caspar?"

"I have a deal Id like to propose to you." He said leaning into me more.  Our faces were about an inch apart. I still wasn't breaking the eye contact.

"Go on." I said confidently.

"Well, you want to get out of here right? You want Caspar to be okay? You want Joe free?" I'd do anything to get out of here, for Caspar to be okay and to free Joe. "I can make all that come true."

"I don't believe you." I started "why should I believe you?"

He tucked a stay piece of hair behind my ear and put his hand under my chin. I didn't completely comprehend what happened next. His lips attacked mine. I instantly pushed him back, but he wouldn't move. I tried too turn my head, but his hands kept me there. I carried on struggling against him until he pulled away.

"Oli!" I exclaimed, " what the hell?!" I pushed his chest which made him step away this time.

"If you want everyone to be okay, I can make that happen. If you want Joe out, I can make that happen." He looked at me in the eyes. "If you're with me, everything will be okay."

My jaw hit the floor. Oli wanted me to be his girlfriend in exchange for all three of us going free. "I can't..." I managed to mumble.

"Why? You care about them two boys..."

He was right. I was being selfish, but was I being selfish hurting Joe like that. My eyes began to fill up with tears as I looked at my feet. I wanted Joe to be here right now telling me everything would be okay. If I did this, would he understand I did it to escape? For him to be free.

"Do Marcus and Alfie know you're doing this?" I asked with a wobble in my voice.

He shook his head. Was he going to grass them up if he got me? "I just want the best for you." He stated.

"Don't you think the best for me is to be with Joe? Why didn't you say anything before Oli?" Despite everything that was going on, I was still talking to him as a best friend.

"Because you'd hate me..." He trailed off.

"And you think now is the best time?" I questioned with my voice raised a little bit. "I would of never of hated you back then, but I hate you now Oli. I hate that you're backing me into a corner. I hate that you're blackmailing me so my boyfriend... Sorry, fiancé, will be free. I hate that I didn't see this in you. I hate what they've made you."

"I'm doing this for you." He said quietly.

"No you're not! You're doing this for yourself. You can't bare to see me and Joe happy together! You're the ones who introduced us!" My voice began cracking.

"I didn't think you'd get together. I never in a million years. Joe was a complete player and possibly still is. God knows how many girls he has on the side..." My hand found his face. I wanted to kill him. I wanted to strangle him. He looked back at me in shock holding his cheek which was turning red. My hand was tingling from the shock. "He doesn't care about you the way I do." He finished off. I was still speechless. How dare he even say something like that.

My mind was still in a frenzy with what to do. My heart was telling me no, but my mind was telling me the complete opposite. I sunk down to the bottom of the wall and thought.

I hated Oli so much. Why would he ever put me in a situation like this. If it was the other way round, I would never ever do anything like this to him, but he had handed me an olive branch.

Maybe if I agreed, things wouldn't be so bad. I mean, Joe would understand why I did it. I could still get Oli arrested after. Just agree with it until everyone is completely free and then we can go back to normality.

Oli had sunk down to my level and watched me intently. I felt his evil eyes dig into me.

"Is Caspar okay?" I asked. He nodded and looked down. He was lying. Caspar wasn't okay. I hadn't heard a peep out of him since Oli had walked in. "Take me to Caspar." I demanded.

"Hannah..."

"Now!" I began shouting. "Before I do anything, I need to make sure he's okay."

Oli put his hand on my knee which I brushed off. "Caspar has gone."

"Where?" I quizzed him. "You said he'd be okay...?"

"Only if you agree." He got out his phone. "If you agree, there is still time to save him."