One And Done: Spoby One Shots

Secrets and Lies

OK so I may make future parts or make it its own story I don't know yet. I hope you like it. Comment and let me know what you think!

Warning: Rape inferences

Spencer had been told by Yvonne to stay away from Toby and she didn't mind. She knew his continued presence in her life was making everyone unhappy. Most of all her boyfriend and his fiance. If Toby was ok with it then spencer would've stayed away for good if it were not for the events of this morning.

Jenna Marshall was back in Rosewood and after Spencer had a mini heart attack she learned Jenna was here because she learned of Toby's engagement and wanted to be supportive. Normally such a sentiment would seem sweet coming from a stepsister but everyone at the table knew how sinister the relationship between Toby and Jenna had been. That she was here to support him as his sister now was laughable.

Spencer had decided to take a trip to Toby's house. She knocked on the aluminum trailers door. Yvonne opened the door and glared at her.

"You really can't take a hint can you?!" she spat "I told you to stay away from Toby!"

"That's why I came when I knew he would be working" she said.

"I'm here to see you" she clarified upon seeing her confused expression.

"What do you want?" she asked crossing her arms.

"I just....since I can't be there for Toby anymore I just wanted to make sure you're going to be there for him especially with Jenna back and all"

"Jenna?" she asked with a curious expression.

"His stepsister?" she said.

"Toby doesn't have a stepsister" she said seriously and Spencer almost fell over.

"I assure you he does" she snapped. She couldn't believe Toby hadn't told the woman he planned to spend the rest of his life with about his past.

"Look, whatever, if it was bothering him I would know about it" she snapped back.

"Fine" she said stopping in her tracks. Her voice was caught in her throat.

He likes hot cocoa and a cool damp towel around his neck

"Something else?" she spat. Spencer just turned and walked away.

What Spencer had said to Yvonne had gotten to her and she decided to just go and ask Toby about it.

"Hey baby" she said walking up to him. "Spencer came by to the house today"

"I had nothing to do with it" he assured.

"I know, she is worried about you because your step sister Jenna is back in town?" she questioned.

Toby couldn't help but smile at Spencer's thoughtfulness.

"Why is she so concerned?" she asked.

"Jenna and i never got along" he said letting out a lot of air. "Her and my dad had a falling out about three years ago" he said shrugging it off. Yvonne could tell he wasn't telling her something.

Since it was a small town it wasn't hard to find jenna.

"Jenna?" she said approaching her at the brew.

"Yes?" she said trying to make out her voice.

"It's Yvonne, Tobys fiance" she said,

"Oh, it's nice to meet you" she said offering her a hand.

"Can I ask why you and toby don't get along, why he never talks about you" she asked.

"I can't tell you, you don't understand what he would do to me if I told you" she sniffled.

"I won't tell him you told" she insisted.

"I was 15, when my mom and I moved in. He was 17. He would come in my room and make me do things. Finally I told him if he didn't stop i would tell mom and dad what he was doing. He told me he would stop and told me he was going to tell mom and dad the truth. I was so relieved it was over i didn't even realize he'd set the garage on fire until it was too late. That's how I lost my sight." she said.

Yvonne was speechless. She didn't know what to believe. She went home to confront Toby.

"What do you mean you never told her?! How could you have not told her?!" she heard Spencer's voice from outside the unfinished house.

"I didn't want her to know" he yelled "you wouldn't know if you hadn't watched the movie that sick freak made"

"But it was better that i did know" spencer said "how are you possibly going to keep this from her?"

"I managed to go a year and a half without bringing it up."he said

"I still think you should tell her, it will make you closer the way it did us."

"Do you think i liked it?" he said angrily. "I hated myself when i was with you"

"Don't say that, you don't mean it" she was sobbing.

"I loved being with you, you know that but i hated being vulnerable and the idea of living it all over again with yvonne"

"You balled your eyes out the first time we made love, and i thought i'd done something wrong" she sobbed.

Yvonne peeked around the corner to see toby cupping her face

"You didnt do anything wrong" he said.

"And what about all those nights you woke up screaming and i had to rock you to sleep"

"It's over, i'm all better now" he said.

Spencer looked like she was mulling something over.

"Spencer don't" he warned.

"Toby..." she started

"You promised you would never bring it up again" he added

"Ok i won't but if something happens to Yvonne because you were too proud to tell her about your past you will never forgive yourself."

Spencer left wiping her eyes. Spencer was on her computer 2 hours later when there was knock at the door.

She opened the door to see Toby's red puffy face.

"I'm not ok" he sniffled coming into the barn. Spencer got him a cool washcloth for his neck and some hot cocoa. She took him to the bed where they always cuddled pulling his head into her chest and rubbing his back saying "shh it's ok, baby  

Comment and let me know what you think so far.