*this story is not mine *
There was a baby sitter watching a little girl while her parents were at dinner. The girl was eating ice cream. She asked the babysitter to get her some fudge from the basement. She shrugged and said ok. She went down and saw a little girl standing out the window. She thought nothing of it. She then went back upstairs. The little girl asked for sprinkles. The sitter sighed and went down.
She saw the girl again but this time in a red cape. Again, she thought nothing of it and thought she was playing dress up. When she got back up the little girl asked for a cherry. The sitter was now annoyed but went back down to get one. She again saw the girl but this time with a knife. She rushed up the stairs without the cherry and called the police and explained.
The young girl asked for a cherry again and the sitter decided to get it so the little girl would not worry. The girl in the red cape now held a bloody knife. She ran back up the stairs only to find the girl she was babysitting dead. The police soon got there with the parents and the sitter explained. The mom sobbing said, "We don't have windows in our basement. Only mirrors."