Black Butler Preferences and Oneshots {Complete}

You Surprise Them With A Kitten {Requested}

Ciel Phantomhive: "Look, Ciel! Look what Sebastian got me!" You showed him the small kitten in your hands. Ciel immediately started sneezing.

"Sebastian! Ah-choo! Why did you do that?!" Ciel said in between sneezes. 

"Lady Y/N wanted me too," Sebastian replied.

"Y/N!" Ciel glared at you.

"But look how cute it is!"

Sebastian Michaelis: "Surprise, Sebastian!" you said, pulling a kitten out from behind your back.

"How wonderful! I better add this to my collection," Sebastian said, picking up the kitten.

"Your what?" You stared at him, thinking you misheard.

"Oh, nothing, my dear!"

Alois Trancy: "Lookie, Y/N! I got you something!" Alois cheerfully said, skipping into the room, kitten in tow.

"Oh, it's so cute!" you replied, picking up the kitten.

"Make sure you don't make me angry; you'll never know what I might do," Alois warned, eyes glancing evilly at the kitten.

"Right..."

Claude Faustus: You hummed as you stroked your kitten's fur.

"What is that?" Claude asked, showing the smallest amount of surprise.

"It's a kitten!" you answered.

"It looks like a disease."

"Claude, that's not nice!" you scolded, as the kitten hissed at Claude.

"I don't like you either," Claude growled at the cat.

Undertaker: "Look, Adrian! It's a kitten!" you pointed out.

A small, white kitten was huddling next to a box. It gazed at you with a forlorn look.

"Can we keep it?" you pleaded, tugging Undertaker.

He laughed. "It looks so sad. I better cheer it up."

You smiled, knowing that was a "yes".

William T. Spears: "William, you do know that you're actually depressed?"

"No, I'm not."

"Yes, you are," you continued, "so I got you a gift."

"Oh, god; what is it?"

"A kitten!" You gave him a kitten as you beamed.