When we were young (a Starkid fanfiction)

Decisions and surprises

''Audrey, wake up.''

''Mhhmm...go away...''

''Come on, get up.''

''Leave me alone mom.''

''It's not your mom'' a voice chuckled.

''Ha?'' I replied getting my head up and looking at the person in front of me. ''What are you doing here?''

''I suppose you don't remember, but you invited me for breakfast last night'' Tyler replied smiling, sitting on my bed.

''Right'' I said remembering the conversation, ''but why did you come so early? And how did you get to my room?''

''It's not early, it's 11 o'clock'' he answered, ''and your mom let me up. She said I have a better chance of getting you out of bed.''

''Great'' I said sarcastically, stretching, and then I slowly got out of bed, ''just give me a minute'' I added walking towards the bathroom.

''I'll give you ten if I can look a minute longer'' he replied smirking. Damn. I forgot what I was wearing. I never sleep in my pajama, only in girl boxers and some kind of t-shirt. So Tyler must have had a good view at my ass. I just turned around, rolled my eyes at him, and continued to the bathroom. I quickly brushed my teeth and washed my face, and made my hair into a messy bun. Unfortunately, I had no clothes in the bathroom so I had to go back in the bedroom like this again.

''Don't you dare make a comment'' I said to him the very moment I walked back in. And he didn't, but he still watched me and smirked satisfied. I grabbed my leggings and a plain long sleeved t-shirt from the closet and put it on as fast as I could. ''Now we can talk'' I said, this time smiling.

''If you say so'' he teased once more, but then continued the conversation normally, ''okay, from what I understood last nigh, you're screwed.''

''Yeah, I agree'' I replied nodding, ''so, do I bring breakfast here or?''

''I think that's a good idea, I have a feeling this is gonna last long.''

And so I went down, made us coffee, grabbed some cookies, fruit and a bunch of other stuff I though might be good for breakfast.

''Thank you'' Tyler replied when I handed him the coffee, and put the snacks on the bed next to us. ''And now begin'' he added.

''Well, basically, I've been with Brian a few times behind Joey's back...'' I started, and then explained the whole thing to him. My feeling towards both of them, my every conversation with Brian, every single detail I could remember. ''...and I just can't keep doing this anymore. It's not fair to Joey, it's not fair to any of them. But I really, really don't know what to do'' I finished, exhausted from all the talking.

''You've got to make up you're mind doll'' he finally spoke.

''Yeah, I know, I just don't know who to choose.''

''Well, I'm not an expert in these thing, we both know that, but I have an idea. Who do you think about more?''

''I...I don't understand, I think about both of them.''

''No, I mean when you're let's say at home, doing some random stuff, who come to your mind first?''

''Joey...'' I replied without even thinking, 'cause that was the truth.

''I think you have your answer.''

''That simple? Tyler this is not about choosing which shoes to wear.''

''I know'' he replied, ''but I believe it is that simple.''

''And what if I'm wrong?'' I asked worried.