What if Hiccup had fallen into the water with the mysterious bounty hunter and Ryker succeeds in stabbing Hiccup.
Hiccup feel into the icy water with the mysterious man. His prosthetic no longer on his left leg and the current pulling him under the water. Hiccup tries to stay up but then hits his head on a rock. He immediately passed out and washed up on the sand.
"Oh look who it is boys. It's our lucky day." Ryker said as he dragged the unconscious Hiccup to the meeting point. He soon saw the dragon riders and started retreating.
"DRAGON RIDERS! RETREAT!" Ryker yelled. The dragon riders landed and Ryker threw Hiccup to the ground. Toothless shoots Ryker in the dragon protected armor. He is ready to kill Ryker before Stoick stops him.
Everyone immediately runs to Hiccup to make sure he is okay. They see the bleeding gash on the side of this head and start hoisting him up onto Toothless. But before they can Ryker takes out his dagger and throws it towards Hiccup, in bedding it into his back. Everyone one stopped as Hiccup's knees buckled and he screamed in pain.
"AAAAAAAAAHHHHHH," He yelled out. Everyone went pale when they saw the dagger sticking out of his back. He went limp again. Astrid checked his pulse and was relieved a little bit.
"He has a pulse guys. Lets hurry and get him back to the Edge." Astrid says. Toothless whines and Stoick flies as fast as he could towards the Edge.
When they got back to the Edge, Hiccup was bandaged and was told to the gang that he would be fine. He needed plenty of rest and would be healed soon.