The Outsiders Imagines and Preferences

Ponyboy x Johnny x Dallas~Jallyboy Imagine

This was requested by @ShaynaShepard5

Pony's POV

I was walking with the most beautiful and fantastic people I know, Johnny and Dally. I love them so much it almost kills me if I don't see at least one of them for a day. We were currently walking to the Dingo to get a milkshake to share with each other because why not? All three of us were walking side by side, Dallas was in the middle and he didn't care if people foubd out if he was queer. Just because he's gay doesn't mean he ain't soft enough to kick someone's ass if they are any sort of threat, at least that's what he says. Johnny is as shy as always, so he's always wary about holding hands or kissing in public, he doesn't want to be made fun of by other people. Dallas and I always make sure to tell and show him that it doesn't matter if people know, as long as we're happy. Most people have never seen a three-way relationship before but you only live once right? Fuck what they think.

As we are a couple of blocks from the Dingo, Dallas's hands intertwines with Johnny's and mine. I smile up at him and he kisses my forehead, he looks over at Johnny and brings his hand up to his lips. Johnny blushes so adorablely, I fall into his gaze and Johnny blushes more. I giggle and Dallas chuckles, I love this hood's laugh too.

"I think we might of uh...broke him" Dallas chuckles at Johnny, I giggle. "Ah-Shut up! It's not my fault you guys make me feel this way..." He blushes majorly, I walk over to his side and kiss his cheek. "But, we love your shyness and innocence...right Dal?" I ask to get his true opinion. He smirks and pulls us into a hug, I make sure to wrap my arms around both of them.

"I love both of ya innocent beautiful minds.." He kisses our foreheads and we melt inside. Dallas doesn't care about what people think, hell! He even TRIES to show us off to the world, no matter what nasty glares we get. It don't really bother me at all, these boys are my life. We walk into the Dingo, hand in hand, people already staring. I hear a few mumbles from some people, I ignore the pitiful comments and we continue to walk up to the register. We order and sit down in a booth, Dallas on one side and me and Johnny on the other.

"How come Johnny gets to sit with you?" Dallas asks dramtically, I giggle and put my arm around the blushing greaser. "Because yesterday Johnny was around you more often than me, today is my turn..and tomorrow I spend most of my time with you~" I flirt with him and wink. He smirks and his hand makes his way to my thigh, I kind of squeal and he smirks more.

"Ok, lover boy~" My cheeks turn pink and this time Johnny kisses my cheek. "Your cute when you're blushing too~" he whispers into my ear. I blush even more, these two boys are teaming up on me. Dallas's hand runs up and down my thigh and then he takes it back. Johnny laid his head at the crook of my neck, he was about to leave little love bites but the waiter came and served us our milkshake. Thank god he came or else I wouldn't be able to control myself. We pop three straws into the shake and start drinking from it, it was pretty good.

After we finish our milkshake, we lean back and talk about the latest news running through town. That is until someone walked up to our booth and chuckled.

"Well, well, well, looky who we have here~" All three of us looked up to see Paul and his two soc minions behind him. Dallas scowled and glared at the blond soc and so did I, Johnny got nervous and held onto me. "What do ya want Paul?" Dallas growled, Paul smirked. "Geez! I thought I'd never see the day where Dallas Winston is a faggot, I must be lucky!" He exclaimed, some people from the restaurant glanced at the scene. "Ok, and? You got a problem, man?" He snarled, I don't really like seeing Dallas angry but you gotta do what ya gotta do.

"You've grown soft Winston" Paul stated. Dallas chuckled. "Just because I'm queer doesn't mean I ain't still gonna kick ur ass" Dallas threatened, Paul scoffed and looked over at me, I pulled Johnny closer to me. "Hey..I know you...ur Darry's kid brother right?" He asked, my eyes narrowed. "Why does that matter?" I growled.

"Me and ur brother used to go to highschool together, we played football with each other" Paul stated. I glared at him some more and he chuckled. "If ya guys keep going out together, imma have no choice but ta tell ur brother about this" Paul smirked and pointed at me. I held tight onto Johnny and looked over at Dal, he was still glaring at Paul.

"You fucker! Get outta here!" Dallas shouted, enough to make the whole restaurant turn and look. Paul smirked and walked out of the Dingo. "Dallas..?" I started. His scowl quickly turned into a concerned expression. "Yes babe?" He asked. "He what he said was true...I don't want Darry to know...if he finds out that I'm gay then-he'll break us up for sure...I don't wamt that, I love both of ya so much, it'll break me..." I admitted, Dallas sighed. "Here...let's get back the the lot, we'll talk over there.." He suggested, Johnny and I both nodded our heads and we walked out, leaving a tip for the waiter since he didn't make fun of us.

****

We arrived at the vacant lot and all of us talked through our problems and concerns. It was nice to get some things off my chest. We were cuddled up against each other. Johnny was in between Dallas's legs and I was in between Johnny's, Dallas had an iron grip on both of us. He kept on giving us little kisses and telling us everything was gonna be alright, whispering comforting things in our ears. I felt safe whenever Johnny or Dallas was around, but when all of us were together, there's nothing more that I want.

Hey! Hope I met your standards on this fluffy chapter! To be honest I'm kind of proud of this chapter! Comment down below on how I did please?!

Love ya guys! STAY GOLD!💕💕💕😘😘😘😊😊😊