Quinn Fabray: My Story

Chapter 53 - The Proposals

Authors Note: This chapter combines both 'Yes/No' and 'Michael' episodes with a few twists on them. I hope you enjoy :)

The next Glee Club rehearsal Mr. Schue was writing on the board 'MARRY ME?'. "Yes, I am proposing to Miss Pillsbury," Mr. Schue said as we all cheered in the choir room excited for Mr. Schue and Miss Pillsbury. Their relationship had been through its ups and downs but I always had a feeling they would end up together. "This is the kind of news that you share with your family, and you guys are my family," Mr. Schue smiled a bit.

"Mr. Schue, we're so happy for you," Finn grinned. "We totally don't think you'll screw it up this time," Brittany said as Mr. Schue laughed a bit. "Here's the thing: it's got to be perfect. I'm sitting down with Emma's parents to ask for permission, and then this proposal needs to knock her well-washed socks off. And that's where you guys come in, okay? So the assignment for the week is to come up with a proposal number," Mr. Schue said as we all looked at each other excitedly "And you know Miss Pillsbury-- it's got to be perfect." "Well, you can count on us, Mr. Schue," Artie grinned as the bell rang. "Alright," Mr. Schue grinned as we exited the choir room.

There we so many love songs that quickly came to my mind. I had always been a romantic so I wanted to help Mr. Schue find the perfect song to sing to Miss Pillsbury. I felt if anything the song should be something heartfelt, something he would sing to her. It was then I thought of the perfect song 'Can't Help Falling in Love' by Elvis Presley.

"Wise men say only fools rush in but I can't help falling in love with you. Oh, shall I stay, would it be a sin. Oh, if I can't help falling in love with you? Like a river flows, surely to the sea. Darling, so it goes, some things are meant to be. Take my hand, take my whole life too. Oh, for I can't help falling in love with you," I sang thinking of Mr. Schue and Miss Pillsbury as I got into the second verse I couldn't help but think of the 3 people I was torn between. I pictured myself singing this song to Puck, Sam, and Rachel. "Oh, like a river flows, surely to the sea. Darling, so it goes, some things are meant to be. Oh, take my hand, take my whole life too for I can't help falling in love with you. Oh, for I can't help falling in love with you," I sang in front of everyone in the choir room as they all cheered for me.

"Quinn, that was such a beautiful song," Mr. Schue smiled. "I just thought it would be the perfect proposal song, Mr. Schue," I smiled a bit. "It is a beautiful song but I was kind of hoping for more of a group number but good effort though," Mr. Schue smiled a bit as I took my seat.

As the week went on Rachel had a solo she had prepared for 'Without You'. Her voice sounded stunning on the song. I couldn't help smiling watching her perform. I knew she was singing to Finn but I couldn't help wishing the song was to me. "Nice," Mr. Schue grinned as we all cheered for Rachel. Finn walked up to Rachel and they started pretty much making out in front of us. "You know, I just wanted to say that I thought that you blew that song out of the water and totally nailed the assignment. Oh, no, wait, wait a second. Was-- the assignment wasn't "Make everything about Rachel Berry and force everyone to watch," was it?," Santana smirked as Rachel and Finn stopped kissing. "Easy, Santana. It's fine," Mr. Schue said as he got up "That was beautiful, Rachel." "So, Mr. Schue, what do you think? We've given you a whole bevy of songs to choose from, from upbeat and awesome to a little overwrought for my taste," Artie said. "They've all been incredible, you guys. I think I just need a little more time to really consider my choices," Mr. Schue nodded as the bell rang.

I began to get my things where I was stopped by Santana. "Okay we need to talk," Santana said. "There's nothing to talk about," I said quickly trying to brush her off. "First of all there is a lot to talk about since when have you decided making goo-goo eyes at Berry was a thing?" Santana asked folding her arms. "You're crazy," I said shaking my head. Had I been that obvious? "Oh please. You need to be more careful with your leering Fabray. I know," Santana said. "Know what?" I asked. "That you're in love with Berry," Santana said. "Keep it down," I said as I pulled Santana over. "So you're not denying it," Santana said. "Look. I'd be lying if I said I didn't have any feelings for Rachel. My feelings for her are...confusing but yes I do have them," I sighed. "You know I always knew there was more to you being so bitchy towards her about Finn," Santana smirked. "Okay I get it you always knew. Can we just keep this between us?" I asked. "For now," Santana shrugged as she walked off.