Veronica, Betty, Kevin, Toni, Cheryl, sweet pea and fangs were all sitting on the couches in Veronica's living room at night and decided to play a little game.
"Ive never been drunk before", "I kissed someone here other then Jughead, and I drank expired milk so I wouldn't have to go to school" betty looked down in her lap kinda embarrassed and her cheeks starting to redden.
"Oh cmon b, that's the worst you've done" Veronica said as she rolled her eyes "Cheryl you go instead" Veronica smirked to Toni, wanting Cheryl to spill some dirty secrets about them. Cheryl has a lot to hide so she was busy trying to think which ones would be the least embarrassing to tell.
"Cmon Cheryl, I know you and Toni did some kinky shit." Kevin looked at Cheryl and sipped the orange liquid in his cup. "It shouldn't be that hard to think of"
Everyone was looking at Cheryl with a smirk. Especially her girlfriend who put her hand on her thigh and leaned over to whisper something in her ear.
Cheryl's mouth gapped open after Toni leaned away and she looked at her girlfriend as her cheeks reddened. Sweet pea and fangs looked at each other and smirked just imagining what it could be.
"I've used handcuffs" Kevin, Veronica and Betty all looked at Cheryl surprised.
*cough* "Toni" *cough* sweet pea said under his breath slightly and Toni just winked at him.
"I've done it in Veronica's room and I've called Toni daddy" cheryl looked over to Veronica who had a facial expression of pure disgust probably because Cheryl said she had sex in her room.
"Handcuffs are a lie" fangs blurred out. Everyone looked at Toni to see her reaction.
"Why are you guys looking at her maybe she's not the person I've used them with" Cheryl said simply as she kissed Toni on the cheek.
"Cheryl, we all know you've only had sex with Toni" Veronica raised her eyebrow.
"I saw you've never done it in my room... that one better be the lie" Veronica gave Cheryl and Toni a look to say I'm going to kill you.
"Why is know one saying that me calling Toni daddy is a lie" Cheryl questioned everyone.
"We all know your a pillow princess" Kevin chuckled.
"I'm pretty sure you told me a story like this Toni" sweet pea said.
"Which one do you think is the lie Toni" betty asked Toni.
"I'm not permitted to say" Toni answered simply and grabbed Cheryl's Hand from beside her.
"Well take a vote, who think the handcuffs is the lie" Cheryl asked and Kevin, fangs and Betty raised their hands. "Who thinks Veronica's room is a lie" Veronica immediately raises her hand while crossing her fingers because she might never sleep in that room again if it's true. Sweet pea also rose his hand.
"You can relax Veronica, your bedroom is the lie" Toni smirked. Veronica let out a huge sigh of relief and everyone chuckled except for Kevin who still had a shocked expression on his face from the handcuffs thing being real.
"So Toni want to tell us what the handcuffs were about" sweet pea questioned the pink haired girl.
"Well you see-" Toni started but was cut off by her girlfriend putting a hand on her mouth.
"All I'll say is, is that Cheryl calling me daddy and the handcuffs were at the same time" Cheryl slapped her girlfriends arm. Toni chuckled and kissed Cheryl's lips as the embarrassed look disappeared.
"Didn't know cheryl likes the kinky shit" fangs and sweet pea both laughed together.
"Alright Veronica" Toni clapped her hands together to break the now awkward silence. "Your turn"
"I've had a threesome, smoked pot and had sex on the beach... a public beach with people there" everyone starred at Veronica being so blatant and upfront. Although everyone in the group could probably agree that they expected Veronica to say stuff like this.
"Are you sure one of these is a lie" Kevin asked Veronica.
Veronica threw her empty pop can at Kevin. He just stuck his middle finger up in return.
"Who says beach is a lie" nobody raised their hand.
"What about smoking pot" only Betty raised her hand.
"Oh cmon Betty we all know Veronica has smoked pot" Cheryl said and Betty just shrugged.
"Betty's the only one who got it right" Veronica laughed and everyone one was shocked.
"Wait how did betty know which one was right" Toni looked at betty then thinking of why her mouth dropped wide open.
"OMG, Betty was there" Toni yelled standing up and pointing at betty.
"Betty you had sex with Veronica at the beach" Kevin gasped.
"No she was at the threesome with me" Veronica answered. Everyone's jaw was in the ground, mean while Betty had her hands covering her face from the blush, making her skin as bright as Cheryl's hair.
"Wow Betty had a threesome. Did not expect that" Veronica kissed Betty's cheek and she just tucked her face into her sweater.
"Who was this threesome with" Toni asked
"My bets on Archie" Kevin and sweet pea said
"No way, it was definitely Jughead" Fangs, Toni and Cheryl agreed.
"It wasn't either of them, this was when all of us were on a break" Veronica answered with everyone looking at them confused
"HOLY SHIT WAS IT-" Kevin yelled but was interrupted by Veronica
"Alight looks like we're out of drink, let's go get some Betty" Veronica grabbed Betty's hand and leaded her away from the group.
"Oh their defiantly going to fuck" fangs laughed.
AN- Oof this turned more into a Beronica thing but I kinda like it and I also hate it so idk. It also kinda sucks tho🤷♀️. Also have fun guessing who they had their threesome with.
