Imagines [Book Three]

Teen Wolf [Theo X Reader]

Imagine being Scott's sister and falling in love with Theo. In a fight with an encroaching Pack, you get severely injured. Can Scott be persuaded to give you the bite or will he let the past repeat itself?
For  @Squish98 

. .

. .

Falling for Theo had been the last thing you'd expected to ever happen. When he'd returned to Beacon Hills just in the nick of time to help out your brother when the Dread Doctors first released one of their experiments, you'd been grateful. You didn't care that he had claws, fangs, and yellow eyes. In fact, you didn't care about his cocky attitude and instead found it rather attractive at times.

But you did start to care that it seemed he was pitting Scott's pack against their alpha and that didn't sit well with you. Theo had become an actual monster and you were heartbroken when it came out that he was working with the Dread Doctors to bring down your brother and resurrect The Beast of Gevaudan. While the pack either gloated or were speechless about Theo's betrayal, it was Scott who comforted you because he knew you and Theo were once close before the Raeken's had moved away. Then Theo disappeared which was good for Stiles' peace of mind, but there was a part of you that was sad all over again.

Ghost Riders came into the picture soon after and wreaked havoc on your hometown, kidnapping locals left and right (though no one knew anyone went missing because everyone's memories were being altered), and Theo was suddenly back. Only this time, Theo was a lesser version of himself and it seemed wherever he was did a number on him because he was terrified of going back. And when no one wanted anything to do with him, you found yourself with a shadow as Theo took to dogging your footsteps and catching up on all that he'd missed.

It was then everyone saw a different side to Theo, he doing his best to earn everyone's trust and even sacrificing himself to the Ghost Riders when they'd cornered him and Liam. His newfound loyalty to the Pack and Beacon Hills did a lot to appease Scott somewhat, and it even got your brother off your back about all the times Theo had hung out at your house.

Then something terrible came, exposing the supernatural side of Beacon Hills to the humans and instilling fear into them all. War broke out between hunters and supernatural beings, and the humans who were in contact with supernatural beings got caught in the middle. Fighting humans was a lot different than defending yourself against a supernatural being, and you were grateful Theo stuck close to help you out when your fellow students started targeting you because of your connection to Scott.

Not a single member of the pack trusted Theo as far as they could throw him, and you completely understood their opinions, but you warmed completely when he stayed to help Mason in the underground tunnels and when he found it in himself to finally take someone's pain away as they were dying. Theo was completely changed after that and though you offered to forgive him for his past deeds, you also mentioned you'd never forget.

Several months down the line, it was Theo who made it his mission to completely win you over. And when he eventually did several more months later, you were at a complete loss when he kissed you and confessed his feelings. He left the ball completely in your court and against almost everyone's wishes, you agreed to date him.