Wrong Choice (Darkiplier x Reader)

𝟓 - 𝐓𝐡𝐞 𝐆𝐨𝐨𝐝 𝐈𝐧 𝐌𝐞

Like a knife in the woods, you hunt down the good in me

♔(Y/N)'s POV♔

Darkness. Darkness was the only thing that filled my vision. Nothing but faded memories of events came to mind. My watery eyes opened and I was in a dark room where the floor felt like ice to the touch. And there were grey, cold chains around my soft, delicate ankles and wrists. Oh fuck. No way. What? I was with Mark on a date and then... I forgot about what had happened... My eyes tried to adjust to everything and as I tilted my head up, I was met with the man himself who trapped me here: Dark.

"I see you have awoken, my love," Dark gave me a toothy grin. He continued, "I know that Mark trusts you. And I know that he loves you. And he tried to keep me at bay from coming out and taking you for myself. Well, we see how that went."

♔ f l a s h b a c k ♔

Everything was set in stone the moment I purchased tickets to PAX to see Jack and Mark! I was so excited when I walked into the venue with my best friend (B/F/N)!

"(Y/N)! Look! They're right there!" (B/F/N) pointed to where Jack and Mark were as they were welcoming fans into their arms, giving them a loving embrace. I always admired how dedicated and grateful they were to their fanbase. And that is why the two of them are my favorite YouTubers and always will be. (I edited the Sh*ne Daws*n part out cause fuck him)

Before (B/F/N) and I knew it, we were in front of the line, 1 second away from meeting our idols. "Next!" the worker called. hOLY FUCKING SHITVDHHGHDHVDHVHDVHNDGHGHFDHGFHDGFHGDFHGDFHGFDHGD THIS IS ACTUALLY HAPPENING. THIS IS REAL. OHMYGOD. I FEEL LIKE I'M GONNA FAINT.

We walked towards Jack and Mark. (B/F/N) went over to Jack and me to Mark. And oh no, oh no, oh no. My face grew hot and I felt my body tense and warm up. "Hey? Are you alright?" Mark said softly to me. VJFGJCJFJFHGFFCMHCFJFHGFJHNCJFJYF. "Mark, I don't feel so good..."

♔...♔

I opened my eyes. Where was I? "Hello? Are you awake?" I heard a familiar voice say. It took me a bit, but my blurry vision cleared up and I was met eye to eye with the man of my dreams: Mark. I smiled a bit as I gazed into his soft, brown eyes. He looked way better up close. Much softer and gentler than he appeared on camera. And oh lord, he looked very tall and big from where I was laying.

I nodded, "I'm awake now... And I'm enjoying the view..." 

I saw a hint of red decorate Mark's cheeks and he turned away, trying to hide it. "S-She's awake now!" Mark called out, completely avoiding what had just happened. Did I, (Y/N) (L/N), just make the Mark Fischbach blush? What a turn of events in my lame life...

A doctor came over and I gulped nervously. "What happened to me that made me end up here?" I asked. 

"Well, Mark claimed that as soon as you met him, your face grew red and you started sweating recklessly. Then you told him that you didn't feel good and passed out. At least, that is what Mark told me."

Now the same blush that Mark had was spread across my face. "Well, am I okay?" I asked. 

The doctor looked at me with a blank expression, "Yes. Your heart rate and blood pressure are perfectly normal. And your body temperature is at a perfect 98 degrees. You might have just passed out from over-exhaustion from the convention and once you saw Mark and got excited, you passed out."

I nodded. "Am I free to go?"

"Yes, we will send the medical bill in a week. Please get some rest when you get home so you won't pass out again. Oh! And drink plenty of water." The doctor said. 

I smiled, "Thank you!"

Mark took my hand, "Here. Let me walk you out to your car. " I gulped nervously and nodded. I got up and we walked out of the medical center that was located in the convention building. We saw (B/F/N) waiting anxiously by my Honda Civic. 

She turned around and saw us, running towards me, "(Y/N)!"

She hugged me tightly. "Thank God you're okay!" (B/F/N) said gratefully. She then looked at Mark,  "Thank you for taking care of her. As her best friend, I'm very thankful that you have a big enough heart to drop everything and take care of a fan."

Mark smiled, "Ah it's no problem. Can't have any of my fans getting hurt, can I?" His brown eyes met my soft (E/C) ones, "Can I have your number? I wanna keep in touch with you to make sure you're okay."

I blushed crimson, "Y-Yeah! Of course!" 

"Great!" Mark reached into his pocket and pulled out his phone, opening the contacts and giving it to me, "Here!"

I took his phone and put my digits and name in. I then handed it back to him, "There."

Mark smiled, "Thanks! I have to get back to the con. I, uh, I'll text you later?" 

"Y-Yeah of course!"

♔ p r e s e n t d a y ♔

"I never found any woman or man so enticing till I met you, my love. Now, I want your heart. And I won't stop until I get it." Dark said, smirking as his hair fell in his face and his black eyes met mine. Uh, what the fuck? Is he fucking crazy? "No, (Y/N), I am not crazy," Dark said out of the blue. Oh lord! Did he just read my mind?? "Of course I did, I'm a demon. Not a mere mortal like you." Darks words were filled with so much poison, I couldn't even explain it myself. "You have such good in you, (Y/N). Such a pure heart. Purer than anything else I've ever seen." Dark's grey hand grabbed my chin gently, forcing me to look at him.

Oh god. I hope I can stay alive because, at this point, I feel like I'm gonna die here. Dark's black eyes flashed little bits of blue and red as if they were filled with untouched desire, "The good in you tempted Mark and me. And of course, stupid Mark could feel me trying to take over his body. I will admit, it is my fault, it's also your fault for stumbling into his life."

"My fault? My fault!? I didn't ask for any of this to happen! I didn't ask for you and Mark to fall in love with me! All I did was pass out at a convention when I met him and that's how this whole shit storm happened," I raised my voice more than usual to defend myself from the bullshit that just spewed out of the mouth of that demon. "I refuse to let you stand here and tell me that this is my fault, you fucking demon!" 

Dark chuckles to himself, "Feisty one, aren't you? I might have to teach you how to behave like the good, obedient girl you are. You're all mine now, my love. Mark may be gone for now, but I am here till he comes back." His fingers stroked the side of my face as I tried to strike him, but the chains around my wrists stopped me from doing so.

"Falling in love with someone, albeit a human, is something out of character for me. Almost as if you've made me forget a part of myself. But, I am still the ruthless monster you all claim me to be." Dark smirked, a fang appearing a bit from the corner of his lips. 

He let go of my chin and I spit in his face, "I'll never be yours! Never!" 

Dark laughs as he gets up and walks to the cell door, "You made the wrong choice. Now all of your good is mine."