Supernatural Thoughts and Quotes or How big of an asshole God really is

5x22 Swan Song

Chuck's Monologue: "So what's it all add up to? It's hard to say, but me I'd say this was a test for Sam and Dean and I think they did alright. Up against good, evil, angels, devils, destiny and God himself. They made their own choice, they chose family... and, well, isn't that kind of the whole point? [THE END] No doubt endings are hard, but then again nothing ever really ends, does it?"

I wanted to believe God (27) here so badly, because he speaks the truth directly from my heart about the show, what's it all about etc. but when I knew that this was God who said that, God the cruel, capricious writer it confused me so much, because how can someone so evil say something so touching and empathetic towards Sam and Dean? Then it hit me: "God's a writer, writers lie". So why should we now believe a word he says?

This whole speech is to lure the boys and the readers to the false premise that family is what's truly important and standing up against destiny, so he can preserve the image of a loving, a caring God and not the sadistic Sociopath that he really is. This means that almost every word he says here is probably a lie: maybe it was indeed a test, but they didn't do alright in his eyes, 'cause they did exactly what he didn't want a rebellion against destiny and how everything is supposed to be in God's story. 

Furthermore I am certain he didn't appreciate that they went up against him although he invested so much in their obedience and to abolish free will. They did in fact make their own choice, which God didn't want but nevertheless went along with it, because it may not have been his idea of a story ending, but it was still entertaining, moreover it gave him the opportunity to continue his story and continue screwing up the Winchester's lives like he implies at the end of his monologue. 

The point he makes about family being "the whole point" is either foreshadowing for Amara and how in the actual end it comes down to him and his family starting a new universe, being the sole, omnipotent leaders of everything together (28) or whatever he may have planned. Or he once again lied straight to our faces, because, yeah sure family is one of the main issues in his story and therefore important, but it is not his main topic which would be destiny vs. free will – God vs. TFW – and who wins in the end.(29)

(27) Who is still Chuck at this point

(28) If they aren't already

(29) Obviously it's going to be God, cause it's still his story and even if the apocalypse didn't happen the way he wanted, he is still convinced that he has full power over the Winchesters, over every little choice and every aspect of their lives. Back then he didn't know that the premature ending with the ghost apocalypse is how it's going to go down, but whatever the end of his story is going to look like, God is always in control of the outcome, because he is, well, God. But is that still the case? With Jack, Billy, the Empty and his bullet wound is he still able to make the whole world follow his orders, is everything still going as he planned it so brilliantly as the *cough* fabulous writer he is, or are the Winchesters actually going to win, to end him and his tyrannical reign on earth? Once again the question stays: TFW or God? Who is it going to be in the end?