Fake dating Stilinski

Seventeen

Eleanor's P.O.V

I walk to Leena's car with a bright smile on my face. I open her car door then climb in shutting it as I notice my best friend holding a small shopping bag close to her. I squeeze my brows together looking at her then the bag. She snickers a laugh then tosses the bag to me.

"Open it," She demands still keeping her eyes out towards the windshield.

I shake my head out of curiosity and when I open it I scoff taking the item out of the bag. I hold it up to Leena as she turns her head to me as the snickering continues.

"What? I know what you guys did. Why else would you sleep overnight at a party?" She winks at me.

I shake my head turning away laughing. My best friend really got me a plan-B pill.

-------

"So... What are you guys now?" My best friend asked as she let me shower at her place and wear her clothes. I wasn't exactly ready to go back home just yet. Especially taking the pill while my mom and dad would be home wouldn't be so great so at least I can hide the carton in Leena's garbage instead of mine.

I didn't exactly think my first time would happen anytime soon. I even turned down Isaac about sex but I didn't turn it down for a second with Stiles. 

I huff out a breath tossing a chip in my mouth, "I don't know."

"Can you walk me through it?" My best friend questioned changing the channel on her radio. "Don't miss out on any of the dirty details." She winked.

I scoffed as I sat up to nudge her in the arm. I rolled my eyes playfully as I sat back down.

"Stiles found me outside playing basketball with Isaac and he just got so mad so he grabbed my hand taking me upstairs. And of course, I'm like 'what the hell Stiles'" I spoke out and Leena nodded her head understanding. "So he mimicked me and said that I know what has been going on with him because of me. So I was saying I was out there with Isaac blah blah then" I bite my lower lip at the memory as I look down. I breathed out smiling, "I said what are you going to do about it then he kissed me I kissed him then... You know, and guess what he said in the middle of it?" I questioned meeting my best friend's gaze. I nibbled on my bottom lip playing with my fingers.

"What?" She asked finally finding a station to listen to.

I sighed, "he said 'I love you Eleanor pace,'" I finished trying too hard my smirk.

Leena's eyes widened. "No! He said that during sex?!" She questioned sitting up on her knees.

I laughed, "Um yeah, and I said it back..." I spoke my tone getting lower.

My best friend's jaw dropped open a gasp escaping the back of her throat. Leena hopped off her bed holding her mouth closed clasped behind her two hands. She was repeating "Omg" many- many times.

Finally, she came back sitting on the bed her chest rising and falling. "Nora! This is big! He finally said it and so did you!"

I scoffed, my feelings I was hiding coming out. I sat up against her wall looking down at my hands. "Well, I don't think that was a proper way to get on better terms with someone. Sure we both said I love you but that doesn't mean that makes everything better between us. Yes, I'm no longer pissed with him but he still thinks I slept with Isaac and I still think things will never be okay between us." I explained my heart-wrenching. After yesterday there was nothing more I wanted than to be held by Stiles day and night.

Leena sighed scooting closer to me looking at me, "I get it Nora but if you feel that way why don't you go speak to him then? Tell him the truth and maybe then everything will be better."

I nodded my head lightly.

"Can I ask you a question?" Leena asked her tone tender.

I nodded my head.

Leena inhaled then exhaled, "do you have any feelings at all for Isaac?"

I had a feeling that question would come sooner or later. I look up this time meeting my best friend's gaze. I begin to shake my head, "No, I don't. It feels weird all these years I've been in love with him and the feelings are just gone."

She chuckles, "that's life, Nora. You never know what it will throw at you sometimes you will like it sometimes you won't. And I think overcoming this giant crush on Isaac was the best decision you ever made. I see the way Stiles looks at you. He is so in love with you."

I grin at her statement. She's right. "But what about Isaac? I think he has feelings for me now. And I think Stiles still hates him because that night he caught us in Isaac's window. I broke their friendship and it's ruined all because of me." I pout looking down.

"Well, I just think if you tell Isaac how you really feel he'll understand. He seems to act like his old self again thanks to you." She smiles, "and as for Stiles once you tell him about what truly happened that night instead of keeping him in the dark he'll realize he misjudged you. Don't worry Nora. Everything will be just fine."

A/N: Hiii! I hope you enjoyed this chapter :) Remember to vote and comment!