Heathers & Mean Girls X Fem!Reader Oneshots (Discontinued)

Our Love Was God [Chandler] Part 1

Y/N: Your name

H/C: Hair color

E/C: Eye color

Warnings: Swearing

A few months before

[3rd Person POV:]

"Do we have to go to game night?" Heather whined. "Yes, Heather. We have to. They're our friends!" Y/N replied. They were driving to Ronnie's house to have, you guessed it, game night with their friends. "But I wanna go home and cuddle you. Maybe even do something more," Heather winked suggestively. "Only good girls get rewards," Y/N smirked. Heather pouted, "Come on! I won't bite." "Tempting offer but no." The red girl kept on complaining but Y/N still kept on driving to Ronnie's place. When they arrived, they knocked on the door. Ronnie greeted them, "Y/N! Heather! Come on, the whole squad is here!"

Both of them walked further inside the house to see the rest of the Heathers, Ram, Kurt, JD (yes, they're good now, fite me), and even Martha! "Hey, guys!" Y/N smiled. "Hey, Y/N! Hey, Heather!" they all replied excitedly. "Come on, guys! Sit down, we're doing truth or dare." Duke said. "Really, that game? That's for little kids," Heather complained even more. "Aww, come on. It's not that bad," Y/N whispered into her ear. "Sorry about that guys, she's just super grumpy today," Y/N explained. The pair took a seat in the circle of people. "It's okay," Mac said.

After a while, it was Y/N's turn again. "So, Y/N. Truth or dare?" JD asked. "Hmm... I'm gonna have to go with truth. The dares you guys make up are absolutely crazy," Y/N answered. "Boo! You're no fun," Heather laughed. Despite what she thought, the strawberry blonde actually got invested in the game. "Okay, Y/N. What's your greatest fear?" The H/C-haired girl stopped for a second like she was caught off guard. "I guess my greatest fear is for someone to fall out of love with me for the same reasons why they fell for me in the first place.

An uncomfortable silence fell on the group. Heather spoke up after a few seconds of this. "I'll never do that, so you don't need to worry," she said while cuddling into you. Everyone was kind of surprised. Yes, they knew that she was in a secret relationship with you, but Heather was more of an "I like it rough" kind of gal. She never cuddled Y/N around them but mostly just gave passionate kisses, held Y/N's side possessively, and did a lot of PDA if they were alone with the group. The Demon Queen, in the group's eyes, was never gentle and kind. But Y/N changed her a lot.

The E/C-eyed girl kissed Heather's forehead and hugged back. After a few more rounds, the group decided to go home. "Thanks, Ronnie! That was super fun!" they all thanked. "Bye, guys!" Y/N and Heather said. Y/N drove Heather home and walked her to the door. "Love you, Heather," the shorter girl kissed Heather on the cheek. "Love you too," Heather kissed back.

Present-day

[Y/N's POV:]

"Hey, hon!" I exclaimed when I climbed inside Heather's room. The only response I got from my girlfriend was one of her signature angry and stern glares. I only laughed and joked "Dreadful etiquette, I know." She just sighed and looked away. "Is it one of those days?" I asked softly, reaching out to her. Heather only slapped my hand away and yelled softly at me. "You're so reckless! Do you know how much trouble I could have been if my parents were here?!" I flinched at her suddenly snapping at me. "But your parents aren't here," I explained.

The angry girl just turned back to whatever she was doing. "I'm sorry, Heather," I mumbled. She just sighed for like the tenth time. Okay, that may be an exaggeration, but still! I sat on her bed and she snapped at me again. "It took me time to fix my bed you know!" I immediately jumped off the red bed and just stood there.