Lemon and Lime

【Cԋαρƚҽɾ 11: Tԋҽσɾყ: Tιƈƈι TσႦყ'ʂ Iԃҽɳƚιƚყ】

Bloody Painter's POV:

Ticci Toby... He looks like Toby, sounds like Toby, acts like Toby, has the same disorders as Toby, and just... Seems like Toby- Tobias Rogers. I started finding evidence that would support the theory of 'Ticci Toby' being Tobias Rogers under the mask.

Ever since I met 'Ticci Toby,' he reminded me of the Toby I knew- Tobias Rogers. The name 'Ticci Toby' itself gave it away. That was what Toby was called in highschool. If 'Ticci Toby' really is Tobias Rogers, then why would he go by the name his bullies called him? Well, it does make sense because of his Tourette..

And that's my next evidence for my theory.

Another thing that gave it away was the fact that he had Tourettes syndrome. Although, just because Toby has it doesn't 100% confirm he is Tobias Rogers. Other people also have Tourettes- not that I know of. Tobias Rogers was the only person I knew who had Tourettes, so 'Ticci Toby' has to be Tobias, right?

Well.. Third thing was- Masky often calls Toby by his last name, which happens to be 'Rogers.' Toby Rogers. That would about sum it up. But what if his real name is just 'Toby?' Well, it'd be real bold to assume that Toby is Tobias Rogers.

Although, the more evidence I have, the more I can prove my theory correct. In fact, I still have some more evidence, though, it is not much.

Toby often comes off as bipolar. Such as getting extremely mad over nothing, then inviting you to eat waffles (which he doesn't like) with him If you question him for that, such as asking, "Waffles?", he'll only remind you that he doesn't like waffles. Another example is being extremely hyped over something, and as soon someone asks what he's happy about, he'll give out a dark response like "death."

He also is completely numb to all physical pain. One time, Masky and Toby got into a fight in the kitchen and were sent to EJ for treatment. They were both injured badly- bleeding and all- but Masky was the only one who felt the pain of his injuries while being patching up; screaming and groaning in pain. Toby, on the other hand, didn't flinch or speak- other than mentioning discomforts such as "EJ don't touch me there" or something along those lines.

Another time, when I waited in the bathroom for Toby to finish showering so that I could shower next, as soon as he came out, I could feel the steamy hot heat from the shower. I could see that his face was red- and he had a gash on his right cheek. His muscular chest was red as well. When I asked him how high he turned the shower on (which determines the temperature,) he told me he put it all the way to the other side. He also said he couldn't feel physical pain, so he can't tell if the water is hot or cold. God, this boy is going to die to water at this rate. He'll die from hypothermia or from being boiled.

Conclusion: Toby can't feel pain, he's bipolar based on my observations, he has Tourettes and possibly some other mental disorders I don't know yet, he looks like Tobias Rogers- and even has the same gash on his right cheek- and he has the same jacket as Tobias Rogers.

Wouldn't this be enough evidence to prove that 'Ticci Toby' is Tobias Rogers?

It would indeed, but I can't be certain that 'Ticci Toby' is Tobias Rogers. Unless I look into his files, I can't be sure. Of course, I can go to Slender and ask for Toby's files, but he'll probably say no. Plus, even if I sneak into his office to find Toby's files and find out Toby's real identity, I would probably be punished for sneaking around for files. Slender might think I'm a spy or something.

"LUNCH TIME."

The door slammed open, I was caught by surprise, quickly closed my art book, and turned around to see an angry Masky at the door. "O-Oh, y-yeah, I'll be there in a bit.." I told him, which he grumbled and said, "I've literally been calling you for half an hour. What got you so wrapped up, you can't hear me banging on your door and screaming that it's lunch time? You didn't even respond."

"Oh, sorry, I got lost in thought." I told him, "I'll be there. Give me a minute."

Masky grumbled and stomped away. I chuckled a bit before adding a few quick doodles before leaving for lunch.

*~~~*-.-*~~~*-.-*~~~*

Bloody Painter's notes [does not include drawing :')]:

Theory: Ticci Toby's Identity

"Ticci Toby"
-Toby (Tobias Rogers) used to be called "Ticci Toby" in highschool.
-The nickname was meant to make fun of Toby

Ticci Toby's Tourettes Syndrome
-Toby (Tobias Rogers) also had Tourettes syndrome
-Other people also has Tourettes syndrome...
   -Toby was the only one I knew who had Tourettes syndrome
-Ticci Toby has Tourettes syndrome too
  -Ticci Toby = Tobias Rogers??

Last Name: "Rogers"
-Masky often calls Ticci Toby by his last name
   -Last name = "Rogers"
-Tobias Rogers
-Ticci Toby: Toby Rogers?
   -Ticci Toby = Tobias Rogers??

Ticci Toby - Bipolar
-Ticci Toby = Bipolar
   -Example 1: Angry for no reason -> invite for waffles -> reminds you he doesn't like waffles.
   -Example 2: Hyped/Happy -> dark and depressing

Ticci Toby - Numb to Physical Pain {+ Gash on his face}
-Tobias Rogers can't feel pain
   -Bit fingers until they bled, but didn't feel the pain
   -Bit into his cheek and caused a gash on right cheek. He didn't feel it when he did it.
-Ticci Toby can't feel pain
   -Example 1: Masky & Toby fought -> they're both injured. EJ treats them, only Masky screams in pain. Toby didn't even flinch.
   -Example 2: Took a hotass shower and became toast.
-Ticci Toby claimed he couldn't feel pain.

Conclusion: Creepypasta: Ticci Toby
-Numb to all physical pain
-Bipolar (based on observation)
-Has Tourettes (and possibly more mental disorders?)
-Has gash on right cheek
-Looks like Tobias Rogers
-Has the same jacket as Tobias Rogers