[Sorry for the late update :')]
Bloody Painter and Toby were missing for an entire day. EJ had just came back from his mission. Masky informed the others that Bloody Painter and Toby had to undergo a trial. Now, the others were trying to decide what will happen- whether the boys live or die.
"You think they'll live?" Jeff asked, "Bet $100 they'll be deader than BEN."
"Well I bet $200 that they won't be deader than me." BEN countered. "At the very least."
"Shut up, I bet yall $1,000 that they'll both live." Sully said.
"I bet $2,000 that only one of them will survive." LJ said.
"That's stupid, LJ." Sully said before Liu continued, "If Slender decides one of them will die, then both of them have to die."
"Well that's stupid. Why?" LJ asked.
"Well, let's say Bloody Painter is the only one who comes out. He'd probably be depressed since his friend Toby died. He would start slacking off at that rate, which means he would be no longer of use to Slender. Then Slender would have to kill off Bloody Painter as well." Liu explained.
"Fine, then I'll bet $3,500 that one of them will survive AND have their memories wiped." LJ said.
"Good point, if they have amnesia, that's a different story. But if they start to remember, then they'll have to be killed off as well."
"I bet you guys your kidneys that they'll get amnesia." EJ said.
Everyone turned to him. EJ hasn't ever placed a bet on anything before- up until now. This had taken the other Creepypastas by surprise.
"What?" EJ asked, explaining, "If I win, I'll take one of all the better's kidneys. If I lose, you keep your kidneys."
"Guys we gotta win the bet." Jeff said.
"I'm scared now." BEN said.
"LOSER!!! BEN'S SO SCAREDDDDD!!! You don't even HAVE kidneys anymore!" Sully said.
"Oh yeah, I forgot." BEN said, "But I'm still slightly scared of EJ. I mean, when does he gamble? Literally almost never."
"Scaredy cat." Sully said, "We're the ones who's supposed to be scared deadass."
"Yeah BEN, we're still alive and have kidneys." Jeff added.
"Fun fact, the kidneys I bet are worth more than the amount of money you guys bet every year." EJ says.
"No way-" Jeff says, "How?!"
"No way. I bet more than these losers. Hell, I bet more than all of yall's monthly pay." Sully said, "And clearly, your monthly pay isn't enough for you either. You guys still resolve to steal from each other. ESPECIALLY YOU JEFF. I SEE YOU STEALING FROM US AT NIGHT."
"HEY I DON'T STEAL!" Jeff yelled.
"Yes you do." Sully said, "Just admit it, we're all killers anyways."
Jeff just scoffed, "Whatever." Jeff says, rolling his eyes.
"With all seriousness," Liu says, "What do you guys think will happen to those two?"
"Deader than BEN of course." Jeff says, "Too dead, they won't even be ghosts."
"No way, they have to be alive." BEN argues.
"Who knows, they might have another trial or something." EJ says, "Honestly, I'm not sure if attacking them while they're sleeping is enough to prove them worthy."
"I'd have to agree with EJ on this one." Liu says, "Maybe they'll have another trial of some sort... Maybe fight us?"
"Bruh, Toby be having the upper hand since he's numb to pain." Jeff scoffs in annoyance.
"But still," Liu says, "He can still get nausea from blood loss. He just won't feel the pain. It doesn't make him immortal for it."
"We're all immortal at this point." Jeff argued.
"Well... I guess that's true... We don't really die so-" Liu says before getting cut off by BEN.
"EHEM- I'm dead." BEN says. "And Sally is too."
"Yes, but that's not what we mean, BEN." Liu says before Sully smothered BEN's name aggressively, "Dumbass!"
"Fuck you too, Sully!" BEN scoffed angrily.
"So, no one's gonna bet for their survival?" Jeff asked, "Well, I don't blame you guys, it's unlikely for them to be kept."
"You DUMBASS." Sully yelled, "I FUCKING BET ON BOTH OF THEIR SURVIVALS. ARE YOU DEAF?!"
"Guys, did you hear anything?" Jeff says hysterically, pretending he didn't hear Sully to aggravate him- which was a success.
Sully charged at Jeff, grabbing him by the collar of his hoodie. Liu tried to fight back and take control again, but Sully wouldn't let him. Sully slammed Jeff against the wall, gritting his teeth as he glared at Jeff. They both stared at each other for a bit- Jeff glaring slyly as Sully glared aggressively, as if he was about to kill Jeff.
"Listen here you little shit," Sully deadpanned, pinning Jeff against the wall, causing Jeff to smile slyly, "Kinky~" Jeff laughed and Sully just froze before shaking it off, "Shut the fuck up you brat." Liu takes over and steps away.
"So, when are we getting the results?" Liu asks, "Do you know when Slender will come out with what he's going to do with them?"
"He'll tell us soon, perhaps some time today." Masky says.
"Bro, they better be alive," Jeff says, "I want people to beat up, you know!"
"But you just bet that they were going to die." BEN says.
"It's called reverse psychology." Jeff says, emphasizing 'reverse psychology.'
"We didn't even learn psychology, Jeff." Liu says, "We didn't even go to college."
"Shut up, can't a man dream?" Jeff says.
"Whatever." Liu deadpans, rolling his eyes.
Static fills the room, Slender teleports in front of them. It seemed like it was time the Slender told them about his decision.
"Hello everyone." Slender says, "I'm sure you've heard about our little situation with Bloody Painter and Toby. And I'm here to assure you, that I have made my decision."
The others stayed still, paying attention to Slender as he told them what he'd decided.
YOU ARE READING
Lemon and Lime
HorrorTobias Erin Rogers and Helen Otis used to be friends in Highschool, March of their senior year. Within a month of their friendship, they had separated. After school was out, they had walked down their own separate paths. They've been away from each...
