Original Magcon Imagines

The Dare pt.2 - Carter Reynolds

This imagine is my first dirty imagine so it would be lovely if you comment what you think of it. VOTE, COMMENT, ETC! xo

***WARNING: A DIRTY IMAGINE***

-

-

Part 2 of The Dare from Carter’s first imagine.

 -

-

Recap of The Dare Part 1

~Y/n POV~

I stayed in my room for the whole day, not wanting to see the bright sky with his dark evil face outside. I can’t believe he used me for a freaking dare just for him to get money. And he thinks that I’m annoying. Why would he lie to me? I told him everything about me that no one else knew. I trusted him because I thought he would never judge me. But he already did judge me before our relationship even started. Why didn’t he tell me? He kept that from me for a whole year. Everything was a lie. Every single word that he told me these past few months was a lie. But every word that I told him wasn’t a lie. My feeling for him wasn’t a lie. How could he do this to me?

The banging of rocks on my window interrupted my thoughts. I groan loudly and stand up from the bed. I wipe my tears with the back of my hand. I open the window to reveal huge letters written on the dirt by flower petals, saying: Baby, I’m so sorry. I look around the backyard and no one was there. But I know who exactly who have done this. I suddenly felt a tap on my shoulder. I shout that I felt that my lung is going to burst. I turn myself around with my eyes close. I felt two arms surround my body and pull me closer to them. I know who this is. I know the scent of his cologne.

“You scared the shit out of me,” I yell, punching his chest multiple times.

He laughs and hugs me tighter.

“I miss you,” he whispers in my ear, his voice is shaky. “Please come back, I miss you so much.”

“No you don’t,” I say, pulling away from our embrace but he didn’t let go of me. “You’re only with me because of the bet, aren’t you?”

“Ok, maybe I am,” he sighs. “But I did it because he threatened me. He told me that if I didn’t ask you out, he would kill me and my parents. I don’t want them to get in danger. I’m really sorry. I truly am. I regretted everything that I made a year ago but asking you out is not regret. I found myself happier than ever when I was with you. Yes I might’ve thought that you we’re annoying but all that change when you told me about the car crash. Everything has changed, especially my feelings for you. I started falling for you when I spend my whole day with you. Y/n, I’m so stupid to even realize that yesterday but I really need you. I lo… I love you… so much. There’s no time when I didn’t think of you all day yesterday since you left. Please come back?”

Well, that’s the first time I heard him say I love you to me.

“Why didn’t you tell me that you got threatened?” I say, looking straight in his red and dull eyes.

“Will you still think the same way about me though?” he asks, cupping my cheeks.

“Probably not,” I say, looking down to my hands.

“Yeah and I also don’t want to hurt your feelings,” he says, lifting my head up. “I care about you so much. Please forgive me.”