Two Different Heroes (Tadashi × Reader) (Completed!/editing)

The Date

The image is what your dress will look like, once you keep on reading!

You were wiping down tables in the cafe, trying to help Aunt Cass during the day before you went on your date with Tadashi. You had finished your project earlier than expected so you decided to come home while Tadashi finished up some of his work down in the garage. "(Y/n), could you work the register while I make some more pastries?"

You turned to Aunt Cass as you nodded. She gave you a thankful smile before turning to go into the kitchen. You made your way to the register after putting away the table cloth, before hearing the little bell to the cafe ring as someone entered.

"Hey there stranger."

You looked up at the source of the voice and smiled when you saw the green eyed boy from yesterday. "Oh hey!"

He smiled as he scanned your face. He liked looking at your pretty eyes and all of you in general. "You look really pretty today."

You were caught off guard at his comment and you couldn't help the light pink that tinted your cheeks. "Oh, well thank you." You said letting out a light laugh.

The man who you yet to know the name of nodded before his eyes went wide. You watched confused as he gasped and face palmed himself. "Are you okay?"

He shook his head and you began to worry that something was wrong. "I totally forgot to introduce myself. I just realized that you don't even know my name and your were probably just referring to me as, that guy."

You laughed as you nodded in agreement, "Yeah I've just kind of been going by, guy with green eyes." He chuckled at that before reaching his hand out for you to shake.

"Well then, let me introduce myself. I'm Colton, it's nice to meet you (y/n)." He grinned as you shook his hand.

"You too. So, is there anything you would like?" You asked as you mentioned towards the pastries.

He averted his gaze to look at the treats but his fingers lingered on your hand, longer than they should've. You noticed this and you studied him as he glanced back over to you. "What do you recommend?"

You glanced at the pastries before turning back to him. "I personally like the lemon bread or the chocolate chip scones."

"I'll take both."

You nodded before wrapping the treats up and placing them on the counter. "That'll be six dollars. Would you like it in a to go bag, or a tray?"

"I'll take a tray please. Oh, and keep the change." Colton smiled before handing you a twenty dollar bill.

"Are you sure?" You asked as you slowly took the money, placing it in the register.

He nodded as he winked at you before grabbing his tray and walking over to a table. You just stared after him as you thought to yourself.

Was he just flirting?

You shook off the thought as you continued to take orders from customers, but every now and then you would feel someone's gaze on you, causing you to look around only to catch Colton looking at you. When your eyes met for the fifth time, he smiled, sending an uncomfortable chill down your spine. It wasn't that he creeped you out or anything but the way he looked at you was so intense that it made you want to hide yourself.

When you heard the sound of footsteps approaching you, you averted your eyes to see Tadashi. Your eyes lit up as you saw him, smiling when he gave you a quick peck on the lips. "Hey beautiful."

Your heart melted every time he called you beautiful and you couldn't help the butterflies you felt in your stomach. "Hey, you all done?"