Light In The Dark - Michael Munroe x M!Reader [Until Dawn]

Chapter Five

While (Y/N) was being forced by gunpoint, the others began to worry. "Didn't (Y/N) say he'd be right back...?" Josh asked, lighting up the last of the candles. (Y/N) had told Josh he was going to head out with Mike and be right back. It had been quite a long time. Certainly longer than a trip to the cabins and back.

"Yeah," Chris answered, sitting down at the table. "Wonder what's taking him so long."

Ashley brushed off the Ouija board, making sure the remaining dust was gone. It hadn't been used in a long time. "Maybe Mike confessed. Finally."

"Confessed to what?" Josh asked, confused. He blew out of the match and tossed it on the table. He sat down, ready to play with the spirit board.

"Uh, his feelings? Duh?" Ashley giggled. "He's liked (Y/N) for a long time." Mike had told her about it after he broke up with Emily. Ashley told Chris, of course. Not that Mike knew that. Mike probably didn't even remember telling Ashley. He was pretty drunk that night.

"Forever, it feels like," Chris agreed.

"Wait, what!?" Josh said, shocked. "You're kidding."

"Honest to God, man," Chris replied, smiling.

"Huh..." Josh nodded, thinking. "So, maybe... Those two are-"

"Nope! Don't wanna think about it," Ashley interrupted, shaking her head. "Can we just get on with the game?"

"Just like Mike and (Y/N) are 'getting' on?" Josh teased, winking at Ashley.

"Oh my God..." Ash sighed, rolling her eyes.

But the reality was that Mike was currently with Jess. He watched from the couch as she slid off her coat. He went to touch her, but she shook her finger. "Nuh, uh, ah..." She teased flirtatiously, taking a step back from him.

He could see what she was doing. He stood up, removing his own coat. Jess wrapped her arms around Mike's shoulders and pulled him into a kiss. Mike attempted to kiss her back, but she pulled away. She winked at him, sticking her tongue out slightly.

She pulled her white shirt off of her, as well as sliding down her jeans. She bit her lip seductively, making her way to the couch. "Come on, Mikey," She whispered, sliding a hand down her stomach to the hem of her underwear.

Mike didn't move. He just looked at her. And thought about how she wasn't (Y/N). He couldn't do this. He couldn't lead her on anymore. "Jess, I..."

A crash interrupted him. The two both gasped, looking at the direction of the noise. "Mike... What is that!?" Jessica whispered, her eyes wide. 

"I don't know!" Mike answered quietly. He tried to keep his voice low, but also loud enough for Jessica to hear.

"Okay, well, go find out! Now! Please!" She begged, hugging her knees to her chest.

Mike nodded and grabbed the flashlight he had put on the table. He glanced at Jessica before walking towards the noise. As he got closer, he could hear the wind thrashing. He could also feel the cold air seeping into the cabin.

He walked into the bathroom. He noticed that the glass was shattered. "Shit..." He mumbled to himself. He looked at the ground, careful not to step on any glass. As he did, he noticed Jessica's phone on the ground. She had dropped it while they were running from the bear. He picked it up, examining it. The music was still playing and it looked in good condition. "It's your phone," He yelled to Jessica, turning around.

Jessica was already standing there. A look of confusion filled her face. "What!? How is it my phone?"

Mike looked through the window, but he couldn't see anything. Just snow and trees. Whoever had thrown it was gone now. "I don't know it just... came through the window."