Arcane Imagines / Head cannons x FemReader

More than friends ~ Caitlyn x Reader

I wanted to tell her that night but it wasn't the right time, it was clear she had too much to drink though that was very unlike her and I doubt she would have remembered it in the morning. Since then I have been avoiding her, it's hard liking your best friend and not being able to tell her. 

Caitlyn has tried to reach out and I have tried to avoid her, I can't pretend that what happened that night didn't happen. 

Flashback-

"Come on Caitlyn you need to rest you've had too much to drink," I tell the girl as I drag her into her room, "Mmm Y/n" She slurs out, I place her on her bed and take a seat next to her. "Do you like that guy you were talking to tonight?" She asks me, I turn to look at her only to see her eyes glossy as she holds back tears.

"What?" I questioned, sure I was talking to that guy but that was it, I have no feelings for him, and even if I did I don't know why she would be upset about it. "I don't want you to like him, I want you to like me. I want to be the only one" She begins crying, wrapping her arms around my neck and pulling herself closer to me. I freeze, what is happening?

"You are so important to me Y/n and i- I don't want you to be with anyone else, I want to be the most important person to you" She rests her head on my chest, her arms still wrapped around me. "Caitlyn" I whisper, "Why do you keep doing this to me?" A tear falls down my face, I know she doesn't mean anything and that's the part that hurts the most.

"Stop getting my hopes up like this, please I can't take it anymore," I tell her, though I can already hear her soft snores as she falls asleep. I sit there motionless, confused, and upset.

Back to the present time-

I was leaving the office late at night, and to my misfortune, I spot a certain blue-haired girl sitting right outside the doors talking to herself. I try my best to rush past but she recognized me.

"Y/n! Wait!" She runs over to me and grabs my shoulder, pulling me back. "Why are you ignoring me, did I do something?" She asks me, forcing me to face her "No you did nothing, now I really need to go" I try to walk away but she grabs onto my wrist and pulls me back.

"Please talk to me" She begs, I take a deep breath and stare at her "Do you remember anything from that night?" I ask her, she hesitates "Sort of, why did I do something?" I look away from her "Oh I did didn't I, I'm so sorry. Look anything I did or said just forget it I probably didn't mean it anyway" She smiles at me in an attempt to lighten the mood.

"That's the part that hurts Caitlyn, you can't even remember and now you are saying to forget it, saying it didn't mean anything. But what if I wanted it to mean something?" I pull my arm away from her grip, I feel a tear roll down my cheek. "What?" She mumbles. 

"I like you Caitlyn" I rush out, instant regret "I like you too! You are one of my best friends" She smiles at me "No... not like that. I like you" I stop and take a breath "I like you more than a friend, and I'm tired of waiting to see if you will ever feel the same," I say to her, she takes a step back not saying a word.

I bite my lip and nod my head "I need to go" I quickly say before walking away, keeping my head low.

I'm shocked when I suddenly feel a pair of arms wrap around my waist, pulling me back "I'm not sure of my feelings, I'm so confused but i- I think I like you too" I hear her say to me, we stand like this for a couple of seconds before I feel her arms leave my waist and I hear her footsteps walking away. 

I turn to look at her and see her racing away, instead of chasing I just leave it, I'm not sure if I should be happy or nervous but all I know is that if this isn't sorted out soon then things are going to be awkward as hell.