From Ranchhands To Soulmates (A Yellowstone Fanfic)

Chapter 16 (Edited)

Chapter 16

Caroline's POV

After the party, I took a moment to myself to ponder the reality of having Beth around and what it was going to be like. Hopefully, she has changed from what she was like when she and Rip were teenagers. But only time can tell about that situation. Rip deserves all the love in the world, so if she can offer him that, then that's great, but if not, there's going to be hell to pay. Beth, being Kayce's sister or not, better know she cannot act like a teenage Bethany anymore. I have a feeling John is gonna say the same thing. I took the liberty of contacting Jamie to find out where the custody lawsuit is with Tate and Carter. "Hey Caroline, is everything okay? You never call me," Jamie says through the phone. "Oh, yeah, sorry about that. I just wanted to call and see where we stood in the custody case... how is everything going?" I ask timidly, as I sit on my reading nook on my windowsill. "Don't worry, everything is working out wonderfully. You and Kayce have a court hearing for Carter and Tate next month and having favors owed to us from the judges doesn't hurt. However, everything looks wonderful, everything is in our favor," Jamie explained proudly. " Thank you, Jamie," I ask, sighing a deep sigh of relief. "No problem sis, congratulations on your new house and happy birthday," Jamie says kindly. "Thanks so much, Jamie," I say sweetly. "You have a great night, Caroline," Jamie said politely. "You too Jamie, good night," I said before hanging up the phone. Oh sweet baby Jesus, thank you. I take a deep breath and relax my mind. All except for the thoughts of Beth running rampant in my mind. I lean my head against the cool glass of the window and try to think of all the good things. After a while, there was a soft knock on my door, and Kayce and Rip walked in. I smiled sweetly at them as they walked over to sit by me. "Hey beautiful, you okay?" Rip asked as he knelt between my knees in front of me. I immediately nodded and shrugged. "Yeah, baby, I'm okay," I said halfheartedly. "Baby, that's not the truth, though. We can see it all over your face," Kayce says, gripping my hand tightly to show his attention. I nodded and sighed. "Tell me about Beth. How was she when you were teenagers?" I asked forthrightly. I don't know what to expect here, but something has to be better than nothing I'm going off of. "Well, she was a Spitfire, always a hard ass and guilty as hell. She grew up blaming herself for the death of our mother," Kayce answered first. I listened intently to his words and tried to give her the benefit of the doubt. "Okay, and how did she treat you?" I asked Rip curiously. Rip cleared his throat before saying, "She was a..." Rip struggled to find the words he wanted to use. "Well, at first she was great, but right before she went to college it was like a different Beth came out..." Rip answers honestly. I nodded and processed the words he spoke. "I'll give her a chance, baby, I promise. But I will not tolerate her disrespecting you, Teeter, or our kids." I say, crossing my arms, meaning every word I say. "Nobody will ever disrespect our family and our boys, darling, regardless of their status," Rip immediately answered and Kayce agreed. "Alright, that's that," I say with a brisk nod. "However, I called Jamie..." I say, smiling at the two men. "Oh yeah? What did he say?" Rip asked me. I smirked at Kayce and Rip before shaking my head. "C'mon baby, don't keep us in suspense," Kayce teased as he nudged my leg. "Jamie said that we have one last court date next month for full custody of both boys!" I say excitedly. "That's amazing, baby!" Rip congratulated us. "We're ALL going to this court date, all of us," I informed them, arching my eyebrow at the men. They both immediately held their hands up in surrender. "Yes ma'am," Kayce says, chuckling. "Good," I giggle. "Feeling better now?" Rip asked me with a sweet smile. I nodded and bit my lip. "Oooh, see now what's that look for?" Kayce teased me playfully. "Kids are in bed, yes?" I ask with a Chester cat-like grin. "Out like a light," Rip confirmed. "Good," I say, biting my lip before running to the bathroom to change my clothes. "What on God's green earth is she up to?" Rip asked Kayce as they waited for me to come back out. "I dunno, man, but we're in for it. Did you see the look on her face? She's going to enjoy every minute of it," I could hear Kayce say to Rip from where I was sneakily changing into some sexy lingerie underneath my clothes. "Can y'all call my boys to come in babes?" I call from the bathroom. "Teeter and Ryan are out for the night, baby," Kayce responded from his spot in the bedroom. "I know, silly! Get the rest of them, big boy," I giggle playfully, throwing him a playful wink as I emerge from the bathroom. "What are you up to, beautiful?" Rip playfully asked me while removing his hat and hanging it on a hat rack on the wall. I walked over and seductively straddled his lap and whispered in his ear, "Fun," before nibbling on his earlobe. "Hmm, better hurry Kayce, go get the boys," Rip says, smiling as he strokes my hair. Kayce chuckled and quickly rushed out of the door, "Guys! Y'all might wanna get in here, you might miss out on something sweet," Kayce yells down the hallway. If the house weren't so massive, I'd be worried about his screaming to wake the boys up, but we made sure to put the kids on the complete other side of the house so they wouldn't overhear anything. Seconds later, there were a couple of grown cowboys rushing into my bedroom. "Where's the sweets? I was told there was gonna be something sweet," Colby said as he lounged on my couch in the middle of my bedroom. "I didn't mean it literally, man," Kayce said, chuckling as he closed the bedroom door behind himself and Jimmy perched himself beside Colby on the couch. "So what's going on with you, baby?" Kayce chuckles as he sits back in his original spot beside me and Rip. "Wanna play a game?" I ask, biting my lip seductively. "Yes!" Jimmy answered without a second thought. I laughed at his eagerness. Jimmy's such a sweetheart. "Whatcha got in mind, sweetie?" Rip questioned, intently chewing on his toothpick. "Strip never have I ever. We ask questions if you've never done it. Take off a piece of clothing." I giggle brazenly. "Ah hell, we're gonna need some alcohol," Rip laughed playfully. "Way ahead of you," I say, walking over to the closet and pulling out a bottle of whiskey from the closet. "Good thinkin', I'm down,'' Colby laughs, getting ready to play. "Alright baby, let's play," Kayce said playfully. "Let's move to the bed, more room, and it's just the 5 of us," I shrug, taking the bottle of whiskey and sitting in my bed. "Alright, Angel, wanna start us off?" Jimmy asked, smirking at me. I nodded excitedly and thought of my first question. "Okay, hmm... never have I ever had sex in public." I say, biting my lip and waiting for a reaction from someone. Kayce was the first to remove his t-shirt. I immediately smirk and cock my eyebrow at Kayce. "Oh really, sir?" I say, giggling at him. "I was a wild child," he says playfully, with a shrug. "Hot. Okay, now your turn," I giggled, reaching for Colby's whiskey bottle. "Never have I ever given someone head in public." Kayce says smirking. I groan playfully after taking a big swig of whiskey and shrug before taking off my shirt. "Goddamn," Colby mumbled, watching me with a smile. "C'mon, next question," I say, smirking at my cowboys in front of me. Rip was next in the circle, and it was his turn to come up with a question. "Alright, never have I ever slept with the same sex." Rip says, biting his lip. I smirk and immediately shimmy out of my shorts and all eyes were on me in my lingerie. "Don't worry, I plan to make sure that no one will say that they haven't here soon," I coo seductively. "Fuck, you're goddamn beautiful," Colby murmurs under his breath, but I still heard his praise. "You're next," I whisper to Colby before taking another sip of whiskey. "Never have I ever used a toy in the bedroom," Colby said before drinking a swig of whiskey. I shrugged and looked around the circle. I am the only one sitting here in my lingerie, while Jimmy, Colby, and Rip are still fully clothed and Kayce is shirtless. This is getting interesting. "Alright Jimmy, Your go," Rip said, leaning back on his hands. "Never have I ever kissed the opposite sex," Jimmy said, shrugging. I smiled, rolling my eyes and smiled. "I'm gonna need y'all to help me out. I'm not the only one fixing to be naked here," I giggle, shaking my head. "She's right," Kayce says smiling. "Never have I ever fantasized about someone," Kayce said, smirking at Jimmy. I smiled and watched Jimmy, Rip, and Colby all strip off their shirts. "Thank you, baby, but you know you had better strip those pants off. I know you've fantasized about me and Teeter making out," I laughed. Kayce chuckled and cleared his throat before undoing his belt and sliding his jeans off quickly. "That's better," I smirk. "Hmm... truth or dare, y'all?" I ask, winking at Jimmy. "Sounds good to me, sweetheart," Kayce answered quickly. "Jimmy, you first. Truth or Dare." I ask him while pushing my boobs up seductively. "Mmm, dare?" He replies, biting his lip. "I dare you to kiss Kayce," I say, my eyes never leaving Jimmy's. Jimmy looks over at Kayce and he sits up beside me and smirks. Jimmy clears his throat and leans over slowly. "It's not gonna make things between us weird, right?" Jimmy asks Kayce softly. "No man, of course it's not. I swear, we're all together anyway, right?" Kayce asked the group for confirmation. "He's right, Jimmy, we're all together," Rip confirms. "Agreed," Colby nods. "Alright," Jimmy said and cleared his throat softly before leaning in fully and kissing Kayce's lips softly. My God, that was the hottest thing I've seen in a while. "Fuck, that was hot," I groan softly. Jimmy and Kayce slowly pull away and Jimmy's face is as red as a tomato. We all cheer and clap as we pass around the bottle. "Shit," Jimmy says, adjusting his jeans. "Next," Jimmy said, trying and failing to hide his smile. "Alright Colby, Truth or dare," Jimmy asks Colby eagerly. "Truth," Colby answered quickly. "What is your sexuality?" Jimmy asked, cocking his eyebrow. "Well, it seems like we're all bisexual here, aren't we?" Colby answered with a smirk. "In continuation to that question, who besides Caroline and Teeter would you like to make out with?" Jimmy asked, drinking from the bottle. Colby thought about the question and shrugged. "Considering I have to be honest here, no offense, but probably Rip or Kayce," Colby answered with a smirk. "Why not me? Rude." Jimmy asked jokingly. Kayce and Rip laughed and playfully cheered for themselves, fist-bumping each other. "Alright, Truth or Dare, Rip?" Colby asked, drinking from the whiskey bottle. "Dare," Rip said quickly. "Blindfold yourself and give the person of my choosing the best make-out session you've ever had," Colby said cheekily. "Do I get to find out who it is?" Rip asked, chuckling. "Not until your lips land on theirs, and if you feel facial hair, you'll have to wait until the end to see who it is. Now, remember you can say no, but if you do, you'll have to strip completely naked and stay that way the rest of the night." Colby said with a smirk. "Maybe next round, you'll need to wait for the Whiskey to kick in a little more. In the meantime, I'm stripping," Rip said, playfully removing his shirt and jeans. I whistled loudly watching his little strip show, "Uh-uh boxers off too, big boy," I said, biting my lip at his revelation. "Looks like there won't be any secrets left here today, huh?" Rip remarked, amused. "No sir, now get 'em off," I reply with a wink. "Mmkay, but remember sweetheart, your turn is coming," Rip said, slipping his black boxers down his hips. "Believe me, baby, I'm prepared," I replied with a smug grin. "Alright Kayce, truth or dare?" Rip asked, trying to hide himself with his arms. "Fuck it, Dare," Kayce says bravely. "I dare you to shave your head," Rip says jokingly. "Hell, no! I veto that!" I say immediately. "I was kidding, darlin," Rip says through his laughter. "No, for real this time. I dare you to blindfold yourself and name whoever kisses you," Rip says, smirking. "Bet, baby got a blindfold?" Kayce asked me with a smirk. I nodded and immediately went into the closet and pulled out a blindfold from my bag. "Here it is," I say, walking over to Kayce and tying it around his eyes. "Can you see anything, baby?" I whispered in Kayce's ear. Kayce shook his head and smirked. "Alright," I say before walking around and making the guys move around so he won't know who it is. I smirk as I look at the guys and urge Colby over to kiss Kayce first. "Alright baby, remember now you've gotta name who kisses you," I explained again to Kayce. "I understand, my love," Kayce says sweetly, waiting for his kiss. Colby shrugged as he leaned in and kissed Kayce deeply before slowly pulling away. "Okay, well, it wasn't Caroline, it's not Jimmy, so it's either Rip or Colby," Kayce answered carefully. "Who was it, baby?" I giggled playfully. "It was Colby, my final answer," Kayce chuckled. "How'd you know?!" Colby asked, exasperated. "The beard, my dude. Rip's isn't nearly as long as yours." Kayce answered immediately with a chuckle. "Damn it, man," Colby says, laughing. "He ain't wrong," Rip chuckles, popping the top off a beer. "My beard is pretty great," Colby chuckled as he ran his fingers through his beard. I leaned towards Colby after taking a big swig of whiskey and stroked his beard softly. "It's so soft," I slurred, giggling slightly tipsy. "I think someone should put her to bed," Rip chuckled as he rubbed my legs. Jimmy immediately answered eagerly, "Me, I'll do it!" I giggled and nodded with a smile. "Alright then, Jimmy, make sure she's taken care of," Rip said, leaning over and stroking my cheek. "You gonna be alright, darlin'?" Rip whispered to me softly. I nodded and kissed his lips sweetly, "I'm fine, Daddy, come check on me in the mornin', yeah?" I reply, looking up at him through my lashes. "I promise we will, baby," he promises before placing a sweet, passionate kiss on my lips. "Goodnight, darlin, I love you," Rip praises before walking out of my room into his room. "I love you!" I called after him. "I have to go out to the reservation tomorrow baby, a family had their mustangs stolen, and that's their livelihood. I've gotta check it out." Kayce said softly. I nodded and looked into his eyes. "Be careful. Please come home to us," I whisper, our eye contact never breaking. "Always, baby. Colby and Jimmy will be here along with the wranglers, to help you when Lloyd and Lee return from the auctions, my love." Kayce says, kissing the back of my hand sweetly. I nodded, remembering that I've got vaccinations to give tomorrow. Thankfully, it won't be until the afternoon when they get back from the auction, so I'll have plenty of time to sleep in the morning. "Thanks, baby, imma need all the help I can get," I giggle softly. "No kiddin, I'll keep you in the loop," Kayce comforted me. "I trust you, baby. I know you're busy, as long as you're doing everything you can to keep our family safe, doing what's best for our home, and making it home to me. I completely trust you." I whisper, placing my hand on his cheek. "I love you," Kayce sighed before kissing me. "I love you too, honey," I mumble, sleepily. "I know you're tired, baby. I'll make sure Carter and Tate start their school in the morning, so you don't have to get up super early." Colby announced before Kayce walked into his room. "Thanks, my love, you're amazing," I answered with a tipsy smile on my face. "I love you, sweetheart. Goodnight," Colby said, chuckling at me before he started walking away. I quickly grab his hand. "Wait..." I say smiling. "I want you both to fuck me." I say confidently, pulling them both in close to me with their hands. "What?" Jimmy asked immediately, giving my sinful demand his undivided attention. Colby groans and bites his lip. "Sweetheart, are you sure?" Colby asked respectfully. I nodded, completely giving myself to them. "I want you. Both of you," I say, looking between the two men. "Baby girl, you've gotta ride tomorrow. Are you positive about taking us both at the same time?" Colby asks again, making me think about the fact I've gotta ride a horse tomorrow. "You're right. Guess you'll just have to share one at a time," I smirk, attempting to strike the sexiest pose I can manage. "Fuck... Don't mind if we do," Jimmy said, crawling across the bed to get closer to me, grabbing my foot and massaging it soothingly. "Relax, princess. Let's daddy take care of you, yeah?" Colby said, kissing my neck, down my collarbone, and stopping in the valley of my breast. I let out a soft moan and arched my back, making them both have a perfect view of my body in this lingerie. "This lingerie... did you pick this out just for us, baby?" Colby moaned in my ear as he gently nibbled on my earlobe, erupting me into another moaning mess as I frantically nodded. "Use your words, princess..." Colby scolded me, biting his lip. "Yes, Daddy," I nodded and bit my lip. "Tell us what you want, princess." Jimmy said while kissing up my leg. "Fuck..." I moaned and bit my lip hard. I suddenly felt all my nerves melt away, and I looked directly into Jimmy's and Colby's eyes. "Tonight is all about me, so get on your knees and put that tongue to work," I say, staring down into Jimmy's eyes. "Yes, ma'am," Jimmy said, smiling ear to ear, wrapping his arms around my hips and pulling me closer to him. I turned my attention to Colby as Jimmy dragged down my panties. "You, sir... I want you to fuck my brains out and spank me," I say, licking my lips. "Oh, that would be my pleasure, princess. Now lean back and let us take care of you," Colby ordered, placing himself behind me and pulling my back flush against his chest.

****

"Oh Fuck!" I scream out loud, my legs violently shaking and clenching around Jimmy's head and hands. "Come on, princess, come for me, come for Daddy," Jimmy coaxed from between my legs. That was it. That was all it took to completely unravel my mind-blowing orgasm. "So sweet, that's my girl," Jimmy purrs, kissing my inner thighs before moving up beside me, getting comfortable on the pillows. "Do you need a minute, baby?" Colby asked me, kissing below my right ear. I shook my head eagerly and smiled. Colby moved from behind me and laid me on the bed, flat on my stomach. "Lift your hips, and face down," Colby ordered, his voice dripping in dominance. Fuck, this was hot. I quickly obeyed and assumed the position as instructed. "Yes, sir," I submitted, waiting for further instructions. "So fucking beautiful... our queen, our wife," Colby said, slowly rubbing his hands down my back and over my ass before delivering a firm slap onto my ass. "Thank you, Daddy," I moaned, gripping the sheets in my hands. Colby positioned himself behind me and slowly slid into me, filling me with his massive size. "Oh shit," I moaned into the bed, trying to muffle my moans. "Oh no, none of that sweetheart, we wanna hear those sexy moans coming out of that sweet mouth," Colby said before planting another slap onto my ass as he continued thrusting deep into me. I moan loudly and bite my lip, "Yes, Daddy! Fuck!" I moan, arching my back even more. "Daddy...!" I moan loudly. "Yes, princess?" Colby asked, spanking me after every thrust. "I want to have your baby. Give me your baby, please!" I moaned loudly, my body starting to quiver. "Is that right, princess? Do you want my baby?" Colby coaxed me closer and closer to my second orgasm of the night. "Yes, Daddy, please!" I moaned, turning my head to face him. "I'll give you my baby, my love. No matter how many times it takes," Colby purred, kissing my shoulder blade. "Daddy! I'm so close," I moaned, biting my lip and staring into Colby's big brown eyes. "I'm almost there, baby. Almost there, just wait for me, princess..." Colby moaned, spanking me over and over, erupting me into a fit of moans. "Okay princess, come for Daddy," Colby says, thrusting into me at a record pace. "Oh, fuck Daddy!" I scream as I ride the high of my second orgasm. "God damn... So fucking perfect," Colby moans as he rides his high out and fills me with his seed before pulling out of me. "I fucking love you, both of you," I say breathlessly. "We love you too, angel," Jimmy answered for the both of them. "I love you, darlin," Colby says, placing a sweet kiss on my lips. I smiled and laid down against my pillows beside Jimmy and snuggled into his side. "I love you, baby. See you in the morning," Colby says, kissing my lips before exiting my bedroom and going into his room. "I love you," I say, blowing a kiss behind him. I laid there in bed thinking just how motherfucking lucky I am to have five smoking hot cowboys and one beautiful cowgirl as my soulmates. "You okay, angel?" Jimmy asked me, stroking my arm gently. I snapped back into reality and realized Jimmy had been looking at me curiously with his eyebrow cocked slightly. "Sorry sweetness, I was just thinking how lucky I am to have all of you forever," I say, looking up into his eyes. "Believe me, angel, we're the lucky ones. Now close your eyes and rest, your body is exhausted, sweet girl." Jimmy whispered as I laid my head on his chest. I sighed and relaxed against his chest, listening to his heartbeat and feeling the rise and fall of every breath he took. "I love you, Angel," Jimmy says, wrapping his arms around me securely. "I love you more," I say confidently before falling asleep on his chest.