Screaming for Stu Macher || Scream Fanfiction

Flashbacks

*After Billy got arrested from Sidney's House*

Stu stormed into the police station. A few officers tried to stop him but he angrily barged right past them.

Billy was leaning against the wall of his holding cell. Stu marched up and reached through the bars. He pulled Billy up by his shirt collar and slammed his face against the bars.

"She wasn't apart of the deal, asshole!" Stu was practically foaming at the mouth, he was seething with anger.

"I don't know what you're talking about" Billy smirked. He removed Stu's hand off his shirt collar.

"Go off and kill your little girlfriend for all I care, but leave mine out of this!" Stu snapped

"I'm sorry, but since when was Kelly your girlfriend?" Billy sarcastically remarked

"Whatever man, you promised me you wouldn't hurt her"

"She got in the way" Billy glanced away from Stu

"Then you should've left!" Stu felt his anger bubbling back up

"And what? Blow my cover?" Billy shook his head

"Your covers already been blown. You're behind cell bars, like hello?" Stu mocked

"That's what you think" Billy's smug expression returned

"You think I won't tell the police? I have all the proof" Stu threatened

"If you tell them, then I guarantee I'll gut your precious Kelly and make you watch" Billy evilly muttered

"You've gone too far Billy. I thought it was supposed to be only Sidney. I let Casey and Steve slide, but you're going mad with murder!" Stu shouted

"Hey! I didn't kill Casey or Steve, so technically I haven't killed anyone yet. I am innocent,whether you like it or not!" Billy shouted back

"Huh?" Stu confusedly looked at Billy

"Oh yeah, forgot to tell you...you've been replaced. There's a new ghost face, and he won't pussy out on me like you. He has the guts unlike you. He'll do whatever it takes, unlike you" Billy glared into Stu's eyes

Stu stepped away from the cell for a moment. He was taken aback, a little hurt by Billy's words. He felt second best to Billy, like he was just some Billy wannabe. If Billy didn't believe in him, then who would?

Stu heard a giggle in his head. It was sweet and kind, it was Kelly's giggle. Her encouraging words began to play throughout his mind. She was always there when he needed her, she believed in him. That's why he loved her so much.

It why's he needed to do everything and anything to protect her from Billy. Stu blinked and came back to reality. Billy once looked so cool, but now he just looked sad and pathetic

"Whatever man, I don't need this" Stu shoved Billy back further into the cell.

He began to walk away when he heard Billy call out for him.

"Stu! Wait!" Billy called

"What?" Stu rolled his eyes

"Don't tell a single soul about my plans...or they'll all die." Billy warned

Stu just scoffed and turned back around. He tried to keep his cool but deep down he was scared. Billy technically was innocent, he would probably be free soon.

There was nothing Stu could do except sit back and let Billy carry out the rest of his plans. He thought it was the only way he could keep Kelly safe. He truly believed Billy would leave her alone if he left him alone.

"Maybe he'll just kill Sidney and be done with it" Stu thought

Stu left the police station and shuddered. He couldn't shake the guilty feeling he had. He was filled with fear. He decided to go over to Kelly's house and check on her. He needed her to be okay.
——————————————————————————-
*Before Stu's party*

Stu was preparing his house for the party. He was loading his kitchen refrigerator with beers he got from down in the garage.

He heard a knock at the back door.

"Billy?" Stu peeked out the window before fulling opening the door.

"Hey man, I need a favor" Billy walked inside and made his way to Stu's kitchen

"What now?" Stu annoyedly asked

"I need you to send Tatum down into the garage during your little shindig" Billy mischievously smiled

"Tatum?" Stu questioned

"Yeah, she's been pissing me off"

"No way man, I can't do that to her"

"Hey, isn't Kelly coming to this little party of yours? Would be a shame if uh-"

"Cut it out, man" Stu clenched his fist

"Come on Stewy, who do you care more about? Your real girlfriend or the one in your head? Either way one of them's gotta die" Billy threatened

"Why, Billy, why? Just kill Sidney and be done with it. Or gee, here's a brilliant idea, don't fucking kill people!" Stu yelled

"Sorry, I've gone mad with murder" Billy mockingly shrugged

"You suck, man. You really suck"

"Yeah, yeah, whatever. You still haven't made your choice Stu, who's it gonna be?"

Stu frustratedly stared at Billy. It was never enough with him.