Slenderman
You had picked up a tendency to call him HoneyBunny, because you thought it was hilarious, and he hated it.
Jeff the Killer
You called him Jeffy-kins, because it bothered the hell out of him.
BEN Drowned
One word. BennyBoo.
Eyeless Jack
If there was anything Jack hated more than unfunny jokes, it was nicknames. So, you decided to give him one, and the nickname may you ask? Jackie-Baby.
Dark Link
Due to his passionate hatred for almost everything, you decided to call him Gumpy. He hated that, too.
Lost Silver
Silver didn't really mind nicknames, you're allowed to call him whatever you was as long as it's kind..so you decided on Honey. Cute, simple, and easy to remember.
Ticci Toby
Typically you don't give nicknames, it's against your nature, you like calling people by their names. But, you had picked up the habit of calling Toby "Bunny", this is because last time you saw him, he saw some rabbits and kept talking about how cute the bunnies were. He didn't like how un-masculine the nickname was, but he tolerated it for you.
YOU ARE READING
Creepypasta Boyfriend Scenarios
Fanfictionever wanted to date a fictional serial killer? you've come to the right place then! <3
