This theory is suggested before the release of Episode 6. Although it is officially debunked, it's still an interesting idea to share.
Soren is the White Pumpkin.
1. Portraits
First, we found some hints in the mansion. Take a look of these screenshots.
Oops! This image does not follow our content guidelines. To continue publishing, please remove it or upload a different image.
Oops! This image does not follow our content guidelines. To continue publishing, please remove it or upload a different image.
If we take a closer look at the background, we can see that there are paintings of Jesse, Lukas and Ivor on the wall. Do you think...
The mansion is owned by the Order?
It is possible. Why else would you hang someone's painting on the wall? The mansion has to be owned by someone who knew the Order.
2. Name
Think about the name. Who would ever name themselves 'White Pumpkin'? There are billions of other cooler names for murderers! Dread Lord, Devil's hand, Satan's Eye... Illuminati.
Why white? Why pumpkin?
Well... What can you do with pumpkin? You can plant them, you can make pumpkin pie, and, as a minecrafter, you know how useful a pumpkin is in the End. They prevent the endermans to see the player! And we all know which MCSM character ALWAYS hangs around endermans - Soren!
And is it a coincidence that white is the color of iron?
3. Time
There must be a certain time gap between Episode 4 and Episode 5. One month to be the least. Totally enough for an architect to escape from the Witherstorm and build his own mansion!
What's his motive, you might ask. Could Soren turn into the second Aiden? Harming the other just because he's envy towards the Order and wanting to seek power as returning to the position of the leader of the Order?
So could Soren possibly be the White Pumpkin? We'll see, in episode 6...
----------
Author's note
Hello there, minecrafters! Tell us your thoughts about this theory in the comments! We'd love to hear them!
Also, if you have any crazy MCSM theories that you want to share with the crowd, PM us! Your theories will have a chance to be featured in this book!
Pick up your pickaxes and SMASH the vote button! Also, share it to other Story Mode fans, too!
