Zach: Your phone cases. Let's face it, you change your phone case way too many times to count. Instead of going and buy one for himself, he'll steal a bunch of yours! He loves 'em. Besides, whenever he's using his phone (which is quite a lot) he thinks of you.
Jack: Your food. If you and Jack are out to lunch, or dinner, or even just going to grab a snack, Jack will always pick off of your plate. He could have all of the food in the world on his plate, but he will still go in for a piece from your plate.
Jonah : The blankets. He's always yanking and pulling the blanket away from you during the night. You often wake up with absolutely no covers on, and he's got the whole comforter wrapped around him like he's in some cocoon or something.
Corbyn: Your drinks. If you have a bottle of water with you, or any drink really, it'll be half gone within the first two minutes of having it. You hadn't realised until a while after he'd started doing it, but he's totally been stealing sips out of your drinks when you were paying much attention!
Daniel: Your headphones. You seem to have a lot of headphones and you don't know why. So if Daniel ever needs new ones, he'd rather just take yours. He often took it to tour so it reminds him of you and the fun times you two have listening to your favourite songs.