Millie's Pov
"Ooooo, let's play truth or dare." Caleb says
"Ok, everyone wants to right?" Gaten says, we all nod.
"Yes! Let's do it! Who is first?" I looked down and tried to not get picked but then Noah says
"Millie, you're up. Truth or Dare?" He looks me in the eyes smiling.
"Truth." I say, hopefully there will be nothing about Finn. But there is a chance it might be.
"Ok simple question, would you date anyone in this circle?" I felt my face getting hot but before I could blush I say
"Yes."
"Would you like to share who it is ?" Noah asks
"No thanks." He knew I would never say any feelings about Finn when he is around, but he still has a disappointed look in his eyes.
"Ok, Sadie truth or dare?" I say
"Dare."
"Ok, do you like anyone in the circle and if so who?" I say smiling knowing that I was the only one who knew about her crush on Caleb.
"Ok, since I'm not a chicken like Millie...I like Caleb." She says and then looks at me and mouths the words I hate you but thank you.
"Gaten, truth or dare?" Sadie says to Gaten
"Dare."
"Ok, run outside and scream." She whispers something in his ears so we can't hear her.
We all run to the sliding door and we all hear what he says.
"I AM KING OF THE WORLD AND FILLIE IS ENDGAME! AND FOR ALL THE FANS HEARING THIS JUST KNOW FILLIE IS NOT A THING RIGHT NOW!" Typical...but Sadie is doing this for a reason, she wants me to reveal my feelings for Finn already. I would but I can't help face the rejection.
Soon seven minutes in heaven started...
Finn and I were just forced into the closet and I'm guessing the only two people who will be playing are Finn and I.
Finn's Pov
As Millie and I are standing in the dark closet I feel my face getting so red, not because it's hot or I'm embarrassed I'm just in love with her. I can never take my eyes off of her shining ray of beauty all the time, I feel she never had liked me so I never have shared my feelings. But in the spirit of trying to kiss who you like and see what their reaction is I walk a little closer to her and lean in to see where it would go.
"Finn, what are you doing?" Millie whispers as she moves aways from me. Great now she must know I like her.
"Sorry, I just thought maybe the minutes would end and we can play a prank on them. Like as if we have feelings and kissed." I played it cool.
"Oh, haha that would be fun but they would kill us for lying about something like that. And is that the reason you tried to kiss me?" She asks, great should I tell her how I feel now?
"I like you, that's why." Wow you really thought I would be dumb and say that, nope I haven't signed up for rejection just yet.
"Mills, I just wanted to play a prank on them. That's all." I say, she nods her head and then we see the light as Maddie opens the door.
"Guys nothing happened, they look completely normal. I think we should just let them fall in love themselves and give up on trying to help." Maddie says to the group as we make our way to the circle.
"Ughhh." Everyone sighs in sadness.
Soon we decided to watch a movie.
We all spread around on the couch in this order: Sadie, Maddie, Noah, Millie, Me, Caleb, Gaten.
Halfway through the movie I felt someone's head on my shoulder, I looked to see that it was Millie. I felt my heart beating fast but I knew it was because she was tired and I just happened to be next to her. I wrapped my arms around her and ignored the photos that everyone was taking. Only one person knew about my feelings and that one person is Noah. I don't know when or how I'll ever tell this girl how I feel.
The movie finishes and the gang decides to sleep all different rooms in my house, I got up and was going to leave Millie on the couch but then I feel an arm grabbing me by the wrist pulling me back.
"Finnie, where are you going?" Millie says sounding tired, she'll usually call me Finnie when she is tired.
"To sleep? I was gonna leave you on the couch so I wouldn't wake you." I say
"Please can I sleep in your bed?" She says getting off the couch and hugging me.
"Of course you can, I'll sleep on the couch."
"No, I wanna be with you. Cause if not we will become cold." She says
"Ok, let's go." I say
"Carry me?"
"Alright." I say picking her up bridal style.
As I got to my room, I opened the door and put Millie down and pulled back the sheets. She got under the covers as I turned off the night light and got comfortable.
As I felt sleep take over my body I felt her breath on my chest. So now she is cuddling into me while she is in my bed great god you have made my feelings go through the roof, but can I ask you some things?
Why do you keep putting me in these situations? Are these signs? Are you trying to tell me something I don't know?
Hope you liked this chapter!
✌️✨Author
YOU ARE READING
Afraid {Fillie}
Fanfiction"When I wake up I'm afraid somebody else might take my place" - song credit: The Neighborhood. Millie has a crush on her co star Finn. Finn has a crush on his co star Millie. Finn thinks Millie doesn't feel the same way, and Millie thinks he doesn'...
