Afraid {Fillie}

✰It's Not What it Looks like✰

A/N: Just a reminder of what happened at the end of the last chapter :)

"Well, at the mall I decided to roam around and I found these things for you. I gave her the bag so she could investigate. She pulls out the outfit and then the sweatshirt, she just smiles.

"Omg, Finn this is adorable. Thank you!" She hugs me, obviously I hug her back.

"While on the topic of clothes I got you something too!" She says handing me a Hollistas bag.

"NO WAY, Mills you got me a beanie!" I have never found one that I liked or looked a little appealing to me.

"I knew you wanted one so... I got it for you." Then I find the comfy looking sweater that says Bee kind, with a little bee on it.

"Aww, thanks a bunch Mills." I say as I hugged her. I was putting the stuff away and then she interrupts me with a peck on the lips, of course making sure no one saw her do it. Everyone still doesn't know about us.

"Of course! I should also thank you Finnie." She says, I can sense that we are both blushing right now.

"Your welcome princess." She blushes even more at the name I give her.

Soon we all left, leaving Millie at home and us at our own houses. I took a shower, put on some sweats, brushed my teeth and my hair. I layed in bed and thought about how fun the day was, but I thought about how Millie and I would tell the others about us. And the fans? Well I'm not sure what we wanna do about that. After those set of thoughts, I found myself asleep in bed all cozy.

A/N: And now enjoy this chapter!

One week later. . .

Millie's Pov

Today was a pretty chill day, everyone went to Finn's and we watched a bunch of movies. I was wearing the sweatshirt Finn got me and he was wearing the one I got him. We were all in the living room except for Jack(he had to go to some modeling gig), today Finn and I thought it would be a good idea to tell everyone about us.

"Ok, ok tell us!" The all said with anticipation.

"We." I say

"Are." Finn says

"DATING!" We both day together. Everyone was going nuts, but they weren't suprímase caused they always shipped us.

"The ship has sailed!" Caleb says.

"Since when?" Kenzie says.

"Well, to be exact. One week ago." Finn says.

"AND YOU DIDN' T TELL US?" They all said.

Soon everyone was chilling just hanging around. Like I said pretty chill day.

Soon Sadie got a notification about a stranger con!

"Guys! We are going to stranger con!" Sadie announces. Maddie and Kenzie know they aren't apart of the con but they could come as our guests.

"When!" Noah says

"Next week on Saturday! It's gonna be in Orlando! The duffers said they would email us our tickets! Kenzie, Maddie would you like to come as out guests?" Sadie says.

"Well, actually we have a dance comp in Pittsburgh, so sorry we can't go." Maddie says.

"And before you all ask, no it's not for dance moms. We left that show years ago." Kenzie says before any of us could mention the show (We love joking about it with them). We all nodded and just talked about random things.

"I can't wait for the panel. It's gonna be so much fun!" Noah says. I agree with him and soon it became only Noah, Caleb, Finn and I at his house. Caleb was sleeping and Finn was in the bathroom. Noah was talking about all the things that could happen at Stranger Con, but I was laughing at all the jokes he was saying regardless if they were funny or not. But I look at him and suddenly I'm about to laugh but BAM! He kisses me, not fast, oh no it was a long one. I didn't kiss back of course but I couldn't pull away, he kept keeping me in the kiss. But then the next thing that happened changed both of our lives, Caleb woke up once he heard the bathroom door open and I can feel his utter shock as Finn saw Noah's lips on mine. Which made it look like we were both doing the kissing.

"NOAH! MILLIE WHAT THE FUCK ARE YOU DOING?!" That's when Noah removed himself from my lips and you could see some of my lip gloss a little messed up on his lips.

"Finn, it's no.." Finn cuts Noah off.

"WHAT NOAH? IT'S NOT WHAT IT LOOKS LIKE? NO THAT'S IMPOSSIBLE YOU TWO WERE SLUMMING IT THE WHOLE TIME I WAS IN THE BATHROOM!" I can see the anger in his eyes, but deep down I know slowly his heart is shattering. I tried to fix it but he only told me to get out.

"Finn, I know what it looks like, but it's not. He came onto me without no warning an..."

"OH WHAT? SO YOU WEREN'T MAKING OUT WITH HIM?! I'm sorry MIllie but I...I just need you to go...please." I see tears forming in his eyes as he tells me to leave.

I got up, took my phone and left. I waited for my uber to come and when I arrived at home I ran up to my room. I closed, locked my door and jumped on my bed and cried. I didn't do anything wrong but it might have looked like something else to Finn.

Finn's Pov

Soon everyone left except for Noah, Caleb and MIllie. I was in the bathroom and when I got out, I saw something horrible.

"NOAH! MILLIE! WHAT THE FUCK ARE YOU DOING?!" That's when Noah ended the kiss, and I could see Millie's lip gloss all over his lips.

"Finn, it's no. .". Noah tries to finish his sentence but I cut him off.

"WHAT NOAH? IT'S NOT WHAT IT LOOKS LIKE? NO THAT'S IMPOSSIBLE YOU TWO WERE SLUMMING IT THE WHOLE TIME I WAS IN THE BATHROOM!" At this very moment I do look and feel angry, but inside I could feel my heart shatter into a million pieces.

"Finn, I know what it looks like, but it's not. He came onto me without no warning an..." Millie tries to say.

"OH WHAT? SO YOU WEREN'T MAKING OUT WITH HIM?! I'm sorry MIllie but. . .can you. . .go. . .please." I cut her off as tears are forming in my eyes. I watched her leave.

She got up, took her phone and left. That's when Caleb decided to leave, he said he could come over later if I needed him. I waited for him to leave so I could talk to Noah.

I sat down across from Noah on the couch. He looks down and looks up waiting for me to talk.

A/N: Hey guys! So, what did you think of this chapter? Leave comments about what you thought of this chapter, I would love to know what you guys think! What a plot twist right? Don't forget to vote and keep enjoying this story! - Author ✨✌