Fool me

Chapter 11- What. Is. Her. Name?

TessaPOV

"Well?" Joey questioned, gesturing for me to say something but I just stood there gaping like a fish on dry ground.

Joey pushed himself away from the wall leaving the girl against it. He slowly began to take steps torwards me and I naturally took a step back.

"I-i-i I'm so sorry I had no idea you'd be home." I stammered. I quickly shook my head before correcting myself. "Well I thought maybe you'd be home but...I didn't think you'd be busy..." I trailed off.

"Yeah we were" The familiar girl jumped in bluntly. It seems like we met before...wasn't she the girl that Joey disappeared off for like hours And asked if I was his girlfriend?

What was her name again? Bailey? Mandy? Abigail? Abby?

ABBY! YES! I remember her now.

"Oh you must be Mandy!" I gushed. Yeah I said her name wrong on purpose. Why I did it? I don't know.

"Its Abby!" She snapped.

I clicked my fingers. "Right!"

"Sorry" I apologized pretending to blush. "Joey just has so many girls, I tend to lose track." I giggled.

Joeys eyes widened and Abby's mouth went agape.

"Joey is this true?" She gasped. Joey remained silent, instead Joey turned to me to shoot me a glare.

"I think its time you leave" he said to Abby ignoring her question - without taking his eyes off of me. I stared back at him with a smirk plastered on my face. 

Abby nodded and walked to the door. Joey broke his staring contest with me and walked to Abby. She walked halfway out the door before turning around.

"Do you really have so much girls that your roomate loses track of them?" She pouted.

"Yes" Joey replied. Abby's eyes widened but mine did too at Joey's blunt response. Joey's emotion suddenly changed. "But I think you are different, babe. You are not like the other girls" He winked and placed a hand to his heart. I felt my jaw drop to the ground. Joey was putting on a performance and she was falling ffor every single word.

A blush had crept to her cheeks. "You really think so?" She giggled.

"Of course babe. Why would I lie?" He smirked and tucked a piece of hair behind her ear. I felt my fists tighten. I have never seen him so close in action. Honestly, it just made me even angrier. How can Joey be so cruel?! How can he say things he doesn't mean?

I actually felt sorry for the girl.

Abby chewed on her bottom lip she then stood on her tippy toes and started whispering in his ear. Seductively I might add. Joey bit down on his bottom lip as she spoke. I just stood there rolling my eyes and sighing every few seconds.

Truthfully, I had no clue what they were saying but I also knew for a fact I didn't want to know. Just the possibility of what they were talking about made me want to gag.

Joey nodded and quickly whispered into her ear then pulling back with a smirk. I got tired of standing there cause clearly she wasn't leaving anytime soon.

I walked to the kitchen and poured myself a glass of orange juice.

I sipped on it slowly, trying to waste as much time as possible. Jerk. How can he play with girls's feelings like that? He basically tells them what they want to hear just so he can get what he wants. Idiot! Jerk of a player! 

I then began downing the orange juice and refilling it every 2 gulps or so. The more I thought of Joey, the more angrier I found myself getting. I was having such a wonderful night until he came and ruined it! Jerk!