Chase Atlantic Preferences

What You Do For Your Birthday-

Clinton Cave-

For his birthday – You knew Clinton didn't love big, flashy celebrations, so you organized a small gathering with his closest friends, homemade cupcakes, and a playlist of songs you knew he loved (and a few embarrassing throwbacks for fun). He ended up grinning all night, telling you, "This is perfect. You're perfect."

For your birthday – Clinton showed up at your place with a coffee in one hand and a wrapped vinyl record in the other. It was an album you'd mentioned in passing months ago. "Had to hunt for it," he said casually, but the way his eyes lit up when you smiled made it clear the effort was worth it.

Mitchel Cave-

For his birthday – You surprised him with a photo book you'd secretly been making, filled with your favorite shots of the band — candid moments, backstage laughs, and even a few of him when he thought you weren't looking. "You're actually trying to make me cry, aren't you?" he teased.

For your birthday – Mitchel booked a private studio space, brought snacks, and told you he wanted to do a "just for fun" photoshoot with you as the model. "Birthday girl gets to be the star," he grinned, handing you a camera at the end so you could still get your shots in.

Christian Anthony-

For his birthday – You baked him a cake — terribly lopsided, but full of effort — and set up a quiet night in with movies and takeout. Christian loved it more than any big night out. "Honestly," he said between bites, "this is the best gift you could've given me."

For your birthday – Christian planned a low-key day tailored just for you — your favorite breakfast, a stop at a bookstore, and a picnic in a quiet park. "I just want you to feel... calm. Happy," he told you. And you did.

Jesse Boyle-

For his birthday – You and the boys decorated the rehearsal space with streamers and balloons, hiding a cake in the corner until the moment was right. Jesse laughed so hard when he saw it, pulling you into a hug. "You're lucky you're my favorite."

For your birthday – Jesse roped your brothers into helping set up a little rooftop hangout with blankets, fairy lights, and your favorite snacks. "See? I can be the thoughtful one too," he said with a smirk, but the look in his eyes was genuine.

Patrick Wilde-

For his birthday – You bought him a rare vinyl of one of his favorite bands, wrapped in paper covered with doodles you'd made. "This is... insane," he said, turning it over in his hands. "You really listen when I talk, huh?"

For your birthday – Patrick showed up at midnight — technically the very start of your birthday — with a cake in one hand and a goofy party hat in the other. "Wanted to be the first one to say happy birthday," he said, and it made your heart ache in the best way.