Chapter 5

247 6 9
                                    

Keefe's POV


Am I a prankster or what? You should have seen Fitzy's face after I put that dye in his hair! He was so embarrassed that Sophie had to see him like that. You should have heard him when I went to his place after school. 

"Keefe, seriously! Why did you have to do that?" He asks when we sat down in his room.

I shrugged smugly.

"Ugh! Sophie saw it too! Like, you know I like her so why'd you have to do it in front of her!" 

I frown. Yup, he likes Sophie... which is fine but... I might have the smallest crush on her too. Okay, it's not a small crush. 

I mean, she's beautiful and so fun to be around. It would be weird if you didn't like Sophie. I know Dex likes her too. And Fitz. The question is... who does she like?

I shake my head to get rid of those thoughts. I snap back to reality.

"You're lucky that stuff came out, Keefe!" Fitz says, frustrated.

I mumble an apology. "Also, thanks for letting me come over," I add. 

I had wanted to come over since my house isn't exactly the place I want to be all the time.

"No problem, dude. Anytime." He says with a smile. He seemed to have forgotten about the 'hair dye incident'.

Glad I have a cool best friend like Fitzypoo!

-Later that day, around 5:00-

It was about 10 minutes before the rest of the gang showed up so Biana, Fitz, and I were sitting in Fitz's huge room, talking.

Biana had a twinkle in her eye. "So...." she said while staring at me and Fitzy, "Who do you guys like? AND DON'T YOU DARE SAY NOBODY!"

I flushed and I could tell Fitz was too. I racked my brain for a random name I could say instead of, ahem, you know who. Fitz seemed to be doing the same thing.

Biana rolled her eyes and sighed. "C'mon, guys! SPILL! If you don't, I will!" She said.

Wait what? How does she know who I like?! "Wait B, why are you asking when you-" I asked, confused.

Biana smacked her palm against her forehead. "Stop stalling." She said, interrupting me.

Fitz groaned and mumbled, "Sophie" under his breath. Surprise, Surprise! Biana smiled slightly and turned to me.

My mind was blank. I liked Foster but I couldn't say that. "Ummmm... Marella." I managed to get out without throwing up.

Suddenly, we heard the doorbell ring from downstairs. Phew! I was saved for sure.

Biana just gave me a quick nod and winked. She stood up and left the room. Fitz and I followed her.

-A Few Minutes Later: Fitz's Room-

We all made our way into Fitz's room. Foster settled onto a beanbag chair and I sat on the floor next to her. I saw her glance at Fitz, blushing softly. Gag me. (although Foster did look super cute when she blushes.) She leans back in her chair. "I'm so glad I met you guys..."She says softly.

I put my arm around her. "My pleasure, Foster," I say, making her blush yet again. 

She looks up at me with those beautiful brown eyes. Her lips curl into a sweet smile.

I hear a loud cough coming from next to me. I turn to see Biana sitting there looking at us with a raised eyebrow.

She leans over and whispers in my ear, "Marella, huh?" 

I flush and look down. Dang, and I thought I was a good liar.

------

After a few minutes, Biana rubs her hands together.

"Okay, guys!!! Truth or Dare time!"

I smirk. It's go time!


A/N:

Heyyy! Thanks for reading this chapter, I appreciate it a lot!

Ahhhh, a Keefe chapter! My favorite to write :) 

BTW: The next chapter is going to be back and forth POVs, just so you know!

No Chapter Questions Today but Feel Free To Comment Some Ships Below!!!

Thanks for over 100 reads! Please vote and comment if you are liking my story! 

Stay Cool! <3

-coolbeansss151

*p.s. I'm going to try to update every other day bc I'm busier with school!*

The Love SquareWhere stories live. Discover now