Gareth x Reader•{Only You}

{Gareth x Y/N}𖧷Halloween special𖧷 P2

TW: Mention of gore and blood

After I grabbed the arm of the body, I jumped back. I looked at the group of people inside the house and looked back at the body. My heart was pounding out of my chest. Holy shit, I thought, my parents are gonna kill me. I got up and dusted myself off and turned to everyone. "It was just a prop!", I lied with a fake smile, "Let's continue this party!", I laughed nervously and everyone began side eying and mumbling.

I ran back inside and up to my room where everyone else were. "Guys who the HELL killed somebody!?", I said slamming the door behind me. "Dude, I don't even know!", Jeff said, "We haven't even poured the fake blood yet or even out the fake bodies."
"Gareth isn't even here yet.", Eddie said. "What do you mean he isn't here?", I looked at Eddie with an eyebrow raise. "He called us earlier and he hasn't made it yet.", Eddie continued. "But he is here..?!", I added.
More screams came from downstairs, me and the boys jumped and huddled up together once we heard the door come open. "HOLY FUCKING SHIT!!", Steve said busting open the door along with Nancy and Robin. "STEVE," I yelled, "I WAS ABOUT TO MURDER YOU MYSELF!" "Sorry, but Y/N your boyfriend is going fucking crazy!", Robin then said locking my door shut. "But that's not him!", Eddie said, "Gareth is at home still!" Steve, Nancy, and Robin were in shock and yelled "WHAT!?"

After me and everyone else hid in my room, we began planning on who goes downstairs first and basically all of us try to kill this imposter. I was just freaking out on my bed while Eddie was next to me and being reassuring. "I'll go down.", Steve said, "I'm sorta the oldest here and I need to at least have to be an adult and do something about it.", he then grabs the baseball bat that was on my wall next to my bed. He was about to leave until Eddie got up and stopped him. "Steve..", he said grabbing his wrist, "I'll go down, it's the least I could do to.", "But Eddie, you really don't have to do this.", Steve then said. "Well I'm gonna do it anyways", Eddie then says talking the bat from Steve's hand and walking out the door.

Eddie's POV

I was out the door and prepared to go downstairs. I slowly walked down the stairs with the bat over my shoulder and once I was down there, it was a sea of dead people and their guts smeared all over the walls, floor, and furniture. "What in fucks name..", I said slightly lowering the bat. I then hear a slimy movement from down the hall coming closer and closer. "Is that—wait!"

Y/N's POV

A blood curdling scream comes from downstairs, we all knew it was Eddie's. "Guys..", Nancy says as she backs away from the door, "do you guys think Eddie just died..?", "THINK!?", Jeff then yells, "He is dead!"
Steve just stood in front of the door. "I'm going to go check it out.", he says quickly opening the door and going out to see Eddie impaled on the stair railing. Steve just dropped to the floor. I went out to look to see and I screamed covering my mouth and dropping to the floor.

Once we were a lil ok, I heard a familiar voice. "Y/N..", the voice said calling my name, "come see me y/n.."  I then covered my ears trying to ignore the voice, "I'm not listening!"
Steve then taps my shoulder to snap me out of it, "Y/N, what's wrong?", he then says concerned. I then look at him then the group and took a breather. "I know how is pretending to be Gareth."