Michael:
I think Michael would be sort of surprised. He would've thought that you would've hated his creepy video games, like Slenderman, or all the horror shows, so when he found out your favourite thing to watch was The Walking Dead he was happy, a bit taken back. "You really like this stuff?" he'd probably be hiding behind his hands as someone gruesomely killed another zombie and you'd nod, eager to see more gore but he would just laugh, and kiss you on the cheek. Tbh, he'd probably think it was the cutest thing ever to see you get all excited about the new season of American Horror Story coming back; but in the back of his mind he's be a bit disappointed. 'Great, Clifford, now your girlfriend is even more punk rock than you...'
Luke:
Luke's reaction would be similar to Mikey's in the sense that'd he would be really surprised. Like he had this great plan to put on Annabelle or something and then you'd be terrified and jump into his arms for comfort, but little did he know you'd be the one comforting him when the creepy little doll advanced towards the screen. "How are you not terrified, y/n?? I mean, look at it!" you just laugh as he nuzzled his head into your neck more, while you wrapped your arms around his back, rubbing small circles into it for comfort. "Don't worry, Lukey, I'll keep you safe" and you couldn't help but laugh out loud at his grumpy expression, which soon changed to fear as she popped across your screen again, making him jump. "Ok, ok, you win, just cuddle me!" and the rest of the evening would be spent with you cuddling him until he felt better aww Luke
Calum:
Calum would probably be completely unaware about it until one day you were showering together because it's Cal and this huge spider would start crawling down the wall my actual biggest fear and he'd like squeal and back away and you'd laugh and put a towel around you and just pick it up and carry it out and carefully give him or her, I'm no expert on spider-genders a quick exit through the window, putting it on a leaf, and when you'd go back to finish the shower Cal would just be staring at you like wtf who are you, woman?? and you'd brush it off but he would be persistent, "Babe, that was a big-ass spider! How were you not scared?" and you'd be really confused because "I thought everyone could do that??" and he'd just laugh and kiss you on the forehead and think to himself 'fuck yeah, Hood, you got yourself one bad-ass babe' and if you think he'd think anything else fight me (not really)
Ashton:
Ash would probs think it's the coolest thing in the world and when it came to Halloween you didn't really want to be anything too 'mainstream' and would insist on being some sort of freaky, demonic thing which Ash would be a little scared of cos he'd want to go as like a Disney character or a Ninja Turtle and he'd try and convince you to co-ordinate costumes but you'd be like "Fuck no, Irwin, this is the one time of year everyone shares my common interests; creepiness" and he'd sigh and give up and you'd be super happy and he loved seeing you happy so he even let you talk him into doing his make-up and you made him so beyond freaky he hardly recognised himself in the mirror. "I guess I'll just be Hercules next year" but he couldn't be that disappointed about it cos you were all excited and happy and giggly and that made him all happy and giggly and you would probably make-out until you had to leave for the party you were going to I can only think about that scene from iCarly where Spencer and that girl have paint on them and they're like 'you painted my mouth blue' 'you painted my mouth red' 'wanna make purple??' sorry I'm weird like that
