A Love Triangle (Jeff the KillerxreaderxTicci Toby)

Jeff is an Asshole!

It's been a few months and school is starting up again in two days.
Technically, I'm still enrolled, but nobody wants to go back to that Hell.
Jeff and Toby have been doing their own thing, murdering, but the news hasn't seen anything about me since I stabbed (y/bff/n).
They suspect I'm dead!
I guess it was fun to lay low for a while, but there comes a time when you begin to get bored of sitting around all day.
The voices in my head have been quiet for a while.
We also haven't heard anything from Toby's mom.
I'm sleeping in Toby's room, until I'm awoken by Toby walking in.
"Hey!" he greets.
"Hello. How has today's murders gone?" I ask.
"Good. Nobody made it out alive, but I'm exhausted!" he laughs.
"Where's Jeff? He hasn't been around a lot lately."
"He's out. Jeff has been a lot more melancholy than usual. I wonder what's up."
"He's been acting like that ever since we met your mom."
It's true.
He's hardly ever around and when he is home, there's always a fight.
"When he comes home, I'll ask him. I'm curious as to what could be so wrong now." I respond.
Toby sighs.
I close my eyes and think about what I can do about school.
Slender wants me to go under an alias, Moonlight Midnight, but I don't want to go back to that Hell!
He said that we'd have to dye my hair and I'd have to wear colored contacts, but I don't want to go through all that trouble if it's not going to work!
I just want to know if it would work.
If I could know, maybe I would go back.
I know Toby and Jeff can't be there, so it'll be pretty boring, but I guess I could try to become friends with (y/bff/n) again, assuming she'll fall for it.
She's not that gullible.
We'll have to restart, since I'm a "different" person.
I guess that's fine, though.
I guess I'll try it, but I'll keep a weapon on me at all times.
The faculty will never find it unless they are really looking for it.
I walk to Slender's office where he hands me the blue and black hair dye and the brown contacts. (Don't worry if you already have brown eyes! Just ignore everything with the contacts!)
Jane helps me dye my hair blue with black tips.
I pick out some clothes and prepare for the worst.
When I walk back to Toby's room, I can hear arguing.
I don't step through the door, but I just listen.
"What the hell are you doing?!?!" someone shouts.
"What am I doing? What are you doing?!?! You're taking (y/n) away from me!" someone else shouts.
"What are you talking about?!?! You haven't been home to be with her! That still doesn't answer my question, either!"
They're fighting over me again.
"Well, if you want to know so badly, I'm getting ready for her to go to sleep!"
Those words...
They're the same words as when Jeff was murdering that girl!
I stumble back in fear.
"Jeff! You can't kill her!"
"Who says I can't? It's been clear to me ever since the day we became murderers that she likes you more!"
I run into the room shouting, "I never said that!"
I leap into Jeff's arms.
"Why did you ever think I liked him more? I would've chosen him if I did. What gave you that idea?" I whisper.
"Oh, (y/n), I'm sorry, but I think it's time for you to GO TO SLEEP!" he shouts in a demonic voice.
I feel a sharp pain in my back and slump down.
"W-why?"
"You have lied to me, made me feel neglected. If you say you're sorry, I may just spare you."
"J-Jeff... I-"
"SPEAK CLEARER!" he shouts as he stabs me again.
"Jeff! Look at what you're doing!" Toby screams.
There is fear in his voice.
"Shut up!"
Jeff stabs me again, but this time, it's bloodier, I can tell.
"Time's-a-ticking!"
Just as things are beginning to go dark, I get out, "I-I'm s-sorry..."
Right before I black out completely, I can hear Jeff cry out, "It's a little late for that..."
Toby's POV
Had Jeff really just killed the love of our life?
He's crying, but he's not sad.
In fact, he keeps stabbing her until EJ and Slender walk in.
I can't control myself.
I go running to (y/n)'s side.
"Wake up! Wake up! Wake u-up..." I keep shouting until I begin to cry harder than the last time I thought she was dead.
"It's okay, Toby. Now we don't have to worry about her! She won't ever pick favorites! She can't, she's dead!" Jeff taunts.
This is just enough for me to shove him against a wall by the throat.
"YOU DON'T EVER TALK ABOUT (Y/N) LIKE THAT! SHE WAS A KIND PERSON! WE BOTH LOVED HER! NO, I LOVED HER! YOU OBVIOUSLY DIDN'T CARE SINCE YOU KILLED HER!" I shout.
He chokes as a get pulled away from him.
Slender pulls me away before I can cause any real damage to his windpipe.
"I'm sorry boys, but she's a lost cause." EJ states, forlorn.
How could he have done that?
He stabbed her, and now... sh-she's g-gone...
Your POV
I can see Toby, Jeff, Slender, EJ, and myself in Toby's room.
I can see Toby yelling at Jeff and Slender pulling him away.
Am I dead?
I guess I am because they can't hear me.
I can hear them, though.
Why did Jeff k-kill me?
I still can't accept the fact that I'm d-dead, but I know that I am.
I still have a physical form, so I guess I'm a ghost.
Slender and EJ leave the room and take Jeff with them.
Toby sits there, twitching and weeping.
Although he can't hear me or feel me, I put my hand on his shoulder and whisper into his ear, "It's okay, I'm still here. I'm not completely gone yet!"
He jerks back and shouts, "Who was that?!?!"
I gasp.
"Toby? Can you hear me? I'm still here!" I let out.
I begin to cry.
"(y/n)? I-is that you?" he asks.
"Yes! I haven't left yet! I'm right here, by your side!" I get out between cries.
"I can hear you, but you're dead! How are you speaking to me when you're lying, dead, in front of me?"
"Does it matter? We can still talk. That's all I care about!"
I embrace him.
"I-I can still feel your warmth, t-too."
He's still weeping, but I guess since he watched me die, that's expected.
He gets up and lays down on his bed.
I follow.
I hug him as we both fall asleep.