A Love Triangle (Jeff the KillerxreaderxTicci Toby)

Insanity Takes Over

a/n this music bc warning, the end of this chapter gets really depressing
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Jeff's POV
As I looked at (y/n), it seemed as if something, somewhere in her mind, snapped.
Her sanity.
She ran out the window and onto the streets, killing anyone who was in her way.
Toby and I followed (y/n) down the streets, trying to catch up with her.
She eventually ran into the forest and towards the mansion.
She slowed down enough to the point where we could catch up, but she was still fast enough to be just out of reach.
"Jeff, you could've waited to kill (y/bff/n)!"
"Shut up dickhead! I already feel guilty enough!"
She reached the mansion and burst through the doors.
We lost her until we heard screaming from a certain elf boy.
We ran to BEN's room.
Just before she could plunge her knife into his torso, I grabbed her hand and held her back.
"LET ME GO!" she shouts.
Her voice is demonic, inhuman.
This is not the (y/n) I know and love.
"LET ME GO!" she repeats.
"Never." I let out.
"I'LL JUST HAVE TO KILL YOU THEN!"
She turns around and maneuvers her hand in such a way that it ends up with my arm being stabbed.
I let go of her and she pins me down.
"WHAT, LOVERBOY? I THOUGHT YOU LOVED ME!"
I try to loosen her grip, but she's too strong.
"The only way I'd love you like this is if you mind-controlled me!"
She plunges the knife into my stomach.
"WHAT WAS THAT? I COULDN'T HEAR YOU OVER THE SOUND OF YOUR BLOOD SPLASHING EVERYWHERE!"
"You heard me!" I shout before coughing up blood.
Toby's POV
Jeff is coughing up blood.
I need to help him without killing her.
I guess there's no other way out of this...
I go behind her and throw my hatchet into her shoulder.
She cries out in pain.
"YOU DICK!"
"Come at me. It's not like you're going to win anyway. I can't feel pain, remember?"
After I said that, she pauses for a moment, but comes back to fight me.
What I said must have triggered a memory...
She charges at me, but I dodge.
"Jeff! Do you think you can hold on for a bit?"
"I'll be okay." he says.
"(y/n), do you remember the party, and how much you looked like a doll?"
She pauses for a moment, hesitates, and charges at me, once again.
This time, she's faster.
She catches my side.
I don't do anything, since I can't feel it.
"Remember sleeping at (y/bff/n)'s house, going to the arcade, coming to the mansion?"
There's a long pause before I ask, "Do you remember kissing us?"
My face heats up as I say it.
She breaks down onto her knees, holding her head.
Normal POV
I can hear Toby's voice...
Things clear up and I look down at myself.
My clothes are covered in blood.
I have a knife in my hand.
It's also very bloody.
I look up at Toby, blood pouring from his side.
I look over to Jeff, also bloody.
I can't help but cry.
Toby walks over and crouches down next to me.
"Don't cry..."
"How can I not cry? I just almost killed the two people I love! Just look at yourself Toby!" I weep.
"It's really not that bad. We'll heal! I don't want you to be sad, so please, don't cry."
"No! I hurt you. Do you remember when you said that you could've killed me if you wanted to when you first became Slender's proxy?"
"You can't mean..."
"Toby, Jeff, I want you to kill me." I state, my voice clear and firm.
Jeff sits up, holds his hand over the wound on his stomach, and walks over to me.
"Don't say that. We'll make it through this, no matter what happens. Besides, I don't think I could kill you again." he states.
"I'm serious. I don't want to hurt you! I know that if you let me live, this will happen again, and you might not survive the next time. I want you to kill me. Don't bring me back this time, either. I don't want to hurt you anymore-"
They both embrace me deeply.
"If that's really what you wish..." Toby whispers into my ear.
I can feel tears on my shoulders and realize they're both crying.
Jeff is the first to give me a kiss.
He licks my lips, asking kindly for entry.
I allow him for one final kiss.
We let go and Toby kisses me in the same way.
"Just remember, we will always love you, more than anything." Jeff states, tears streaming down his face.
"Are you ready?" Toby asks.
"I'm ready when you are." I reply.
"Ready as I'll ever be." Jeff answers.
"One more thing, leave my corpse somewhere the cops will find it. They will need to know that I died."
They both nod.
They take out their weapons as I lay down, awaiting my demise.
They slowly slit my throat at the same time.
I can feel my life draining from my body as well as my blood.
They begin to cry once more.
Jeff holds my right hand and Toby holds my left.
I can't speak, but I mouth, "I love you both." just before everything goes black.
For a few more seconds, I can hear loud cries.
I loved them both so very much and I wouldn't trade the time I spent with them for anything.
Even my last few moments of consciousness were happy, even if it was filled with sadness.
I was just happy I could spend the last few moments of my life with them.
Toby's POV
She slowly closes her eyes as she bleeds out.
(y/n) was a lovely girl.
She was a murderer, but she was like that because she was misunderstood.
I could tell she was happy.
She won't have to hurt anyone else ever again...
Though, she will forever scar my heart and Jeff's.
No matter how hard we try, we will never forget her and the things she did for us before we became creepypastas.
It's never easy to forget someone you truly loved.
I know this now, and it's too late.
I want to forget it all, but I simply can't.
(y/n) simply left to big of a mark on my heart to be forgotten.
I think Jeff feels the exact same way.

Epilogue

Jeff's POV
It's been two weeks since (y/n) died.
Toby and I carried her corpse to the side of the road where the police found her.
Relief fell on the town for a couple days until we killed someone else.
Investigators just think (y/n)'s death was a suicide, but everybody in this mansion knows what really happened.
I still don't know how we were actually able to slit her throat.
Just thinking about it makes me want to cry.
She will definitely never be forgotten.
She left a scar on my stomach that will never heal, but that's not what hurts.
What hurts is that she left a scar right on my heart.
It will always be there.
The pain will never go away.
Every time I kill someone, I will feel it.
She was there for us.
She helped us.
We had our times of laughter and our times of sadness, but the moments of true love will never be forgotten.
She marked us forever.
We will forever mourn her death.
We will always remember the lovable, kind, beautiful, special, and understanding (y/n).

The End

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
a/n I am literally crying right now! That was a WTF ending if I've ever seen one. I've been planning this ending for a few days now, but I never got into writing it. But anyway, that was the end. I hope you loved the story in all it's WTF moments!