A Love Triangle (Jeff the KillerxreaderxTicci Toby)

Revealed

I get the boys so I can talk to them.
"What's up?" Jeff asks.
"I need you two for something tonight. It won't take very long, I swear!" I plead.
"What is it?" Toby questions.
"I need you to come with me to (y/bff/n)'s house. Bring your weapons in case things go south, but don't use them unless you absolutely have to." I explain.
"Why are you going to the girl's house?"
"I need to set things completely straight between you guys, (y/bff/n), and I. I need her to understand that we're not bad people, just misunderstood. I don't want to have to hide who I am in front of her."
"(y/n), we understand, but I don't know if she will. (y/bff/n) thinks you're Moonlight Midnight, and I think it should stay that way. If she doesn't understand, then what are you going to do? Hide for the rest of your life?" Toby explains.
"If she doesn't understand, I'll kill her and end it all." I answer.
His eyes seem to widen from under his goggles.
"If you think you can, we'll go with you. I certainly don't want to be the person to kill your best friend." he states.
"Fine then. It's decided, we'll go." I state.
Later that night, we leave the mansion.
None of us talk the entire trip.
I can feel a little bit of tension between us.
We finally reach (y/bff/n)'s house.
Her parents are home, but her window is open and she's asleep.
We climb up to her window carefully and crawl in.
We all have our weapons in easy reach, just in case.
We walk slowly in the dark room.
Jeff and Toby hide somewhere while I wake up (y/bff/n).
She slowly stirs into consciousness.
"Moonlight? What are you doing here? Shouldn't you be at your house trying to sleep?" she asks.
"I need to talk to you." I state simply.
She stands up and turns on the light.
"What is it? How'd you get in anyway?"
I point to the window.
"I must've left it open on accident. I have to stop doing that! One of the murderers might get in!" she scolds to herself.
I try my best not to laugh, but it's impossible.
I break out laughing.
"Well, I need to talk to you about a certain two boys and I. You know what two boys. Jeffery Woods and Toby Rogers."
Her eyes widen.
"M-Moonlight, h-how do you kn-know about them? A-are you... (y-y/n)?" she asks, her voice shaky.
I nod.
"I'm glad you finally found out. This brings me to my next point. I want you to meet Jeff the Killer and Ticci Toby."
Toby and Jeff step out of hiding.
(y/bff/n)'s eyes widen even more.
"Wh-what do y-you want? M-my l-life?!?!"
"We just want to talk. We have no intentions of hurting you, but call anyone and we won't hesitate to attack. Listen, I don't want to hurt you, but if you call for anyone, you put my life in danger, so I have no choice. But, I digress. I just want to set things straight."
"C-continue."
"I want you to know, no matter what I do, I'm still your friend. I never want to bring you harm. I may be a murderer, but I do have some sense of friendship. I want you to be friends with these boys. They'll stay away from people I tell them not to kill."
I turn my head to Jeff and Toby to see they are nodding, and turn my head back.
"O-okay..."
"I don't want you to be scared of us."
"Wait a minute... How can I trust you? You are murders!"
She stands up and begins to get closer.
"How can I trust you after you stabbed me in the back last time-"
She goes limp as she's right in front of my face.
Jeff had stabbed her.
"Jeff! What the hell?!?! I told you not to kill her! I told you to only use your weapon if things got out of control!" I yell.
"I couldn't hold it back anymore! I had to take action!" he shouts.
She bleeds out quickly because she's on blood thinners and Jeff took the weapon from her body.
At this point, I lose control.
All I can remember is everything going black.