Is it Safe to go Back?

Red Robin?//Chapter 17

*Anna's POV*

I ran upstairs and put on my strappy high heel sandals and checked the mirror. The sandals made me at least two inches taller, my black skinny jeans were perfect, and my strapless maroon top was all messed up.

"That's what you get for having a shirtless make out session in the kitchen!" I said to myself as I fixed the shirt. I touched up my hair which was already curled, added a little more makeup, sprayed on some perfume and ran downstairs to a very impatient Isabel.

"Let's go, we don't want to make Mom and Dad wait!" Isabel said looking me up and down before turning around and walking out to her car. She started the car and pulled out of the driveway, we got to the end of our road and she turned left instead of right. Going in the opposite direction of Red robin.

"Where are we going?" I ask fidgeting anxiously with my ring, she didn't answer me she just kept driving not even looking at me. "Where are we going?" I ask again, and she doesn't answer me, again. "Isabel! Where are we going!? This is not the way to Red Robin!" Again she doesn't answer me. Finally I pull my phone out and text my mom,

Anna- Hey are Isabel and I supposed to be meeting you and Dad at Red Robin for a family dinner tonight?

Mom- Umm no I'm still at work, why?

Anna- She told me we were going to meet you and Dad for dinner but she is going in the opposite direction of Red Robin... Getting a little wor... before I could finish typing Isabel pulled over to the side of the road and grabbed my phone from me.

"No way, you actually did join the gang on purpose? You weren't forced were you?!" I screamed at her furious that my own sister would kidnap me.

"Look, my name isn't Isabel and I'm not your sister!" she shouted at me, "my name is Carrie and Isabel is still being held captive by the gang." I sat in shock, I couldn't move or say anything, I couldn't believe it, my sister was alive but she was still being held captive by the gang? And this woman had been living in my house pretending to be my sister, going to the Fall Out Boy and Black Veil Brides concert with me, and she's seen Dominic and I kiss. Wait! Oh god, no please no. She saw Dominic and I in the kitchen earlier... Wait, I thought the gang was only Alexander, Elijah, and that one boy Lucas? This is getting too confusing but then everything in my life is. Seeing that I wasn't going to say anything else Carrie started driving again. Even though I wanted to ask her about the gang I couldn't find the strength to talk, so I just sat back and watched out the window to see where we were going. After all I've been through they couldn't do anything to me that could hurt me, even if they killed me maybe that would just be better. Ideas ran through my mind on how to ask her about the gang, but I was too scared to ask. We pulled up to an abandoned building that looked like a school. When she stopped the car she got out and walked around to the back, getting something out of the trunk. I just sat there, frozen, I couldn't move. She opened the door again grabbing her purse and some extra stuff.

"Come on, we are already running late. Don't worry they won't kill you." She said before she started walking off. I thought I heard her say something else but I couldn't tell what it was. I sat there watching her walk off, does she really think I'm that dumb? I would just follow her into an abandoned building where death is guaranteed? I know I'm smarter than to follow her but what if my real sister is in there? Or if Isabel is in trouble? I got out of the car and followed her into the old school where they were probably already planning where to hide my body.

When we walked in the building was extremely quiet, I could even hear the sounds of the mice as they ran across the hall from one side to the other. She led me to what I guess was the old cafeteria and as we got closer the smell of food got stronger. The aroma was so wonderful it made my mouth water. We sat down at a table in the far right corner. There was steak, potato salad, and coconut cake already set up.

"You can go ahead and start eating." She said as she took a bite of her steak. I picked up the silverware and started to take tiny bites. I slowly picked at my food while she gorged everything in sight. I continued to eat and the more I ate the hungrier I got. When I finished eating I sat back in my chair. Now I was extremely tired, I think I ate too much, and everything is going black...

Carries POV

Once she was asleep I called Nolan to let him know I was ready. He sent Rick out to help me carry her body out of the old school. As I sat and waited I tried to figure out what position she could fill that Nolan would let her do instead of killing her. I was just starting to like this girl, I don't want to see her die. I just hope that boy of hers is smart enough to not try and come save her this time. I would hate to see a cute boy like him die. When Rick showed up he picked Anna up and carried her to my car, he set her in the backseat and gave me the address of where to go.

"See you later" he said as we both started driving.