Supernatural preferences

Things he appriciates

(Not mine)

Dean
Dean likes to relax with you. He likes to have you as an escape from hunting and his main life. When he has you wrapped in his arms with his head resting on yours he can pretend he's normal, and he can be happy.

Sam
Sam would like you to do things with him. He'd like it when you helped him with research because he loved the expressions you made when you were reading. He'd like the evenings that you spent along together, almost falling asleep after going through endless pages of old lore. When you were too tired to continue, Sam would insist on carrying you to bed, laying you down gently and then laying down beside you.

Cas
Cas would appreciate the moments you spent together doing normal human things. He liked when you introduced him to new things. He loved when you'd become obsessed with something and wouldn't stop talking about it. He would think that was adorable.

Crowley
Crowley would like showing off to you. He'd like to take you out to dinner anywhere in the world and treat you like a queen. He'd also appreciate the simpler times however. The times when you were lying in bed together. Maybe you were trying to annoy him or the other way around. The times when you could just be beings together and feel happy.

Gabriel
Gabriel would appreciate when you made an effort for him. He'd appreciate if you made the first move or suggested something that he would usually suggest like watching movies and eating sweets or baking. He'd love that you actually liked the same things as him. It would make him feel more comfortable and that he didn't have to substitute anything with his tricks.

Lucifer
Luci would appreciate when you shared your opinion. He was used to people being too scared of him to say anything against him so when you share your opinion with him it shows that you're not scared of him. With you, that's a good thing.

Balthazar
Balthazar would appreciate when you showed him parts of your life. He'd like meeting your family and being shown things from your childhood. He'd find some things incredibly funny but despite the sarcastic comments and general air of boredom, he really was happy that you liked him enough to show him your life