13 Reasons Why & Riverdale Preferences

First 'I love you'

Clay: Plain and simple.
'I love you Clay'
'I love you too Y/N'

Justin: He isn't good with his emotions so kept it bottled up for a while until he told you.
'Y/N, I need to tell you this before my brain tells me to shut up again. I love you.'
'I love you too Justin'

Zach: He was so sweet when he told you, he went all out, bought you chocolate, flowers and then simply told you.
'I love you Y/N'
'I love you too Zach'
*kiss*

Alex: You had to tell him first because he was kind of afraid of rejection.
'I love you Alex'
'I-I love you too Y/N'

Marcus: He just blurted it out at one point.
'Y/N. I love you.'
'I know. I love you too.'

Montgomery: Short and blunt.
'I love you Monty'
'I love you too'

Tyler: It was during a photoshoot and he just kind of said it.
*poses a few times*
'God I love you Y/N'
'I love you too'

Ryan: He wrote the cheesiest poem and read it to you.
'Roses are red,
Violets are blue,
Sugar is sweet,
And I love you'
'I love you too Ryan'

Jeff: He made a grand gesture. He got the baseball team to hold up cards that spelt out 'I love you Y/N' at the end of a game.
*end of the game, boys run in line*
'I've been wanting to say this for a while, but I wanted to do it in an unconventional way, so-'
*boys turn cards*
'I love you Y/N'
'I love you too Jeff!'

Tony: He made you a mixed tape and at the end was a recording of him saying it.
'Just listen to it Y/N'
'Ok.Ok.'
*listening to recording*
'I love you Y/N'
*gasps*
'I love you too'