Secret // Ticci Toby x Reader

Chpt 10: Caught

----------3:30pm----------

Toby's P.O.V
With nothing to do, me and (Y/N) lay on the couch, arms wrapped around eachother. As I gently caress her hair, she sighs softly, looking up at me. "What do you want to do..?" "I don't know. Wanna go out for a bit?" she thinks for a moment "... But what about our relationship remaining a secret? Won't going out together just give it away?" "... I don't take my mouthgard or goggles off that much back at the mansion so I don't think anyone would recognise me." "Mmn... But what about the gash on your cheek? That's a dead giveaway since I highly doubt that many people have that. And plus, it'll make you stand out." I sigh, now running my fingers through her (H/C) hair. "Yeah, I guess you're right." "You guess? I AM right." she giggles softly, moving a little closer to me. "... Maybe we could go to the forest? I have my hatchets in case anything happens. I can also always threaten anyone if they catch us and try to tell Slenderman about our relationship." it takes her a moment to respond as she thinks about what to say. She opens her mouth "Alright. We can go to the forest."

----------4:00pm---------

As we walk around the forest, I take hold of (Y/N)'s hand, stuffing my free hand in my pocket. My hatchets hang at my sides right where they should be and I take a deep breath, enjoying the time I was spending with (Y/N). Sure, what we were doing was risky, but it's better than staying at her place with nothing to do for the next few hours. I feel something wrap around my arm and I look to see (Y/N) hugging it, quietly humming a tune. A smile forms on my lips and I look around us, making sure that no one else is around. When I look behind us, I see a familiar figure in a certain mask. My heart skips a beat as I realize who it is - Masky. Quickly, I gently remove (Y/N) from my arm and move her behind me. Masky walks toward us, hands in his pockets. Once he's right in front of us, he stops walking and silently stares at me for a minute before proceeding to speak.

Masky's P.O.V
'Why the hell is Toby out here? I thought he told Slender that he was going to go get himself a few drinks. But more importantly... Why is he walking around with this girl?' I wonder about this and stare at him, trying to piece every thing together. "Toby. I thought you told the boss that you were getting yourself a few drinks? I don't see any drinks on you nor do I hear any police sirens in the distance." I say, not taking my eyes off the male in front of me. It takes a few seconds for Toby to respond but when he does, he twitches. "I ch-changed my mind on the drinks, I mean, I did have at least two bottles of alcohol last week.." "Okay... Why do you have this girl with you?" Toby freezes and I know that he doesn't have a good lie to cover that up. I smirk, though it isn't visible under my mask. "... I knew it. You're secretly dating her, aren't you? You do know that is against Slender's rules, right?" "Masky... P-Please don't tell him.. I-I'll make you a ginormous cheesecake..!" "How? You can't be trusted to bake. Hell, you can't even be trusted to work in the kitchen; with your love for fire and shit." he remains silent as he listens, the girl behind him clinging to his arm. "Listen, if you steal me a few packs of cigarettes from the store AND steal me a new gun, I won't tell Slender about your relationship. Deal?" I lift my mask a little until my mouth is visible and take a pack of cigarettes out from pocket, opening it only to find one last smoke. I take it out from the pack and toss the now-empty box onto the ground, taking out my lighter afterwards. Once the cigarette is lit, I put my lighter back in my pocket and inhale, allowing the smoke to fill my lungs. "Also, I need a new lighter." "Fine." "Alright. How about we take your little girlfriend back to her home and go collect everything I want now?" he glances at his girlfriend who nods then looks back at me. "Alright." "Great, let's go then." and with everything decided, Toby begins to lead the way, his girlfriend following behind.

(Y/N)'s P.O.V
As we walk, I can't help but to feel frightened, taking hold of Toby's hand. "Um.. Toby? Who is he?" I ask as I look over at the masked male walking beside us. "He's Masky; another proxy who's working for Slenderman." "How many proxies does he have?" "Three. Me, Masky, and Hoodie." "Oh.." nodding my head, I glance over at Masky again to which he nods his head a little, greeting me. "Nice to meet you. I honestly found it surprising when I figured out that you and Toby were dating.. I mean, he's annoying as hell and even with all of his rapid mood swings... How do you deal with that?" "It's nice to meet you too. And mood swings? What are you talking about?" Masky tosses his cigarette onto the ground and stomps on it, looking at me once again when he's finished. "Toby has Bipolar Disorder. He also has schizophrenia, Tourettes, PTSD, Anxiety, A.D.H.D, and Congenital Insensitivity to Pain or C.I.P.A" my eyes widen slightly as I hear all of this and Toby stops walking. Curious as to why he suddenly stopped, Toby lets go of my hand and turns around to glare at Masky "Shutup you masked freak. I was going to tell her myself." "And behold, one of his mood swings-!" Masky says, gesturing to Toby. Just then, he is tackled to the ground. "What the FUCK!!? GET OFF OF ME YOU ASSHOLE!!" Masky shouts and I groan in frustration. Taking a deep breath, I shout at both of them "BOTH OF YOU STOP IT RIGHT NOW! NOW IS NOT THE TIME TO BE FIGHTING GOD DAMN IT!" the two boys stopped fighting and looked at me with wide eyes, surprised at my anger. I huff, crossing my arms over my chest as Toby slowly, but hesitantly gets off of Masky. "Jesus. You two are just like children who want the same toy." "Sorry..." they both mumble.

Once we arrive at my place, I open the door and walk inside, sighing softly. "Well, it was nice to meet you, Masky." "... Tim. My name's Tim but everyone calls me Masky. Anyways, it was nice meeting you too." we shake hands and once we let go, Toby leans in for a kiss. Before we could kiss, however, I place my hand over his mouth "I'm still a little frustrated that you and Masky started fighting back at the forest. However, if you apologise for starting the fight..." a annoyed groan leaves Toby's lips and I smirk when he turns to Masky, sighing before he speaks "... Sorry." though he doesn't sound very apologetic, that's enough for me so I turn him back towards me and wrap my arms around his neck, leaning in for a kiss. The kiss only lasts a second but it's enough to cause Masky to clear his throat. Once I let go of Toby, I smile at both of them. "Alright then, see you two. Please don't murder eachother.." "We'll try not to, but his safety is not guaranteed." Toby mutters as he puts on his mouthgard and goggles. Once they leave, I lock the door and make my way up to my room.