Toby's P.O.V
Once we leave the house, me and Timothy - or should I say Masky, head into a dark alleyway to hide until there are no people in the area. As we wait, the bastard begins to talk to me "...Quite the woman you found. I never expected that such a woman would want to date you." "Tch. You better not go crushing on my girlfriend now or else you're dead meat." "Alright, alright. Calm down, Mr. Crabby pants. Besides, even if I did have a crush on her, I highly doubt that you'd be strong enough to kill me." already getting annoyed with him, I take a peek at the street and luckily for us, no one is around. Stepping out of the alleyway, both me and Masky take a minute before barging into a convenience store. Masky has his gun pointed at the cashier and the cashier freezes, putting his hands up in the air. I quickly grab a few packs of cigarettes and stuff them in my pockets. "Please don't kill me! I won't tell anyone, take anything you want!!" "... That's what you all say. Rogers, take him out." Masky says and I nod my head, taking hold of my hatchets and swinging at the man. His blood splatters the walls as his head rolls on the ground, his body falling next to it. Once he's dead, me and Masky rush to destroy all evidence - including footage of the whole thing. Once that's done, I quickly grab a lighter before we both rush out of the store, running off to our next destination.
Once we arrive at a shop full of hunting supplies, we are lucky to see that no one else is there besides the cashier. The man is terrified as he stares at us. Masky begins looking for a new gun while I keep the man in place, ready to kill if needed. Once Masky finds a gun, he decides to test it out on the cashier. The man falls to the floor with blood pooling around him. Satisfied with his find, Masky slips the gun in his pocket and I go to destroy the evidence.
Finally finished with everything, I hand the cigarettes over to Masky along with the lighter and he leaves. I begin to head back to (Y/N)'s home, blood splatters on my hoodie.
When I arrive, I knock on the door several times and wait for her to open the door. As soon as she does, I quickly slip inside the house, closing the door behind me and locking it. Once the door is locked, I remove my goggles and mouthgard, placing them on the table. When she notices the blood, (Y/N) begins to freak out "What the hell did you do?! I thought that you were just going to steal Tim some things?!" "I did, but we couldn't leave behind any witnesses. If we let the cashier's live, they would have told the police how we looked, no shit about it." I twitch and she sighs, taking a moment to calm down a little. "... Remove your hoodie. I'm going to wash it before the... Blood stains it." I do as she says and remove my hoodie to which she takes it and looks at me with a serious look in her eyes. "You're washing your hatchets. There's no way I'm gong to wash them." "Alright. Are you mad?" "... No. I'm just... A little surprised, that's all. I mean, I already know that you kill so I knew that this day would happen eventually."
(Y/N)'s P.O.V
Toby sighs in relief once I say this and kisses my cheek. "I'm sorry." "Don't be. I just gotta get used to this, that's all." in an attempt to comfort him, I smile and place a quick kiss on his lips.
Once the laundry is done and his hatchets have been cleaned, I decide to relax and lay on the couch, closing my eyes. "I love you." I hear Toby say and I open my eyes, only to see him looking down at me as he leans on the back of the couch. "I love you too." we both smile.
Around midnight, I stand up from the couch and stretch, yawning. "Tired?" Toby is sitting on an armchair, watching a random movie he found on Netflix. "Yeah. I think I'm going to bed, now." "Alright. Well, I guess I gotta start heading back to the mansion or else Slender will start getting suspicious." He stands up as well and walks towards me, kissing my forehead once he stops in front of me. "Oh.. Okay. I'll miss you." "I'll miss you too. I'll try to visit in a few days, alright?" "Okay."
And with that, Toby throws on his goggles and mouthgard, placing his hatchets on his belt afterwards. He then leaves the house, shutting the door behind him. Once he's gone, I walk up to my room and go to bed.
YOU ARE READING
Secret // Ticci Toby x Reader
Fanfiction"In order to make sure that the creepypasta's do their best at their jobs, Slenderman has one rule. You can't fall in love or be in a relationship... But what happens when Toby Rogers falls for his victim..?" This is my first fanfic so feel free to...
